HeteronomyoftheWillastheSourceofallspuriousPrinciplesofMoralityIfthewillseeksthelawwhichistodetermineitanywhereelsethaninthefitnessofitsmaximstobeuniversallawsofitsowndictation,consequentlyifitgoesoutofitselfandseeksthislawinthecharacterofanyofitsobjects,therealwaysresultsheteronomy。Thewillinthatcasedoesnotgiveitselfthelaw,butitisgivenbytheobjectthroughitsrelationtothewill。Thisrelation,whetheritrestsoninclinationoronconceptionsofreason,onlyadmitsofhypotheticalimperatives:\"IoughttodosomethingbecauseIwishforsomethingelse。\"Onthecontrary,themoral,andthereforecategorical,imperativesays:\"Ioughttodosoandso,eventhoughIshouldnotwishforanythingelse。\"E。g。,theformersays:\"I
oughtnottolie,ifIwouldretainmyreputation\";thelattersays:
\"Ioughtnottolie,althoughitshouldnotbringmetheleastdiscredit。\"Thelatterthereforemustsofarabstractfromallobjectsthattheyshallhavenoinfluenceonthewill,inorderthatpracticalreason(will)maynotberestrictedtoadministeringaninterestnotbelongingtoit,butmaysimplyshowitsowncommandingauthorityasthesupremelegislation。Thus,e。g。,Ioughttoendeavourtopromotethehappinessofothers,notasifitsrealizationinvolvedanyconcernofmine(whetherbyimmediateinclinationorbyanysatisfactionindirectlygainedthroughreason),butsimplybecauseamaximwhichexcludesitcannotbecomprehendedasauniversallawinoneandthesamevolition。
ClassificationofallPrinciplesofMoralitywhichcanbefoundedontheConceptionofHeteronomyHereaselsewherehumanreasoninitspureuse,solongasitwasnotcriticallyexamined,hasfirsttriedallpossiblewrongwaysbeforeitsucceededinfindingtheonetrueway。
Allprincipleswhichcanbetakenfromthispointofviewareeitherempiricalorrational。Theformer,drawnfromtheprincipleofhappiness,arebuiltonphysicalormoralfeelings;thelatter,drawnfromtheprincipleofperfection,arebuilteitherontherationalconceptionofperfectionasapossibleeffect,oronthatofanindependentperfection(thewillofGod)asthedeterminingcauseofourwill。