Methods of Ethics

第36章

试读中

第36章

Methods of Ethics Henry Sidgwick

后面的故事,去 App 接着看,下载后搜索书名即可继续阅读。

Methods of Ethics
阅读主题
字体大小

  WisdomwasalwaysplacedbytheGreekphilosophersfirstinthelistofvirtues,andregardedasinamannercomprehendingalltheothers:infactinthepost-AristotelianschoolsthenotionoftheSageorideallyWisemansophoswasregularlyemployedtoexhibitinaconcreteformtherulesoflifelaiddownbyeachsystem。IncommonGreekusage,however,thetermjustmentionedwouldsignifyexcellenceinpurelyspeculativescience,nolessthanpracticalwisdom:andtheEnglishtermWisdomhas,tosomeextent,thesameambiguity。

  Itis,however,chieflyusedinreferencetopractice:andevenwhenappliedtotheregionofpurespeculationsuggestsespeciallysuchintellectualgiftsandhabitsasleadtosoundpracticalconclusions:namely,comprehensivenessofview,thehabitofattendingimpartiallytoanumberofdiverseconsiderationsdifficulttoestimateexactly,andgoodjudgmentastotherelativeimportanceofeach。Atanyrate,itisonlyPracticalWisdomwhichwecommonlyclassamongVirtues,asdistinguishedfrompurelyintellectualexcellences。HowthenshallwedefinePracticalWisdom?Themostobviouspartofitsmeaningisatendencytodiscern,intheconductoflifegenerally,thebestmeanstotheattainmentofanyendsthatthenaturalplayofhumanmotivesmayleadustoseek。ascontrastedwithtechnicalskill,orthefacultyofselectingthebestmeanstogivenendsinacertainlimitedandspecialdepartmentofhumanaction。Suchskillinthespecialartsispartlycommunicablebymeansofdefiniterules,andpartlyamatteroftactorinstinct,dependingsomewhatonnaturalgiftsandpredispositions,buttoagreatextentacquiredbyexerciseandimitation;andsimilarlypracticalWisdom,ifunderstoodtobeSkillintheArtofLife,wouldinvolveacertainamountofscientificknowledge,theportionsofdifferentsciencesbearingdirectlyonhumanaction,togetherwithempiricalrulesrelatingtothesamesubject-matter;

  andalsothetactortrainedinstinctjustmentioned,whichwouldevenbemoreprominenthere,onaccountoftheextremecomplexityofthesubject-matter。

  Butitdoesnotappearfromthisanalysiswhythisskillshouldberegardedasavirtue:andreflectionwillshowthatwedonotordinarilymeanbywisdommerelythefacultyoffindingthebestmeanstoanyends:forweshouldnotcallthemostaccomplishedswindlerwise;whereasweshouldnothesitatetoattributetohimcleverness,ingenuity,andotherpurelyintellectualexcellences。Soagainweapplytheterm``worldly-wise’’toamanwhoskilfullychoosesthebestmeanstotheendofambition;butweshouldnotcallsuchaman`wise’withoutqualification。Wisdom,inshort,appearstometoimplyrightjudgmentinrespectofendsaswellasmeans。

  Here,however,asubtlequestionarises。Fortheassumptiononwhichthistreatiseproceedsisthatthereareseveralultimateendsofaction,whichallclaimtoberationalends,suchaseverymanoughttoadopt。Hence,ifWisdomimpliesrightjudgmentastoends,itisclearthatapersonwhoregardssomeoneendasthesolerightorrationalultimateendwillnotconsideramanwisewhoadoptsanyotherultimateend。CanwesaythenthatinthecommonuseofthewordWisdomanyoneultimateendisdistinctlyimpliedtotheexclusionofothers?Itmaybesuggested,perhaps,thatinthemoralviewofCommonSensewhichwearenowtryingtomakeclear,sinceWisdomitselfisprescribedorcommendedasaqualityofconductintuitivelydiscernedtoberightorgood,theultimateendwhichthewisemanprefersmustbejustthisattainmentofrightnessorgoodnessinconductgenerally;ratherthanpleasureforhimselforothers,oranyotherulteriorend。Ithink,however,thatinthecaseofthisnotionitisimpossibletocarryoutthatanalysisofordinarypracticalreasoningintoseveraldistinctmethods,eachadmittingandneedingseparatedevelopment,uponwhichtheplanofthistreatiseisfounded。

后续内容在 App 继续看

精彩内容未完,打开 App 继续阅读

后面的故事已为你准备好,下载 App 后搜索“Methods of Ethics”即可继续阅读这一章。