122Ihavebrieflyshownthatsuchknowledgeisnecessary,butIpassedovercertainconsiderationswhichIwillnowdrawattentionto。
123Ifwereadabookwhichcontainsincredibleorimpossiblenarratives,oriswritteninaveryobscurestyle,andifweknownothingofitsauthor,norofthetimeoroccasionofitsbeingwritten,weshallvainlyendeavourtogainanycertainknowledgeofitstruemeaning。124Forbeinginignoranceonthesepointswecannotpossiblyknowtheaimorintendedaimoftheauthor;ifwearefullyinformed,wesoorderourthoughtsasnottobeinanywayprejudicedeitherinascribingtotheauthororhimforwhomtheauthorwroteeithermoreorlessthanhismeaning,andweonlytakeintoconsiderationwhattheauthormayhavehadinhismind,orwhatthetimeandoccasiondemanded。125Ithinkthismustbetolerablyevidenttoall。
126Itoftenhappensthatindifferentbookswereadhistoriesinthemselvessimilar,butwhichwejudgeverydifferently,accordingtotheopinionswehaveformedoftheauthors。127IrememberoncetohavereadinsomebookthatamannamedOrlandoFuriosousedtodriveakindofwingedmonsterthroughtheair,flyoveranycountriesheliked,killunaidedvastnumbersofmenandgiants,andsuchlikefancies,whichfromthepointofviewofreasonareobviouslyabsurd。128AverysimilarstoryIreadinOvidofPerseus,andalsointhebooksofJudgesandKingsofSamson,whoaloneandunarmedkilledthousandsofmen,andofElijah,whoflewthroughtheair,saidatlastwentuptoheaveninachariotoffire,withhorsesoffire。129Allthesestoriesareobviouslyalike,butwejudgethemverydifferently。130Thefirstonlysoughttoamuse,thesecondhadapoliticalobject,thethirdareligiousobject。131Wegatherthissimplyfromtheopinionswehadpreviouslyformedoftheauthors。132Thusitisevidentlynecessarytoknowsomethingoftheauthorsofwritingswhichareobscureorunintelligible,ifwewouldinterprettheirmeaning;andforthesamereason,inordertochoosetheproperreadingfromamongagreatvariety,weoughttohaveinformationastotheversionsinwhichthedifferencesarefound,andastothepossibilityofotherreadingshavingbeendiscoveredbypersonsofgreaterauthority。
133AfurtherdifficultyattendsthismethodinthecaseofsomeofthebooksofScripture,namely,thattheyarenolongerextantintheiroriginallanguage。133TheGospelaccordingtoMatthew,andcertainlytheEpistletotheHebrews,werewritten,itisthought,inHebrew,thoughtheynolongerexistinthatform。134AbenEzraaffirmsinhiscommentariesthatthebookofJobwastranslatedintoHebrewoutofanotherlanguage,andthatitsobscurityarisesfromthisfact。135Isaynothingoftheapocryphalbooks,fortheirauthoritystandsonveryinferiorground。
136TheforegoingdifficultiesinthismethodofinterpretingScripturefromitsownhistory,IconceivetobesogreatthatIdonothesitatetosaythatthetruemeaningofScriptureisinmanyplacesinexplicable,oratbestmeresubjectforguesswork;butImustagainpointout,ontheotherhand,thatsuchdifficultiesonlyarisewhenweendeavourtofollowthemeaningofaprophetinmatterswhichcannotbeperceived,butonlyimagined,notinthings,whereoftheunderstandingcangiveaclearidea,andwhichareconceivablethroughthemselves:,[Endnote8],matterswhichbytheirnatureareeasilyperceivedcannotbeexpressedsoobscurelyastobeunintelligible;astheproverbsays,\"awordisenoughtothewise。\"137