Allthatisrequiredistheabolitionoftheacademicexecutiveandofthegoverningboard。Anythingshortofthisheroicremedyisboundtofail,becausetheevilssoughttoberemediedareinherentintheseorgans,andintrinsictotheirfunctioning。
Evengrantingthepossibilityofmakingsuchamove,inthefaceofpopularprejudice,itwilldoubtlessseemsuicidal,onfirstthought,totakesoradicaladeparture;inthatitwouldbeheldtocripplethewholeacademicorganizationandsubverttheschemeofthingsacademic,forgoodandall:——which,bytheway,ispreciselywhatwouldhavetobeaimedat,sinceitisthepresentschemeandorganizationthatunavoidablyworkthemischief,andsince,also(astouchestheinterestofthehigherlearning),theyworknothingbutmischief。
Itshouldbeplain,onreflection,toanyonefamiliarwithacademicmattersthatneitheroftheseofficialbodiesservesanyusefulpurposeintheuniversity,insofarasbearsinanywayonthepursuitofknowledge。Theymayconceivablybothbeusefulforsomeotherpurpose,foreignoralientothequestoflearning;butwithinthelinesoftheuniversity’slegitimateinterestbotharewhollydetrimental,andverywastefullyso。
Theyareneedless,excepttotakecareofneedsandemergenciestowhichtheirownpresencegratuitouslygivesrise。Insofarastheseneedsanddifficultiesthatrequireexecutivesurveillancearenotsimplyandflagrantlyfactitious,——as,e。g。,theonerousdutiesofpublicity——theyarealtogethersuchneedsasariseoutofanexcessivesizeandagratuitouslycomplexadministrativeorganization;bothofwhichcharacteristicsoftheAmericanuniversityarecreatedbythegoverningboardsandtheirexecutiveofficers,fornobetterpurposethanavaingloriousself—complacency,andwithnobetterjustificationthananuncriticalprepossessiontotheeffectthatlargesize,complexorganization,andauthoritativecontrolnecessarilymakeforefficiency;whereas,inpointoffact,intheaffairsoflearningthesethingsunavoidablymakefordefeat。
Objectiontoanysuchmeasureofabolitionisnottobegroundedintheirimpracticabilityortheirinefficiency,——