Thelordtakesalsotenementsintohishandinthewayofescheat,intheabsenceofheirs。Court-rollsconstantlymentionplotswhichhavebeenresumedinthiswaybythelord。91*Thehomagehastoreporttothestewardastoallchangesofoccupation,andastothemeasureswhicharethoughtnecessarytopromotetheinterestsofthelandownerandofthetenantry。92*
Astothetreatmentoftenureinmanorialdocuments,itistobenoticedthatadistinctionwhichhasnojuridicalmeaningatallbecomesallimportantinpractice。Atcommonlaw,ashasbeensaidrepeatedly,thecontrastbetweenfreelandandservilelandresolvesitselfintoacontrastbetweenprecariousoccupationandproprietaryright。Thiscontrastisnoticedoccasionallyandasamatteroflegalprinciplebymanorialdocuments93*quiteapartfromtheconsequenceswhichflowfromit,andofwhichIhavebeenspeakingjustnow。Butinactuallifethisfundamentalfeatureisnotveryprominent;allstressislaidonthedistinctionbetweenlandheldbyrentandlandheldbylabour。Inthecommonphraseologyofsurveysandmanorialrolls,thetenementsonwhichtherentprevailsoverlabourarecalled’freetenements,’andthoseonthecontrarywhichhavetorenderlabourservices,bearthenamesof’servileholdings。’Thisfactiscertainlynottobetreatedlightlyasamereresultofdeficientclassificationorterminology。Itisaveryimportantoneanddeservestobeinvestigatedcarefully。
IntheancientsurveyofGlastonburyAbbey,compiledin1189,thequestionstobeansweredbythejuryareenumeratedinthefollowingway:’Whoholdsfreely’andhowmuch,andbywhatservices,andbywhosewarrant,andfromwhattime?HaslandwhichoughttoperformworkbeenturnedintofreelandinthetimeofBishopHenry,orafterwards?Bywhosewarrantwasthischangemade,andtowhatextentisthelandfree?Isthedemesnelandincultivation,orisitgivenawayinfreetenureorvillaintenure;issuchmanagementprofitable,orwoulditbebetterifthislandwastakenbackbythelord?’94*Thecontrastisbetweenlandwhichprovideslabourandlandwhichdoesnot;theformerisunfree,andvillaintenureisthetenureoflandheldbysuchservices;portionsofthedemesnegivenawayfreelymayeventuallybereclaimed。Theschemeofthesurveymadeinanswertothesequestionsisentirelyinkeepingwiththismodeofclassification。Allholdingsareconsideredexclusivelyfromtheeconomicpointofview;thetestofsecurityandprecariousoccupationisneverapplied。Itisconstantlynoticed,ontheotherhand,whetheraplotpaysrentorprovideslabour,whetheritcanbetransferredfromonecategoryintotheother,onwhatconditionsdemesnelandhasbeengiventopeasants,andwhetheritisexpedienttoalterthem。Letustakethefollowingcaseasaninstance:JohnClerkhadinthetimeofBishopHenryonevirgateinDomerhamandholdsitnow,andanothervirgateinStapelhamfortenshillings。WhenhefarmedtheDomerhammanorheleftonhisownauthoritythevirgateinStapelhamandtookhalfavirgateinDomerham,asitwasnearer。Thishalfvirgateoughttoworkandisnowfree。AndthevirgateinStapelbam,thoughitwasfreeformerly,hastoworknow,aftertheexchange。95*Theoppositionisquiteclear,andentirelysuitedtothelistofquestionsaddressedtothejury。Themeaningofthetermsfreeandfreedomisalsobroughtoutbythefollowingexample。AnderdBuddeholdshalfavirgateofdemesneland,fromthetimeofBishopHenry,bythesameservicesasallwhoholdsomuch。Thevillagehastorenderasgifttwenty-nineshillingsandsixpence。Sixpencearewantingtocompletethethirtyshillings?
becauseAnderdholdsmorefreelythanhisancestorsusedto。96*
Suchphraseologyisbynomeansrestrictedtoonedocumentoronelocality。InaRamseyCartularywefindthefollowingentryinregardtoaHuntingdonshiremanor:’Ofsevenhidesoneisfree;oftheremainingsixtwovirgatespayrent。Theholderpayswiththevillains;hepaysmerchetandjoinsintheboon-workasthevillains。Theremainingfivehidesandthreevirgatesareinpurevillainage。’97*ThegradationissomewhatmorecomplexherethanintheSomersetshireinstance:besidesfreelandandworkinglandwehaveaseparatedivisionformixedcases。Butthefoundationisthesameinbothdocuments。EarliersurveysofRamseyAbbeyshowthesameclassificationofholdingintofreeandworkingvirgatesliberae,adopus98*。