butinordertoansweritwerequireawholelogicalandpsychologicalapparatus。
Benthamshowsthisapparatusatwork,butdoesnotexpounditsorigininanyseparatetreatise。Enoughinformation,however,isgivenastohismethodinthecuriouscollectionofthefragmentsconnectedwiththeChrestomathia。
Alogicalmethoduponwhichheconstantlyinsistedisthatof’bipartition,’16*
calledalsothe’dichotomous’or’bifurcate’method,andexemplifiedbythestalled’PorphyrianTree。’Theprincipleis,ofcourse,simple。Takeanygenus:divideitintotwoclasses,oneofwhichhasandtheotherhasnotacertainmark。Thetwoclassesmustbemutuallyexclusiveandtogetherexhaustive。
Repeattheoperationuponeachoftheclassesandcontinuetheprocessaslongasdesired。17*Ateverystepyouthushaveacompleteenumerationofallthespecies,varieties,andsoon,eachofwhichexcludesalltheothers。Nomerelogic,indeed,cansecuretheaccuracyandstilllesstheutilityoftheprocedure。Thedifferencesmaybeinthemselvesambiguousorirrelevant。IfIclassifyplantsas’trees’and’nottrees,’thelogicalformissatisfied:butIhavestilltoaskwhether’tree’conveysadeterminatemeaning,andwhetherthedistinctioncorrespondstoadifferenceofanyimportance。