Butbesidesthequestionofthewriter,thereareotherpointstonoticewhichcommonsuperstitionforbidsthemultitudetoapprehend。3Ofthesethechiefis,thatEzrawhomIwilltaketobetheauthoroftheaforesaidbooksuntilsomemorelikelypersonbesuggesteddidnotputthefinishingtouchestothenarrativecontainedtherein,butmerelycollectedthehistoriesfromvariouswriters,andsometimessimplysetthemdown,leavingtheirexaminationandarrangementtoposterity。
4Thecauseifitwerenotuntimelydeathwhichpreventedhimfromcompletinghisworkinallitsportions,Icannotconjecture,butthefactremainsmostclear,althoughwehavelostthewritingsoftheancientHebrewhistorians,andcanonlyjudgefromthefewfragmentswhicharestillextant。5ForthehistoryofHezekiah2Kingsxviii:17
aswritteninthevisionofIsaiah,isrelatedasitisfoundinthechroniclesofthekingsofJudah。6Wereadthesamestory,toldwithfewexceptions,[Endnote11],inthesamewords,inthebookofIsaiahwhichwascontainedinthechroniclesofthekingsofJudah2Chron。xxxii:32。7FromthiswemustconcludethattherewerevariousversionsofthisnarrativeofIsaiah\'s,unless,indeed,anyonewoulddreamthatinthis,too,therelurksamystery。8Further,thelastchapterof2Kings27-30isrepeatedinthelastchapterofJeremiah,v。31-34。
9Again,wefind2Sam。vii。repeatedinIChron。xvii。,buttheexpressionsinthetwopassagesaresocuriouslyvaried[Endnote12],thatwecanveryeasilyseethatthesetwochaptersweretakenfromtwodifferentversionsofthehistoryofNathan。
10Lastly,thegenealogyofthekingsofIdumaeacontainedinGenesisxxxvi:31,isrepeatedinthesamewordsin1Chron。i。,thoughweknowthattheauthorofthelatterworktookhismaterialsfromotherhistorians,notfromthetwelvebookswehaveascribedtoEzra。10Wemaythereforebesurethatifwestillpossessedthewritingsofthehistorians,thematterwouldbemadeclear;however,aswehavelostthem,wecanonlyexaminethewritingsstillextant,andfromtheirorderandconnection,theirvariousrepetitions,and,lastly,thecontradictionsindateswhichtheycontain,judgeoftherest。