Yet,Irepeatoncemore,theexistenceofmysticalstatesabsolutelyoverthrowsthepretensionofnon-mysticalstatestobethesoleandultimatedictatorsofwhatwemaybelieve。Asarule,mysticalstatesmerelyaddasupersensuousmeaningtotheordinaryoutwarddataofconsciousness。Theyareexcitementsliketheemotionsofloveorambition,giftstoourspiritbymeansofwhichfactsalreadyobjectivelybeforeusfallintoanewexpressivenessandmakeanewconnectionwithouractivelife。Theydonotcontradictthesefactsassuch,ordenyanythingthatoursenseshaveimmediatelyseized。[287]Itistherationalisticcriticratherwhoplaysthepartofdenierinthecontroversy,andhisdenialshavenostrength,fortherenevercanbeastateoffactstowhichnewmeaningmaynottruthfullybeadded,providedthemindascendtoamoreenvelopingpointofview。Itmustalwaysremainanopenquestionwhethermysticalstatesmaynotpossiblybesuchsuperiorpointsofview,windowsthroughwhichthemindlooksoutuponamoreextensiveandinclusiveworld。Thedifferenceoftheviewsseenfromthedifferentmysticalwindowsneednotpreventusfromentertainingthissupposition。Thewiderworldwouldinthatcaseprovetohaveamixedconstitutionlikethatofthisworld,thatisall。
Itwouldhaveitscelestialanditsinfernalregions,itstemptinganditssavingmoments,itsvalidexperiencesanditscounterfeitones,justasourworldhasthem;butitwouldbeawiderworldallthesame。Weshouldhavetouseitsexperiencesbyselectingandsubordinatingandsubstitutingjustasisourcustominthisordinarynaturalisticworld;weshouldbeliabletoerrorjustaswearenow;yetthecountinginofthatwiderworldofmeanings,andtheseriousdealingwithit,might,inspiteofalltheperplexity,beindispensablestagesinourapproachtothefinalfullnessofthetruth。
Theysometimesaddsubjectiveauditaetvisatothefacts,butastheseareusuallyinterpretedastransmundane,theyobligenoalterationinthefactsofsense。
Inthisshape,Ithink,wehavetoleavethesubject。Mysticalstatesindeedwieldnoauthorityduesimplytotheirbeingmysticalstates。Butthehigheronesamongthempointindirectionstowhichthereligioussentimentsevenofnon-
mysticalmenincline。Theytellofthesupremacyoftheideal,ofvastness,ofunion,ofsafety,andofrest。TheyofferusHYPOTHESES,hypotheseswhichwemayvoluntarilyignore,butwhichasthinkerswecannotpossiblyupset。Thesupernaturalismandoptimismtowhichtheywouldpersuadeusmay,interpretedinonewayoranother,beafterallthetruestofinsightsintothemeaningofthislife。