Nomancanbecompletely,oreventolerablysatisfied,withhavingavoidedeverythingblame-worthyinhisconduct;unlesshehaslikewiseavoidedtheblameorthereproach。Awisemanmayfrequentlyneglectpraise,evenwhenhehasbestdeservedit;
but,inallmattersofseriousconsequence,hewillmostcarefullyendeavoursotoregulatehisconductastoavoid,notonlyblame-worthiness,but,asmuchaspossible,everyprobableimputationofblame。Hewillnever,indeed,avoidblamebydoinganythingwhichhejudgesblame-worthy;byomittinganypartofhisduty,orbyneglectinganyopportunityofdoinganythingwhichhejudgestobereallyandgreatlypraise-worthy。But,withthesemodifications,hewillmostanxiouslyandcarefullyavoidit。Toshowmuchanxietyaboutpraise,evenforpraise-worthyactions,isseldomamarkofgreatwisdom,butgenerallyofsomedegreeofweakness。But,inbeinganxioustoavoidtheshadowofblameorreproach,theremaybenoweakness,butfrequentlythemostpraise-worthyprudence。
’Manypeople,’saysCicero,’despiseglory,whoareyetmostseverelymortifiedbyunjustreproach;andthatmostinconsistently。’Thisinconsistency,however,seemstobefoundedintheunalterableprinciplesofhumannature。
Theall-wiseAuthorofNaturehas,inthismanner,taughtmantorespectthesentimentsandjudgmentsofhisbrethren;tobemoreorlesspleasedwhentheyapproveofhisconduct,andtobemoreorlesshurtwhentheydisapproveofit。Hehasmademan,ifImaysayso,theimmediatejudgeofmankind;andhas,inthisrespect,asinmanyothers,createdhimafterhisownimage,andappointedhimhisvicegerentuponearth,tosuperintendthebehaviourofhisbrethren。Theyaretaughtbynature,toacknowledgethatpowerandjurisdictionwhichhasthusbeenconferreduponhim,tobemoreorlesshumbledandmortifiedwhentheyhaveincurredhiscensure,andtobemoreorlesselatedwhentheyhaveobtainedhisapplause。
Butthoughmanhas,inthismanner,beenrenderedtheimmediatejudgeofmankind,hehasbeenrenderedsoonlyinthefirstinstance;andanappealliesfromhissentencetoamuchhighertribunal,tothetribunaloftheirownconsciences,tothatofthesupposedimpartialandwell-informedspectator,tothatofthemanwithinthebreast,thegreatjudgeandarbiteroftheirconduct。Thejurisdictionsofthosetwotribunalsarefoundeduponprincipleswhich,thoughinsomerespectsresemblingandakin,are,however,inrealitydifferentanddistinct。Thejurisdictionofthemanwithout,isfoundedaltogetherinthedesireofactualpraise,andintheaversiontoactualblame。Thejurisdictionofthemanwithin,isfoundedaltogetherinthedesireofpraise-worthiness,andintheaversiontoblame-worthiness;inthedesireofpossessingthosequalities,andperformingthoseactions,whichweloveandadmireinotherpeople;andinthedreadofpossessingthosequalities,andperformingthoseactions,whichwehateanddespiseinotherpeople。Ifthemanwithoutshouldapplaudus,eitherforactionswhichwehavenotperformed,orformotiveswhichhadnoinfluenceuponus;themanwithincanimmediatelyhumblethatprideandelevationofmindwhichsuchgroundlessacclamationsmightotherwiseoccasion,bytellingus,thatasweknowthatwedonotdeservethem,werenderourselvesdespicablebyacceptingthem。If,onthecontrary,themanwithoutshouldreproachus,eitherforactionswhichweneverperformed,orformotiveswhichhadnoinfluenceuponthosewhichwemayhaveperformed;themanwithinmayimmediatelycorrectthisfalsejudgment,andassureus,thatwearebynomeanstheproperobjectsofthatcensurewhichhassounjustlybeenbestoweduponus。Butinthisandinsomeothercases,themanwithinseemssometimes,asitwere,astonishedandconfoundedbythevehemenceandclamourofthemanwithout。Theviolenceandloudness,withwhichblameissometimespouredoutuponus,seemstostupifyandbenumbournaturalsenseofpraise-worthinessandblame-worthiness;andthejudgmentsofthemanwithin,thoughnot,perhaps,absolutelyalteredorperverted,are,however,somuchshakeninthesteadinessandfirmnessoftheirdecision,thattheirnaturaleffect,insecuringthetranquillityofthemind,isfrequentlyinagreatmeasuredestroyed。Wescarcedaretoabsolveourselves,whenallourbrethrenappearloudlytocondemnus。Thesupposedimpartialspectatorofourconductseemstogivehisopinioninourfavourwithfearandhesitation;whenthatofalltherealspectators,whenthatofallthosewithwhoseeyesandfromwhosestationheendeavourstoconsiderit,isunanimouslyandviolentlyagainstus。Insuchcases,thisdemigodwithinthebreastappears,likethedemigodsofthepoets,thoughpartlyofimmortal,yetpartlytooofmortalextraction。Whenhisjudgmentsaresteadilyandfirmlydirectedbythesenseofpraiseworthinessandblame-worthiness,heseemstoactsuitablytohisdivineextraction:Butwhenhesuffershimselftobeastonishedandconfoundedbythejudgmentsofignorantandweakman,hediscovershisconnexionwithmortality,andappearstoactsuitably,rathertothehuman,thantothedivine,partofhisorigin。