Anothercase,thoughsomewhatdifferent,maybeheregiven,asitishighlyremarkable,andisestablishedonexcellentevidence。Kolreuterminutelydescribesfivevarietiesofthecommontobacco(16/25。’ZweiteForts。’s。53
namelyNicotianamajorvulgaris;(2)perennis;(3)transylvanica;(4)asub—
var。ofthelast;(5)majorlatifol。fl。alb。)whichwerereciprocallycrossed,andtheoffspringwereintermediateincharacterandasfertileastheirparents:fromthisfactKolreuterinferredthattheyarereallyvarieties;andnoone,asfarasIcandiscover,seemstohavedoubtedthatsuchisthecase。HealsocrossedreciprocallythesefivevarietieswithN。
glutinosa,andtheyyieldedverysterilehybrids;butthoseraisedfromthevar。perennis,whetherusedasthefatherormotherplant,werenotsosterileasthehybridsfromthefourothervarieties。(16/26。KolreuterwassomuchstruckwiththisfactthathesuspectedthatalittlepollenofN。glutinosainoneofhisexperimentsmighthaveaccidentallygotmingledwiththatofvar。perennis,andthusaideditsfertilisingpower。ButwenowknowconclusivelyfromGartner(’Bastarderz。’s。34,43)thatthepollenoftwospeciesneveractsCONJOINTLYonathirdspecies;stilllesswillthepollenofadistinctspecies,mingledwithaplant’sownpollen,ifthelatterbepresentinsufficientquantity,haveanyeffect。Thesoleeffectofminglingtwokindsofpollenistoproduceinthesamecapsuleseedswhichyieldplants,sometakingaftertheoneandsomeaftertheotherparent。)Sothatthesexualcapacityofthisonevarietyhascertainlybeeninsomedegreemodified,soastoapproachinnaturethatofN。glutinosa。(16/27。Mr。Scotthasmadesomeobservationsontheabsolutesterilityofapurpleandwhiteprimrose(Primulavulgaris)whenfertilisedbypollenfromthecommonprimrose(’JournalofProc。ofLinn。Soc。’volume81864page98);buttheseobservationsrequireconfirmation。Iraisedanumberofpurple—floweredlong—
styledseedlingsfromseedkindlysentmebyMr。Scott,and,thoughtheywereallinsomedegreesterile,theyweremuchmorefertilewithpollentakenfromthecommonprimrosethanwiththeirownpollen。Mr。Scotthaslikewisedescribedaredequal—styledcowslip(P。verisibidpage106),whichwasfoundbyhimtobehighlysterilewhencrossedwiththecommoncowslip;butthiswasnotthecasewithseveralequal—styledredseedlingsraisedbymefromhisplant。Thisvarietyofthecowslippresentstheremarkablepeculiarityofcombiningmaleorgansineveryrespectlikethoseoftheshort—styledform,withfemaleorgansresemblinginfunctionandpartlyinstructurethoseofthelong—styledform;sothatwehavethesingularanomalyofthetwoformscombinedinthesameflower。Henceitisnotsurprisingthattheseflowersshouldbespontaneouslyself—fertileinahighdegree。)