Ath。But,mydearfriend,letusdistinguishbetweendifferentcases,andnotbehastyinformingajudgment:Onewayofconsideringthequestionwillbetoimagineafestivalatwhichthereareentertainmentsofallsorts,includinggymnastic,musical,andequestriancontests:thecitizensareassembled;prizesareoffered,andproclamationismadethatanyonewholikesmayenterthelists,andthatheistobearthepalmwhogivesthemostpleasuretothespectators-thereistobenoregulationaboutthemannerhow;
buthewhoismostsuccessfulingivingpleasureistobecrownedvictor,anddeemedtobethepleasantestofthecandidates:Whatislikelytobetheresultofsuchaproclamation?
Cle。Inwhatrespect?
Ath。Therewouldbevariousexhibitions:oneman,likeHomer,willexhibitarhapsody,anotheraperformanceonthelute;onewillhaveatragedy,andanotheracomedy。Norwouldtherebeanythingastonishinginsomeoneimaginingthathecouldgaintheprizebyexhibitingapuppet-show。Supposethesecompetitorstomeet,andnottheseonly,butinnumerableothersaswellcanyoutellmewhooughttobethevictor?
Cle。Idonotseehowanyonecanansweryou,orpretendtoknow,unlesshehasheardwithhisownearstheseveralcompetitors;thequestionisabsurd。