Methods of Ethics

第56章

试读中

第56章

Methods of Ethics Henry Sidgwick

后面的故事,去 App 接着看,下载后搜索书名即可继续阅读。

Methods of Ethics
阅读主题
字体大小

  Inthefirstplace,ithastobedecidedwhetherwearetoincludeinourlistofmotivestheMoralSentiments,orimpulsestowardsparticularkindsofvirtuousconductassuch,e。g。Candour,Veracity,Fortitude。Itseemsunwarrantabletoexcludethem,assuchsentimentsareobservableasdistinctandindependentimpulsesinmostwell-trainedminds,andwesometimesrecognisetheirexistenceinconsiderableintensity,aswhenwespeakofamanbeing`enthusiasticallybrave’,or`intenselyveracious’,oras`havingapassionforjustice’。

  Atthesametimetheiradmissionplacesusinthefollowingdilemma。Eithertheobjectsoftheseimpulsesarerepresentedbytheverynotionsthatwehavebeenexamining——inwhichcase,afterwehavedecidedthatanyimpulseisbetterthanitsrival,alltheperplexitiessetforthinthepreviouschapterswillrecur,beforewecanactonourdecision;forwhatavailsittorecognisethesuperiorityoftheimpulsetodojustice,ifwedonotknowwhatitisjusttodo?——orifinanycasetheobjectwhichamoralsentimentpromptsustorealiseisconceivedmoresimply,withoutthequalificationswhichacompletereflectiononCommonSenseforcedustorecognise;then,asthepreviousinvestigationshows,weshallcertainlynotfindagreementastotherelationbetweenthisandotherimpulses。

  Forexample,adispute,whethertheimpulsetospeakthetruthoughtoroughtnottobefollowed,willinevitablyarisewhenVeracityseemsopposedeithertothegeneralgood,ortotheinterestsofsomeparticularperson;

  thatis,whenitconflictswith`particular’or`universal’benevolence。

  Hutchesonexpresslyplacestheselatterimpulsesinahigherrankthan``candour,veracity,fortitude’’;reservingthehighestmoralapprobationfor``themostextensivebenevolence’’or``calm,stable,universalgoodwilltoall’’。[1]Butthisview,whichcoincidespracticallywithUtilitarianism,wouldcertainlybedisputedbymostIntuitionalmoralists。Again,someofthesemoralistsasKantregardallactionsasbad——ornotgood——whicharenotdonefrompureregardfordutyorchoiceofRightasRight:whileHutcheson,whorepresentstheoppositepoleofIntuitionalEthics,equallydistinguishestheloveofVirtueasaseparateimpulse;buttreatsitasatonceco-ordinateinrankandcoincidentinitseffectswithuniversalBenevolence。

后续内容在 App 继续看

精彩内容未完,打开 App 继续阅读

后面的故事已为你准备好,下载 App 后搜索“Methods of Ethics”即可继续阅读这一章。