VIII。TherearesomewhothereforeimagineMonarchytobeemoregrievousthenDemocraty,becausethereislesselibertyinthat,theninthis。IfbylibertytheymeananexemptionfromthatsubjectionwhichisduetotheLawes(i。e。)thecommandsofthePeople,neitherinDemocraty,norinanyotherstateofgovernmentwhatsoever,isthereanysuchkindofliberty。Iftheysupposelibertytoconsistinthis,thattherebefewlawes,fewprohibitions,andthosetoosuch,thatexcepttheywereforbidden,therecouldbenoPeace;thenIdenythatthereismorelibertyinDemocratythenMonarchy;fortheoneastrulyconsistethwithsuchaliberty,astheother。Foralthoughthewordliberty,mayinlarge,andamplelettersbewrittenoverthegatesofanyCitywhatsoever,yetisitnotmeanttheSubjects,buttheCitiesliberty,neithercanthatwordwithbetterRightbeinscribedonaCitywhichisgoverned。bythepeople,thenthatwhichisruledbyaMonarch。Butwhenprivatemenorsubjectsdemandliberty,underthenameofliberty,theyasknotforliberty,butdominion,whichyetforwantofunderstanding,theylittleconsider;forifeverymanwouldgrantthesamelibertytoanother,whichhedesiresforhimselfe,asiscommandedbythelawofnature,thatsamenaturallstatewouldreturnagain,inwhichallmenmaybyRightdoeallthings,whichiftheyknew,theywouldabhor,asbeingworsethenallkindofcivillsubjectionwhatsoever。Butifanymandesiretohavehissinglefreedome,therestbeingbound,whatdoesheelsedemandbuttohavetheDominion?forwhosoisfreedfromallbonds,isLordoverallthosethatstillcontinuebound。SubjectsthereforehavenogreaterlibertyinaPopular,theninaMonarchicallState。Thatwhichdeceivesthem,istheequallparticipationofcommand,andpubliqueplaces;forwheretheauthorityisinthePeople,singlesubjectsdoesofarforthshareinitastheyarepartsofthePeopleruling;andtheyequallypartakeinpubliqueOfficessofarforthastheyhaveequallvoicesinchoosingMagistrates,andpubliqueMinisters。AndthisisthatwhichAristotleaim’dat,himselfalso,throughthecustomeofthattime,mis-callingDominionliberty,inhissixthBook,andsecondChapterofPolitiques。InapopularStatethereislibertybysupposition;whichisaspeechofthevulgar,asifnomanwerefreeoutofthisState。Fromwhence,bytheway,wemaycollect,ThatthoseSubjects,whoinaMonarchydeploretheirlostliberty,doeonelystomackthis,thattheyarenotreceiv’dtothesteerageoftheCommon-weal。
IX。Butperhapsforthisveryreasonsomewillsay,ThataPopularStateismuchtobepreferr’dbeforeaMonarchicall。
becausethat,whereallmenhaveahandinpubliquebusinesses,’thereallhaveanopportunitytoshewtheirwisedome,knowledge,andeloquence,indeliberatingmattersofthegreatestdifficultyandmoment;whichbyreasonofthatdesireofpraisewhichisbredinhumanenature,istothemwhoexcellinsuchlikefaculties,andseemetothemselvestoexceedothers,themostdelightfullofallthings。ButinaMonarchy,thissamewaytoobtainpraise,andhonour,isshutuptothegreatestpartofSubjects;andwhatisagrievance,ifthisbenone?Iletellyou:
Toseehisopinionwhomwescorne,preferr’dbeforeours;tohaveourwisedomeundervaluedbeforeourownfaces;byanuncertaintryallofalittlevaineglory,toundergoemostcertaineenmities(forthiscannotbeavoided,whetherwehavethebetter,ortheworse);tohate,andtobehated,byreasonofthedisagreementofopinions;tolayopenoursecretCounsells,andadvisestoall,tonopurpose,andwithoutanybenefit;toneglecttheaffairesofourownFamily:These,Isay,aregrievances。Buttobeabsentfromatriallofwits,althoughthosetriallsarepleasanttotheEloquent,isnotthereforeagrievancetothem,unlessewewillsay,thatitisagrievancetovaliantmentoberestrainedfromfighting,becausetheydelightinit。
X。Besides,therearemanyreasonswhydeliberationsarelessesuccessefullingreatAssemblies,theninlesserCouncells;