inwhichareparticularlyconsideredPopulation,Agriculture,Trade,Industry,Money,Coin,Interest,Circulation,Banks,Exchange,PublicCredit,andTaxesbySirJamesSteuart,Bart。
Oretrabitquodcumquepotestatqueadditacervo。
Hor。Lib。I。Sat。1
inTwoVolumes。
London:
PrintedforA。Millar,andT。Cadell,intheStrand。
MDCCLXVII
PREFACE
ItiswiththegreatestdiffidencethatIpresenttothepublicthisattempttowardsreducingtoprinciples,andformingintoaregularscience,thecomplicatedinterestsofdomesticpolicy。WhenIconsiderthetimeandlabouremployedinthecomposition,Iamapttovalueitfromselfishconsiderations。
WhenIcompareitevenwithmyownabilities,Istillthinkfavourablyofit,forabetterreason;becauseitcontainsasummaryofthemostvaluablepartofallmyknowledge。ButwhenI
considerthegreatnessofmysubject,howsmalldoestheresultofmyapplicationappear!
Theimperfections,therefore,discoveredinthiswork,mustbeascribedtothedisproportionbetweentheextentoftheundertaking,andthatofmycapacity。This,Icanassuremyreader,hasbeenexertedtotheutmost:andif,afterall,Ihavefailed,itmay,atleast,withjustice,besaid,thatIhavemiscarriedinanattemptofthegreatestimportancetomankind。
Inowhere,Ithink,haveshewnadesiretomakemycourttoanyparticularminister,whoseadministrationmighthavebeenhintedat。Ihavefreelyfollowedthethreadofmyreasoningwithoutabias,eitherinfavourofpopularopinions,orofanyofthenumberlesssystemswhichhavebeenformedbythosewhohavewrittenuponparticularpartsofmysubject。ThewarmthofmytempermayhaveledmesometimesintocommendationswhenI
havebeenpleased;butwhenIfelttheeffectsofillhumouronbeingdissatisfiedwithparticularcircumstances,relatingtocountries,tomen,andtothings,whichIhadinmyeyeatthetimeIwaswriting,Iwasimmediatelyawareofthedangerofblamingthestepsofanyadministration,withoutbeingwellformedofthewholecombinationofcircumstanceswhichtheministermayhavehadbeforehimatthetime。
Thiscompositionbeingthesuccessivelabourofmanyyearsspentintravelling,thereaderwillfindsomepassagesinwhichtheunitiesoftimeandplacehavenotbeenobserved。TheseI
couldhavecorrectedwithease,hadInotbeenadvisedtoleavethemascharacterstopointoutthecircumstancesunderwhichI
wrote,andtherebytoconfirmtheauthenticityofcertainfacts。
Themodesofthinking,also,peculiartotheseveralcountrieswhereIhavelived,have,nodoubt,hadaninfluenceonwhatIhavewrittenconcerningtheircustoms:thiswork,therefore,willnot,ingeneral,correspondtothemeridianofnationalopinionsanywhere;andofthisitisproperthereadershouldbeapprised,thathemaynotapplytothedomesticcircumstancesofhisowncountrywhatwasintendedtorefertothoseofothernations;norimputetowilfulprejudice,whatwastheirresistibleeffectofmyexperienceandconviction。
Sincethefirstpublicationofthisworksomecriticismsuponithavebeenpublishedinwhichlittleregardhasbeenpaidtothisadvertisement。
Thegreaterpartofitbyfar,thethreefirstbooksparticularlywascomposedabroad。Canitbesupposed,thatduringanabsenceofneartwentyyears,IshouldinmystudieshaveallthewhilebeenmodellingmyspeculationsuponthestandardofEnglishnotions。
IthasbeenallegedthatIhaveimbibedprejudicesabroad,bynomeansconsistentwiththepresentstateofEngland,andthegeniusofEnglishmen。
TowhichIanswer,thatIflattermyselftohaveimbibednoprejudiceseitherabroadorathome,atleastIthinkIhaveexhibitednoneoftheminmywork;becausethereIhaverejectedallpartyopinionswhatever。
Accordingtomywayoftreatingthissubjectnogeneralrulecanbelaiddowninpoliticalmatters:everythingtheremustbeconsideredaccordingtothecircumstancesandspiritofthenationstowhichtheyrelate。Accordinglyweshallfindinthisinquirysomereasoningsbuiltontheprinciplesofarbitrarypower,othersonthoseofnationalliberty,othersagainonthoseofdemocracy。HadI,incomplimenttothesentimentsofEnglishmen,suppressedeverycombinationwhichmightapplytothecircumstancesofthoseverycountrieswhereIwasstudyingmysubject,fromtheactualinspectionoftheirpolicy,whatmeritshouldIhavehadtopleadwithmyowncountrymenfrommytravelsandfrommystudies,anylocalEnglishwriterdescribingEnglishpolicyandsoundingthrougheverypagethemostpeculiaropinionsofthisnation,mighthaveamusedhisreadersfarbetterthaneverIcouldpretendto。
If,fromthiswork,Ihaveanymeritatall,itisbydivestingmyselfofEnglishnotions,sofarastobeabletoexposeinafairlight,thesentimentsandpolicyofforeignnations,relativelytotheirownsituation。
Nowtheprincipalattentionofanintelligentreaderwhoperusesabooklikethis,willbedirectedtowardstheinvestigatorypartofit:everystepofthereasoningwillbeweighedbyhimuntilthefinalconclusionbedrawn;hewillthengivehisassenttoitinproportiontotheaccuracyoftheinduction;butheneverwillrecoilfromwhathehasonceassentedto,inordertoformageneralnotionconcedinganyresultbycomparingitwithhisownanimalfeelingsorwiththepopularopinionofhiscountrymen。
ThismuchIamobligedtosayinmyownjustification,withrespecttoseveralpassageswhichhavebeenwrittenattimeswhenEnglandwasverydistantfrommythoughts。
Ihavereadmanyauthorsonthesubjectofpoliticaloeconomy;andIhaveendeavouredtodrawfromthemalltheinstructionIcould。Ihavetravelled,formanyyears,throughdifferentcountries,andhaveexaminedthem,constantly,withaneyetomyownsubject。IhaveattemptedtodrawinformationfromeveryonewithwhomIhavebeenacquainted:this,however,I
foundtobeverydifficultuntilIhadattainedtosomepreviousknowledgeofmysubject。SuchdifficultiesconfirmedtomethejustnessofLordBacon’sremark,thathewhocandrawinformationbyformingproperquestions,mustbealreadypossessedofhalfthescience。
IcouldformnoconsistentplanfromthevariousopinionsI
metwith:henceIwasengagedtocompiletheobservationsIbadcasuallymade,inthecourseofmytravels,reading,andexperience。FromtheseIformedthefollowingworkafterexpungingthenumberlessinconsistenciesandcontradictionswhichIfoundhadarisenfrommyseparateinquiriesintoeveryparticularbranch。
Ihadobservedsomanypersonsdeclininginknowledgeastheyadvancedinyears,thatIresolvedearlytothrowuponpaperwhateverIhadlearned;andtothisIusedtohaverecourse,asothershavetotheirmemories。Theunityoftheobjectofallmyspeculations,renderedthispracticemoreusefultomethanitwouldbetoonewhoseresearchesaremoreextended。
Whoeverismuchaccustomedtowriteforhisownusemerely,mustcontractamorecarelessstylethananotherwhohasmadelanguagehisstudy,andwhowritesinhopesofacquiringaliteraryreputation。Inever,tillverylately,thoughtofappearingasanauthoronthissubject;and,inthefrequentperusalsofwhatIhadwritten,mycorrectionswerechieflyinfavourofperspicuity。addtothis,thatthelanguageinwhichI
nowwritewas,formanyyears,foreigntothosewithwhomIlivedandconversed。Whenthesecircumstancesareaddedtotheintricacyofmysubject,whichconstantlycarriedoffmyattentionfromeveryornamentoflanguage,Iflattermyselfthatthoseofmyreaders,atleast,whoenterasheartilyasIhavedoneintothespiritofthiswork,willcandidlyoverlookthewantofthatelegancewhichadornsthestyleofsomecelebratedauthorsinthisAugustanage。
Ipresentthisenquirytothepublicasnothingmorethananessaywhichmayserveasacanvassforbetterhandsthanminetoworkupon。
ItcontainssuchobservationsonlyasthegeneralviewofthedomesticpolicyofthecountriesIhaveseen,hassuggested。Itisaspeculation,andnomore。Itisaroughdrawingofamightyplan,proportionedincorrectnesstomyownsagacity,tomyknowledgeofthesubject,andtotheextentofmyideas。
Itgoeslittlefartherthantocollectandarrangesomeelementsrelatingtothemostinterestingbranchesofmodernpolicy,suchaspopulation,agriculture,trade,industry,money,coin,interest,circulation,banks,exchange,publiccredit,andtaxes。Theprinciplesdeducedfromallthesetopics,appeartolerablyconsistent;andthewholeisatrainofreasoning,throughwhichIhaveadheredtotheconnectionofsubjectsasfaithfullyasIcould:butthenatureoftheworkbeingadeductionofprinciples,notacollectionofinstitutions,I
seizedtheopportunitieswhichmyreasoningthrewinmyway,toconnecteveryprinciple,asIwentalong,witheverypartoftheinquirytowhichitcouldrefer;andwhenIfoundtheconnexionsufficientlyshewn,Ibrokeoffsuchdisquisitionsaswouldhaveledmefromtheobjectthenpresent。
Whenprinciplesthuscasuallyappliedinonepart,tomattersintendedtobeafterwardstreatedofinanother,cametobetakenupa-new,theyinvolvedmeinwhatmayappearprolixity。ThisI
foundmostunavoidable,whenIwasledtothoughtswhichwerenewtomyself,andconsequentlysuchasmusthavecostmethegreatestlabourtosetinaclearanddistinctpointofview。HadIbeenmasterofmysubjectonsettingout,thearrangementofthewholewouldhavebeenrenderedmoreconcise:buthadthisbeenthecase,Ishouldneverhavebeenabletogothroughthepainfuldeductionwhichformsthewholechainofmyreasoning,anduponwhich,tomanyreadersslowinformingcombinations,theconvictionitcarriesalongwithitinagreatmeasuredepends:
tothefew,again,ofamorepenetratinggenius,towhomtheslightesthintissufficienttolayopeneveryconsequencebeforeitbedrawn,inallusiontoHorace,Iofferthisapology,Clarusesselaboro,prolixusfio。
ThepathIhavetakenwasnewtome,afterallIhadreadonthesubject。Iexamined,bymyownprinciples,whatIhadgatheredfromothers;andadopteditasfarasIfoundittallywithcollateralcircumstances。When,ontheotherhand,Ifoundadisagreement,Iwasapprizedimmediatelyofsomemistake;andthisIfoundconstantlyowingtothenarrownessofthecombinationsuponwhichithadbeenfounded。
Thegreatdangerofrunningintoerroruponparticularpointsrelatingtothissubject,proceedsfromourviewingtheminalighttooconfined,andtoournotattendingtotheinfluenceofconcomitantcircumstances,whichrendergeneralrulesoflittleuse。Menofpartsandknowledgeseldomfailtoreasonconsequentiallyoneverysubject;butwheninquiriesaremadeconcerningthecomplicatedinterestsofsociety,thevivacityofanauthor’sgeniusisapttopreventhimfromattendingtothevarietyofcircumstanceswhichrenderuncertaineveryconsequence,almost,whichhecandrawfromhisreasoning。TothisIascribethehabitofrunningintowhattheFrenchcallSyst鑝es。Thesearenomorethanachainofcontingentconsequences,drawnfromafewfundamentalmaxims,adopted,perhaps,rashly。Suchsystemsaremereconceits;theymisleadtheunderstanding,andeffacethepathtotruth。Aninductionisformed,fromwhenceaconclusion,calledaprinciple,isdrawnanddefined;butthisisnosoonerdone,thantheauthorextendsitsinfluencefarbeyondthelimitsoftheideaspresenttohisunderstanding,whenhemadehisdefinition。Thebestmethod,therefore,todetectapretendedsystem,isalwaystosubstitutethedefinitioninplaceoftheterm。
Theimperfectionalsooflanguageengagesusfrequentlyindisputesmerelyverbal;andinsteadofbeingonourguardagainstthemanyunavoidableambiguitiesattendingthemostcarefulspeech,weplaceagreatpartofourlearningwhenatschool,andofourwitwhenweappearonthestageoftheworld,intheprostitutionoflanguage。Thelearneddelightinvague,andthewittyinequivocalterms。Ingeneral,wefamiliarizeourselvessomuchtowords,andthinksolittle,whenwespeakandwrite,thatthesignsofourideastaketheplaceoftheimageswhichtheywereintendedtorepresent。
Everytrueproposition,whenunderstood,mustbeassentedtouniversally。Thisisthecasealways,whensimpleideasareaffirmedordeniedofeachother。Nobodyeverdoubtedthatsoundistheobjectofhearing,orcolourthatofsight,orthatblackisnotwhite。Butwheneveradisputearisesconcerningaproposition,whereincomplexideasarecompared,wemayoftenrestassured,thatthepartiesdonotunderstandeachother。
Luxury,saysone,isincompatiblewiththeprosperityofastate。
Luxuryisthefountainofanation’swelfareandhappiness,saysanother。Theremay,inreality,benodifferenceinthesentimentsofthesetwopersons。Thefirstmayconsiderluxuryasprejudicialtoforeigntrade,andascorruptingthemoralsofapeople。Theothermayconsiderluxuryasthemeansofprovidingemploymentforsuchasmustlivebytheirindustry,andofpromotinganequablecirculationofwealthandsubsistence,throughalltheclassesofinhabitants。Ifeachofthemhadattendedtotheother’scomplexideaofluxury,withallitsconsequences,theywouldhaverenderedtheirpropositionslessgeneral。
Thedifference,therefore,ofopinionbetweenmenisfrequentlymoreapparentthanreal。Whenwecompareourownideas,weconstantlyseetheirrelationswithperspicuity;butwhenwecometocommunicatetheserelationstootherpeople,itisoftenimpossibletoputthemintowordssufficientlyexpressiveoftheprecisecombinationofthemwehavemadeinourownminds。
Thisbeingthecase,Ihaveavoided,asmuchaspossible,condemningsuchopinionsasIhavetakenthelibertytoreview;
becauseIhaveexaminedsuchonlyashavebeenadvancedbymenofgeniusandreputation;andsinceallmattersofcontroversyregardthecomparisonofourideas,ifthetermsweusetoexpressthemweresufficientlyunderstoodbybothparties,mostpoliticaldisputeswould,Iampersuaded,besoonatanend。
Hereitmaybeobjected,thatwefrequentlyadoptanopinion,withoutbeingabletogiveasufficientreasonforit;andyetwecannotpersuadeourselvestogiveitup,thoughwefinditcombatedbythestrongestarguments。TothisIanswer,thatinsuchcaseswedonotadheretoourownopinions,buttothoseofothersreceivedupontrust。Itisourregardfortheauthority,andnotfortheopinion,whichmakesustenacious:forweretheopiniontrulyourown,wecouldnotfailofseeing,oratleastweshouldnotlongbeatalossinrecollecting,thegrounduponwhichitisbuilt。Butwhenweassentimplicitlytoanypoliticaldoctrine,thereisnoroomforreason:wethensatisfyourselveswiththepersuasionthatthosewhomwetrusthavesufficientreasonsforwhattheyadvance。Whileourassentthereforeisimplicit,wearebeyondconviction;notbecausewedonotperceivetheforceoftheargumentsbroughtagainstouropinion,butbecauseweareignorantoftheforceofthosewhichcanbebroughttosupportit:andasnobodywillsellwhatbelongstohim,withoutbeingpreviouslyinformedofitsvalue,sonobodywillgiveupanimplicitopinion,withoutknowingallthatcanbesaidforit。TothisclassofmenIdonotaddressmyselfinthisinquiry。
ButIinsensiblyrunintoametaphysicalspeculation,inordertoprove,thatinpoliticalquestionsitisbetterforpeopletojudgefromexperienceandreason,thanfromauthoritytoexplaintheirterms,thantodisputeaboutwords;andtoextendthecombinationsoftheirownideas,thantofollowconceits,howeverdecoratedwiththenameofsystems。HowfarI
haveavoidedsuchdefects,thereaderwilldetermine。
Everywritervalueshimselfuponhisimpartiality;becauseheisnotsensibleofhisfetters。ThewanderingandindependentlifeIhaveledmaynaturallyhavesetmefree,insomemeasure,fromstrongattachmentstopopularopinions。Thismaybecalledimpartiality。Butasnomancanbedeemedimpartial,wholeanstoanysidewhatever,Ihavebeenparticularlyonmyguardagainsttheconsequencesofthissortofnegativeimpartiality;becauseI
havefounditsometimescarryingmetoofarfromthattowhichanationalprejudicemighthaveledme。
Indiscussinggeneralpoints,thebestmethodIfoundtomaintainajustbalanceinthisrespect,wastoavertmyeyefromthecountryinwhichIlivedatthetime;andtojudgeofabsentthingsbytheabsent。Objectswhicharepresent,areapttoproduceperceptionstoostrongtobeimpartiallycomparedwiththoserecalledbymemoryonly。
WhenIhavehadoccasiontodipintoanyquestionconcerningthepreferencetobegiventocertainformsofgovernmentaboveothers,andtotouchuponpointswhichhavebeentheobjectofsharpdisputes,Ihavegivenmyopinionwithfreedom,whenitseemedproper:butinstatingthequestion,Ihaveendeavouredtoavoidalltrite,and,asImaycallthem,technicaltermsofparty;whichinsuchdisputeseverysidechusestotakeintheirownacceptation:andasthereisnosentimentofconcordorgood-willintheirhearts,insteadofcomingtoexplanationstogether,theyarecharmedtofindanoccasiontodifferconcerninggeneralpropositions,fromthosetheyhateforparticularconsiderations。
Ihavesometimesenteredsoheartilyintothespiritofthestatesman,astobeapttoforgetmystationinthesocietywhereIlive;andwhenasaprivatemanIhavereadovertheworkofthepolitician,mynaturalpartialityinfavourofindividualshasledmetocondemn,asMachiavellianprinciples,everysentiment,approvingthesacrificeofprivateconcernsinfavourofageneralplan。
Inorder,therefore,toreconcilemetomyselfinthisparticular,andtopreventcertainexpressionshereandthereinterspersed,frommakingtheslightestimpressionuponareaderofdelicatesentiments,Imustobserve,thatnothingwouldhavebeensoeasyastosoftenmanypassages,wherethepoliticianappearstohavesnatchedthepenoutofthehandoftheprivatecitizen:butasIwriteforsuchonlywhocanfollowaclosereasoning,andattendtothegeneralscopeofthewholeinquiry,Ihave,purposely,madenocorrection;butcontinuedpainting,inthestrongestcolours,everyinconveniencewhichmustaffectcertainindividualslivingunderourfreemoderngovernments,wheneverawisestatesmansetsaboutcorrectingoldabuses,proceedingfromidleness,sloth,orfraudinthelowerclasses,arbitraryjurisdictionsinthehigher,andneglectsinadministrationswithrespecttotheinterestsofboth。Themoreanycureispainfulanddangerous,themoreoughtmencarefullytoavoidthedisease。Thisleadsmetosayawordconcerningtheconnectionbetweenthetheoryofmoralsandthatofpolitics。
Ilayitdownasageneralmaxim,thatthecharacteristicofagoodactionconsistsintheconformitybetweenthemotive,andthedutyoftheagent。Weretherebutonemanuponearth,hisdutywouldcontainnootherpreceptsthanthosedictatedbyself-love。Ifhecometobeafather,ahusband,afriend,hisself-lovefallsimmediatelyunderlimitations:hemustwithholdfromhimself,andgivetohischildren;hemustknowhowtosacrificesomeofhisfancies,inordertogratify,nowandthen,thoseofhiswife,orofhisfriend。Ifhecometobeajudge,amagistrate;hemustfrequentlyforgetthatheisafriend,orafather:andifherisetobeastatesman,hemustdisregardmanyotherattachmentsmorecomprehensive,suchasfamily,placeofbirth,andeven,incertaincases,hisnativecountry。Hisdutyherebecomesrelativetothegeneralgoodofthatsocietyofwhichheisthehead:andasthedeathofacriminalcannotbeimputedtothejudgewhocondemnshim,neithercanaparticularinconvenienceresultingtoanindividual,inconsequenceofasteptakenforageneralreformation,beimputedtohimwhositsatthehelmofgovernment。
Ifitshouldbeasked,ofwhatutilityaspeculationsuchasthiscanbetoastatesman,towhomitisinamanneraddressedfromthebeginningtotheend:Ianswer,thatalthoughitseemaddressedtoastatesman,therealobjectoftheinquiryistoinfluencethespiritofthosewhomhegoverns;andthevarietyofmattercontainedinit,mayevensuggestusefulhintstohimself。
Buthisowngeniusandexperiencewillenablehimtocarrysuchnotionsfarbeyondthereachofmyabilities。
IhavealreadysaidthatIconsideredmyworkasnomorethanacanvasspreparedformoreablehandsthanminetoworkupon。
Nowalthoughthesketchitcontainsbenotsufficientlycorrect,Ihavestillmadesomeprogress,Ithink,inpreparingthewayforotherstoimproveuponmyplan,bycontrivingproperquestionstoberesolvedbymenofexperienceinthepracticalpartofgovernment。
Ileaveitthereforetomastersinthesciencetocorrectandextendmyideas:andthosewhohavenotmadetheprinciplesofpolicytheirparticularstudy,mayhaveanopportunityofcomparingtheexpositionIhavegivenofthemwiththecommonlyreceivedopinionsconcerningmanyquestionsofgreatimportancetosociety。Theywill,forinstance,beabletojudgehowfarpopulationcanbeincreasedusefully,bymultiplyingmarriages,andbydividinglands:howfartheswellingofcapitals,citiesandtowns,tendstodepopulateacountry:howfartheprogressofluxurybringsdistressuponthepoorindustriousman:howfarrestrictionslaiduponthecorntrade,tendtopromoteanamplesupplyofsubsistenceinallourmarkets:howfartheincreaseofpublicdebtstendstoinvolveusinageneralbankruptcy:howfartheabolitionofpapercurrencywouldhavetheeffectofreducingthepriceofallcommodities:howfarataxtendstoenhancetheirvalue:andhowfarthediminutionofdutiesisanessentialrequisiteforsecuringtheliberty,andpromotingtheprosperityandhappinessofapeople。
Isitnotofthegreatestimportancetoexamine,withcandour,theoperationsbywhichallEuropehasbeenengagedinasystemofpolicysogenerallydeclaimedagainst,andsocontrarytothatwhichweheardailyrecommendedasthebest?Toshew,fromtheplainprinciplesofcommonsense,thatourpresentsituationistheunavoidableconsequenceofthespiritandmannersofthepresenttimes;andthatitisquitecompatiblewithalltheliberty,affluence,andprosperity,whichanyhumansocietyeverenjoyedinanyage,orunderanyformofgovernment?
Apeopletaughttoexpectfromastatesmantheexecutionofplans,bigwithimpossibilityandcontradiction,willremaindiscontentedunderthegovernmentofthebestofKings。
BookI
OfPopulationandAgricultureIntroductionOeconomy,ingeneral,istheartofprovidingforallthewantsofafamily,withprudenceandfrugality。
Ifanythingnecessaryorusefulbefoundwanting,ifanythingprovidedbelostormisapplied,ifanyservant,anyanimal,besupernumeraryoruseless,ifanyonesickorinfirmbeneglected,weimmediatelyperceiveawantofoeconomy。Theobjectofit,inaprivatefamily,isthereforetoprovideforthenourishment,theotherwants,andtheemploymentofeveryindividual。Inthefirstplace,forthemaster,whoisthehead,andwhodirectsthewhole;nextforthechildren,whointeresthimaboveallotherthings;andlastfortheservants,whobeingusefultothehead,andessentialtothewell-beingofthefamily,havethereforeatitletobecomeanobjectofthemaster’scareandconcern。
Thewholeoeconomymustbedirectedbythehead,whoisbothlordandstewardofthefamily。Itishowevernecessary,thatthesetwoofficesbenotconfoundedwithoneanother。Aslord,heestablishesthelawsofhisoeconomy;assteward,heputstheminexecution。Aslord,hemayrestrainandgivehiscommandstoallwithinthehouseashethinksproper;assteward,hemustconductwithgentlenessandaddress,andisboundbyhisownregulations。
Thebettertheoeconomist,themoreuniformityisperceivedinallhisactions,andthelesslibertiesaretakentodepartfromstatedrules。Heisnotsomuchmaster,asthathemaybreakthroughthelawsofhisoeconomy,althoughineveryrespecthemaykeepeachindividualwithinthehouse,inthemostexactsubordinationtohiscommands。Oeconomyandgovernment,eveninaprivatefamily,presentthereforetwodifferentideas,andhavealsotwodifferentobjects。
Whatoeconomyisinafamily,politicaloeconomyisinastate:withtheseessentialdifferences,however,thatinastatetherearenoservants,allarechildren:thatafamilymaybeformedwhenandhowamanpleases,andhemaythereestablishwhatplanofoeconomyhethinksfit;butstatesarefoundformed,andtheOeconomyofthesedependsuponathousandcircumstances。
Thestatesmanthisisageneraltermtosignifythelegislatureandsupremepower,accordingtotheformofgovernmentisneithermastertoestablishwhatoeconomyhepleases,or,intheexerciseofhissublimeauthority,tooverturnatwilltheestablishedlawsofit,lethimbethemostdespoticmonarchuponearth。1*
Thegreatartthereforeofpoliticaloeconomyis,firsttoadaptthedifferentoperationsofittothespirit,manners,habits,andcustomsofthepeople;andafterwardstomodelthesecircumstancesso,astobeabletointroduceasetofnewandmoreusefulinstitutions。
Theprincipalobjectofthisscienceistosecureacertainfundofsubsistenceforalltheinhabitants,toobviateeverycircumstancewhichmayrenderitprecarious;toprovideeverythingnecessaryforsupplyingthewantsofthesociety,andtoemploytheinhabitantssupposingthemtobefree-meninsuchamannerasnaturallytocreatereciprocalrelationsanddependenciesbetweenthem,soastomaketheirseveralinterestsleadthemtosupplyoneanotherwiththeirreciprocalwants。
Ifoneconsidersthevarietywhichisfoundindifferentcountries,inthedistributionofproperty,subordinationofclasses,geniusofpeople,proceedingfromthevarietyofformsofgovernment,laws,climate,andmanners,onemayconclude,thatthepoliticaloeconomyineachmustnecessarilybedifferent,andthatprinciples,howeveruniversallytrue,maybecomequiteineffectualinpractice,withoutasufficientpreparationofthespiritofapeople。
Itisthebusinessofastatesmantojudgeoftheexpediencyofdifferentschemesofoeconomy,andbydegreestomodelthemindsofhissubjectssoastoinducethem,fromtheallurementofprivateinterest,toconcurintheexecutionofhisplan。
Thespeculativepersonwho,removedfromthepractice,extractstheprinciplesofthissciencefromobservationandreflection,shoulddivesthimself,asfaraspossible,ofeveryprejudiceinfavourofestablishedopinions,howeverreasonable,whenexaminedrelativelytoparticularnations:hemustdohisutmosttobecomeacitizenoftheworld,comparingcustoms,examiningminutelyinstitutionswhichappearalike,whenindifferentcountriestheyarefoundtoproducedifferenteffects:
heshouldexaminethecauseofsuchdifferenceswiththeutmostdiligenceandattention。Itisfromsuchinquiriesthatthetrueprinciplesarediscovered。
Hewhotakesupthepenuponthissubject,keepinginhiseyethecustomsofhisownoranyothercountry,willfallmorenaturallyintoadescriptionofoneparticularsystemofit,thanintoanexaminationoftheprinciplesofthescienceingeneral;
hewillapplaudsuchinstitutionsashefindsrightlyadministeredathome;hewillcondemnthosewhichareadministeredwithabuse;but,withoutcomparingdifferentmethodsofexecutingthesameplanindifferentcountries,hewillnoteasilydistinguishthedisadvantageswhichareessentialtotheinstitution,fromthosewhichproceedfromtheabuse。Forthisreasonaland-taxexcitesheindignationofaFrenchman,anexcisethatofanEnglishman。Onewholooksintotheexecutionofboth,ineachcountry,andineverybranchoftheirmanagement,willdiscovertherealeffectsoftheseimpositions,andbeabletodistinguishwhatproceedsfromabuse,fromwhatisessentialtotheburden。
Nothingismoreeffectualtowardspreparingthespiritofapeopletoreceiveagoodplanofoeconomy,thanaproperrepresentationofit。Ontheotherhand,nothingisbettercalculatedtokeepthestatesman,whoisattheheadofaffairs,inawe。
Whenprinciplesarewellunderstood,therealconsequencesofburdensomeinstitutionsareclearlyseen:whenthepurposestheyareintendedforarenotobtained,theabuseofthestatesman’sadministrationappearspalpable。Peoplethenwillnotsomuchcryoutagainsttheimposition,asagainstthemisapplication。Itwillnotbealand-taxoffourshillingsinthepound,noranexciseuponwinesandtobacco,whichwillexcitethemurmursofanation;itwillbetheprodigaldissipationandmisapplicationoftheamountofthesetaxesaftertheyarelaidon。Butwhenprinciplesarenotknown,allinquiryisatanend,themomentanationcanbeengagedtosubmittotheburden。Itisthesamewithregardtomanyotherpartsofthisscience:whilepeopleremainblindtheyarealwaysmistrustful。
Havingpointedouttheobjectofmypursuit,Ishallonlyadd,thatmyintentionistoattachmyselfprincipallytoacleardeductionofprinciples,andashortapplicationofthemtofamiliarexamples,inordertoavoidabstractionasmuchaspossible。Ifartherintendtoconfinemyselftosuchpartsofthisextensivesubject,asshallappearthemostinterestinginthegeneralsystemofmodernpolitics;ofwhichIshalltreatwiththatspiritofliberty,whichreignsmoreandmoreeveryday,throughoutallthepoliteandflourishingnationsofEurope。
WhenIcomparetheelegantperformanceswhichhaveappearedinGreatBritainandinFrancewithmydryandabstractedmanneroftreatingthesamesubject,inaplainlanguagevoidofornament,IownIamdiscouragedonmanyaccounts。IfIbeobligedtosetoutbylayingdown,asfundamentalprinciples,themostobvioustruths,Idreadtheimputationofpedantry,andofpretendingtoturncommonsenseintoscience。IfIfollowtheseprinciplesthroughaminutedetail,Imayappeartrifling。I
thereforehopethereaderwillbelieveme,whenItellhim,thatthesedefectshavenotescapedmydiscernment,butthatmygenius,thenatureofthework,andtheconnectionofthesubject,haveobligedmetowriteinanorderandinastyle,whereeverythinghasbeensacrificedtoperspicuity。
Myprincipalaimshallbetodiscovertruth,andtoenablemyreadertotouchtheverylinkofthechainwhereImayatanytimegoastray。
Mybusinessshallnotbetoseekfornewthoughts,buttoreasonconsequentially;andifanythingnewshallbefound,itwillbeintheconclusions。
Longstepsinpoliticalreasoningleadtoerror:closereasoningistedious,andtomanyappearstrivial:this,however,mustbemyplan,andmyconsolationis,thatthefartherI
advance,Ishallbecomethemoreinteresting。
Everysuppositionmustbeconsideredasstrictlyrelativetothecircumstancespresupposed;andthough,inordertopreventmisapplication,andtoavoidabstractionasmuchaspossible,I
frequentlymakeuseofexamplesforillustratingeveryprinciple;
yetthese,whicharetakenfrommattersoffact,mustbesupposeddivestedofeveryforeigncircumstanceinconsistentwiththesupposition。
Ishallcombatnoparticularopinioninsuchintricatematters;thoughsometimesImaypasstheminreview,inordertopointouthowIamledtodifferfromthem。
Ipretendtoformnosystem,but,bytracingoutasuccessionofprinciples,consistentwiththenatureofmanandwithoneanother,Ishallendeavourtofurnishsomematerialstowardstheformingofagoodone。
Chap。I
OftheGovernmentofMankindManwefindactinguniformlyinallage,inallcountries,andinallclimates,fromtheprinciplesofself-interest,expediency,duty,orpassion。Inthisheisalike,innothingelse。
Thesemotivesofhumanactionsproducesuchavarietyofcircumstances,thatifweconsidertheseveralspeciesofanimalsinthecreation,weshallfindtheindividualsofnoclasssounliketooneanother,asmantoman。Nowonderthenifpeopledifferinopinionwithregardtoeverythingalmostwhichrelatestoourspecies。
Asthisnobleanimalisasociablecreature,bothfromnecessityandinclination,wefindalso,inallages,climatesandcountries,acertainmodificationofgovernmentandsubordinationestablishedamongthem。Hereagainwearepresentedwithasgreatavariety,astherearedifferentsocieties;allhoweveragreeinginthis,thattheendofavoluntarysubordinationtoauthorityiswithaviewtopromotethegeneralgood。
Constantanduninterruptedexperiencehasprovedtoman,thatvirtueandjustice,inthosewhogovern,aresufficienttorenderthesocietyhappy,underanyformofgovernment。Virtueandjustice,whenappliedtogovernment,meannomorethanatenderaffectionforthewholesociety,andanexactandimpartialregardfortheinterestofeveryclass。
Allactions,andallthingsindeed,aregoodorbadbyrelationonly。Nothingissocomplexasrelationswhenconsideredwithregardtoasociety,andnothingissodifficultastodiscovertruth,wheninvolvedandblendedwiththeserelations。
Wearenottoconcludefromthis,thateveryoperationofgovernmentmustbecomeproblematicalanduncertainastoitsconsequences:someareevidentlygood;othersarenotoriouslybad;those,thetendencyofwhichislessevident,arealwaystheleastessential,andthemorecomplextheyappeartoadiscerningeye,themoretrivialtheyarefoundtobeintheirimmediateconsequences。
Agovernmentmustbecontinuallyinaction,andoneprincipalobjectofitsattentionmustbe,theconsequencesandeffectsofnewinstitutions。
Experiencealonewillshew,whathumanprudencecouldnotforesee;andmistakesmustbecorrectedasoftenasexpediencyrequires。
Allgovernmentshavewhattheycalltheirfundamentallaws;
butfundamental,thatis,invariablelaws,canneversubsistamongmen,themostvariablethingweknow:theonlyfundamentallaw,saluspopuli,musteverberelative,likeeveryotherthing。
Butthisisratheramaximthanalaw。
Itishoweverexpedient,nayabsolutelynecessary,thatineverystate,certainlawsbesupposedfundamentalandinvariable:
bothtoserveasacurbtotheambitionofindividuals,andtopointouttothestatesmantheoutlines,orsketchofthatplanofgovernment,whichexperiencehasprovedtobethebestadaptedtothespiritofhispeople。
Suchlawsmayevenbeconsideredasactuallyinvariable,whileastatesubsistswithoutconvulsionsorrevolutions;
becausethenthealterationsaresogradual,thattheybecomeimperceptibletoall,butthemostdiscerning,whocancomparethecustomsandmannersofthesamepeopleindifferentperiodsoftimeandunderdifferentcircumstances。
Aswehavetakenforgrantedthefundamentalmaxim,thateveryoperationofgovernmentshouldbecalculatedforthegoodofthepeople,sowemaywithequalcertaintydecide,thatinordertomakeapeoplehappy,theymustbegovernedaccordingtothespiritwhichprevailsamongthem。
IamnexttoexplainwhatImeanbythespiritofapeople,andtoshowhowfarthisspiritmustbemadetoinfluencethegovernmentofeverysociety。
Chap。II
OftheSpiritofaPeopleThespiritofapeopleisformeduponasetofreceivedopinionsrelativetothreeobjects;morals,government,andmanners:theseoncegenerallyadoptedbyanysociety,confirmedbylongandconstanthabit,andnevercalledinquestion,formthebasisofalllaws,regulatetheformofeverygovernment,anddeterminewhatiscommonlycalledthecustomsofacountry。
Toknowapeople,wemustexaminethemunderthesegeneralheads。Weacquiretheknowledgeoftheirmoralswithease,byconsultingthetenetsoftheirreligion,andfromwhatistaughtamongthembyauthority。
Thesecond,orgovernment,ismoredisguised,asitisconstantlychangingfromcircumstances,partlyresultingfromdomesticandpartlyfromforeignconsiderations。Athoroughknowledgeoftheirhistory,andconversationwiththeirministersofstate,maygiveone,whohasaccesstothesehelps,averycompetentknowledgeofthisbranch。
Thelast,ortheknowledgeofthemannersofapeople,isbyfarthemostdifficulttoacquire,andyetisthemostopentoeveryperson’sobservation。Certaincircumstanceswithregardtomannersaresupposedbyeveryoneinthecountrytobesowellknown,sogenerallyfollowedandobserved,thatitseldomoccurstoanybodytoinformastrangerconcerningthem。Inonecountrynothingissoinjuriousasastrokewithastick,orevenagesturewhichimpliesadesignoradesiretostrike。inanotherastrokeisnotnearsooffensiveasanopprobriousexpression。
Aninnocentlibertywiththefairsex,whichinonecountrypasseswithoutcensure,islookeduponinanotherasthehighestindignity。Ingeneral,theopinionofapeoplewithregardtoinjuriesisestablishedbycustomonly,andnothingismorenecessaryingovernment,thananexactattentiontoeverycircumstancepeculiartothepeopletobegoverned。
ThekingdomofSpainwaslostforaviolencecommitteduponchastity;2*thecityofGenoaforablow;3*thekingdomsofNaplesandSicilyhaveeverbeenreadytorevolt;becausehavingbeenformanyagesunderthedominionofstrangers,thepeoplehaveneverbeengovernedaccordingtothetruespiritoftheirmanners。Letusconsulttherevolutionsofallcountries,andweshallfind,thatthemosttrivialcircumstanceshavehadagreaterinfluenceonsuchevents,thanthemoreweightyreasons,whicharealwayssetforthastherealmotives。Ineednotenlargeuponthissubject,myintentionisonlytosuggestanideawhichanyonemaypursue,andwhichwillbeapplieduponmanyoccasionsaswegoalong;forthereisnotreatinganypointwhichregardsthepoliticaloeconomyofanation,withoutaccompanyingtheexamplewithsomesuppositionrelativetothespiritofthepeople。
Ihavesaid,thatthemostdifficultthingtolearnconcerningapeople,isthespiritoftheirmanners。
Consequently,themostdifficultthingforastrangertoadopt,istheirmanner。Menacquirethelanguage,nayevenlosetheforeignaccent,beforetheylosethepeculiarityoftheirmanner。
Thereasonisplain。Theinclinationsmustbechanged,thetasteforamusementsmustbenew-modelled;establishedmaimsupongovernment,manners,nayevenuponsomemoralactions,mustundergocertainnewmodifications,beforethestranger’sconversationandbehaviourcanbecomeconsistentwiththespiritofthepeoplewithwhomhelives。
Fromtheseconsiderations,wemayfindthereason,whynothingismoreheavytobearthanthegovernmentofconquerors,inspiteofalltheirendeavourstorenderthemselvesagreeabletotheconquered。Ofthis,experiencehaseverprovedthetruth,andprincesaresomuchpersuadedofit,thatwhenacountryissubduedinourdays,orwhenitotherwisechangesmasters,thereisseldomanyquestionofaltering,butbyveryslowdegreesandlengthoftime,theestablishedlawsandcustomsoftheinhabitants。Imightsafelysay,thereisnoformofgovernmentuponearthsoexcellentinitself,as,necessarily,tomakethepeoplehappyunderit。Freedomitself,imposeduponapeoplegroaningunderthegreatestslavery,willnotmakethemhappy,unlessitismadetoundergocertainmodifications,relativetotheirestablishedhabits。
HavingexplainedwhatImeanbythespiritofapeople,I
comenexttoconsider,howfarthisspiritmustinfluencegovernment。
Ifgovernmentsbetakeningeneral,weshallfindthemanalogoustothespiritofthepeople。Butthepointunderconsiderationis,howastatesmanistoproceed,whenexpediencyandrefinementrequireachangeofadministration,orwhenitbecomesnecessaryfromachangeofcircumstances。
ThegreatalterationintheaffairsofEuropewithinthesethreecenturies,bythediscoveryofAmericaandtheIndies,thespringingupofindustryandlearning,theintroductionoftradeandtheluxuriousarts,theestablishmentofpubliccredit,andageneralsystemoftaxation,haveentirelyalteredtheplanofgovernmenteverywhere。
Fromfeudalandmilitary,itisbecomefreeandcommercial。I
opposefreedomingovernmenttothefeudalsystem,tomarkonlythatthereisnotfoundnowthatchainofsubordinationamongthesubjects,whichmadetheessentialpartofthefeudalform。Theheadtherehadlittlepower,andthelowerclassesofthepeoplelittleliberty。Noweveryindustriousman,wholiveswithoeconomy,isfreeandindependentundermostformsofgovernment。
Formerly,thepowerofthebaronsswalloweduptheindependencyofallinferiorclasses。Iopposecommercialtomilitary;becausethemilitarygovernmentsnowaremadetosubsistfromtheconsequencesandeffectsofcommerceonly。thatis,fromtherevenueofthestate,proceedingfromtaxes。Formerly,everythingwasbroughtaboutbynumbers;now,numbersofmencannotbekepttogetherwithoutmoney。
Thisissufficienttopointoutthenatureoftherevolutioninthepoliticalstate,andofconsequenceinthemannersofEurope。
Thespiritofapeoplechangesnodoubtofitself,butbyslowdegrees。Thesamegenerationcommonlyadherestothesameprinciples,andretainsthesamespirit。Ineverycountrywefindtwogenerationsuponthestageatatime;thatistosay,wemaydistributeintotwoclassesthespiritwhichprevails;theoneamongstmenbetweentwentyandthirty,whenopinionsareforming;
theotherofthosewhoarepastfifty,whenopinionsandhabitsareformedandconfirmed。Apersonofjudgmentandobservationmayforeseemanythingsrelativetogovernment,fromanexactattentiontotheriseandprogressofnewcustomsandopinions,providedhepreservehismindfreefromallattachmentsandprejudices,infavourofthosewhichhehimselfhasadopted,andinthatdelicacyofsensationnecessarytoperceivetheinfluenceofachangeofcircumstances。Thisisthegeniuspropertoformagreatminister。
Ineverynewstepthespiritofthepeopleshouldbefirstexamined;andifthisbenotfoundripefortheexecutionoftheplan,itoughttobeputoff,keptentirelysecret,andeverymethodusedtopreparethepeopletorelishtheinnovation。
TheprojectofintroducingpoperyintoEnglandwasblownbeforeitwasputinpractice,andsomiscarried。QueenElizabethkeptherownsecret,andsucceededinasimilarattempt。Theschemeofageneralexcisewaspushedwithtoomuchvivacity,wasmadeamatterofparty,wasill-timed,andthepeoplenowisepreparedforit;henceitwillbethemoredifficulttobringaboutatanothertime,withoutthegreatestprecautions。
Inturningandworkinguponthespiritofapeople,nothingisimpossibletoanablestatesman。Whenapeoplecanbeengagedtomurdertheirwivesandchildren,andtoburnthemselves,ratherthansubmittoaforeignenemy,whentheycanbebroughttogivetheirmostpreciouseffects,theirornamentsofgoldandsilver,forthesupportofacommoncause;whenwomenarebroughttogivetheirhairtomakeropes,andthemostdecrepitoldmentomountthewallsofatownforitsdefence;IthinkImaysay,thatbyproperlyconductingandmanagingthespiritofapeople,nothingisimpossibletobeaccomplished。ButwhenIsay,nothingisimpossible,Imustbeunderstoodtomean,thatnothingessentiallynecessaryforthegoodofthepeopleisimpossible;
andthisisallthatisrequiredingovernment。
Thatitrequiresaparticulartalentinastatesmantodisposethemindsofapeopletoapproveevenoftheschemewhichisthemostconducivetotheirinterestandprosperity,appearsfromthis,thatweseeexamplesofwise,rich,andpowerfulnationslanguishingininactivity,atatimewheneveryindividualisanimatedwithaquitecontraryspirit;becomingapreytotheirenemies,likethecityofJerusalem,whiletheyaretakenupwiththeirdomesticanimosities,merelybecausetheremediesproposedagainsttheseevilscontradictthespiritofthetimes。
Thegreatartofgoverningistodivestoneselfofprejudicesandattachmentstoparticularopinions,particularclasses,andabovealltoparticularpersons;toconsultthespiritofthepeople,togivewaytoitinappearance,andinsodoingtogiveitaturncapableofinspiringthosesentimentswhichmayinducethemtorelishthechange,whichanalterationofcircumstanceshasrenderednecessary。
Cananychangebegreateramongfreemen,thanfromastateofabsolutelibertyandindependencetobecomesubjecttoconstraintinthemosttrivialactions?ThischangehashowevertakenplaceoverallEuropewithinthesethreehundredyears,andyetwethinkourselvesmorefreethaneverourfatherswere。
Formerlyagentlemanwhoenjoyedabitofland,knewnotwhatitwastohaveanydemandmadeuponhim,butinvirtueofobligationsbyhimselfcontracted。Hedisposedofthefruitsoftheearth,andofthelabourofhisservantsorvassals,ashethoughtfit。Everythingwasbought,sold,transferred,transported,modified,andcomposed,forprivateconsumption,orforpublicuse,withouteverthestate’sbeingoncefoundinterestedinwhatwasdoing。This,Isay,wasformerlythegeneralsituationofEurope,amongfreenationsunderaregularadministration;andtheonlyimpositionscommonlyknowntoaffectlandedmen,weremadeinconsequenceofacontractofsubordination,feudalorother,whichhadcertainlimitations;
andtheimpositionswereappropriatedforcertainpurposes。
Dailyexperienceshews,thatnothingismoreagainsttheinclinationsofapeoplethantheimpositionoftaxes;andthelesstheyareaccustomedtothem,themoredifficultitistogetthemestablished。
Thegreatabuseofgovernorsintheapplicationoftaxescontributesnotalittletoentertainandaugmentthisrepugnancyinthegoverned:butbesidesabuse,thereisoftentoolittlemanagementusedtopreparethespiritsofthepeopleforsuchinnovations;forweseethemuponmanyoccasionssubmittingwithcheerfulnesstoveryheavyimpositions,providedtheyhewell-timed,andconsistentwiththeirmannersanddisposition。A
Frenchgentleman,whocannotbearthethoughtofbeingputuponalevelwithapeasantinpayingaland-tax,payscontentedly,intimeofwar,ageneraltaxuponallhiseffects,underadifferentname。Topayforyourheadisterribleinonecountry;
topayforlightappearsasterribleinanother。
Itoftenhappens,thatstatesmentakethehintofnewimpositionsfromtheexampleofothernations,andnotfromaniceexaminationoftheirowndomesticcircumstances。Butwhenthesearerightlyattendedto,itbecomeseasytodiscoverthemeansofexecutingthesameplan,inawayquiteadaptedtothespirit,temper,andcircumstancesofthepeople。Whenstrangersareemployedasstatesmen,thedisorderisstillgreater,unlesstherebeextraordinarypenetration,temper,and,aboveall,flexibilityanddiscretion。
Statesmenhavesometimesrecoursetoartificeinsteadofreason,becausetheirintentionsoftenarenotupright。Thisdestroysallconfidencebetweenthemandthepeople;andconfidenceisnecessarywhenyouareinamannerobligedtoaskafavour,orwhenwhatyoudemandisnotindisputablyyourright。A
peoplethustrickedintoanimposition,thoughexpedientfortheirprosperity,willopposeviolently,atanothertime,alikemeasure,evenwhenessentialtotheirpreservation。
Atothertimes,weseestatesmenpresentingtheallurementofpresentease,preciselyatthetimewhenpeople’smindsarebestdisposedtoreceiveaburden。Imeanwhenwarthreatens,andwhenthemindisheatedwitharesentmentofinjuries。Isitnotwonderful,atsuchatimeasthis,toincreasetaxesinproportiononlytotheinterestofmoneywanted;doesnotthisimplyashortsightedness,oratleastanindifferenceastowhatistocome?Isitnotmorenatural,thatapeopleshouldconsenttocomeunderburdenstogratifyrevenge,thansubmittorepayalargedebtwhentheirmindsarerestoredtoastateoftranquility。
FromtheexamplesIhavegiven,IhopewhatImeanbythespiritofapeopleissufficientlyunderstood,andIthinkIhaveabundantlyshewnthenecessityofitsbeingproperlydisposed,inordertoestablisharightplanofoeconomy。Thisissotrue,thatmanyexamplesmaybefound,ofapeople’srejectingthemostbeneficialinstitutions,andeventhegreatestfavours,merelybecausesomecircumstancehadshockedtheirestablishedcustoms。
Nowonderthen,ifweseethemrefusetocomeunderlimitations,restraints,andburdens,whentheutmosttheycanbeflatteredwithfromthem,isadistantprospectofnationalgood。
Ihavefounditnecessarytopremisethesegeneralreflections,inordertoobviatemanyobjectionswhichmightnaturallyenoughoccurintheperusalofthisinquiry。Ishallhaveoccasiontomakeanumberofsuppositions,andtodrawconsequencesfromthem,whichareabundantlynatural,providedaproperspiritinthepeoplebepresupposed,butwhichwouldbefarfrombeingnaturalwithoutthissupposition。Isuppose,forexample,thatapoorman,loadedwithmanychildren,wouldbegladtohavethestatemaintainthem;thatanother,whohaswastelands,wouldbeobligedtoonewhowouldgratuitouslybuildhimafarm-houseuponit。yetinbothsuppositionsImayprovemistaken;forfathersthereare,whowouldratherseetheirchildrendeadthanoutoftheirhands;andproprietorsaretobefound,who,forthesakeofhunting,wouldlaythefinestcountryinEuropeintoawaste。
InordertocommunicateanadequateideaofwhatIunderstandbypoliticaloeconomy,Ihaveexplainedtheterm,bypointingouttheobjectoftheart;whichis,toprovidefood,othernecessaries,andemploymenttoeveryoneofthesociety。
Thisisaverysimpleandaverygeneralmethodofdefiningamostcomplicatedoperation。
Toprovideaproperemploymentforallthemembersofasociety,isthesameastomodelandconducteverybranchoftheirconcerns。
Uponthisideamaybeformed,Ithink,themostextensivebasisforaninquiryintotheprinciplesofpoliticaloeconomy。
Thenextthingtobedone,istofalluponadistinctmethodofanalysingsoextensiveasubject,bycontrivingatrainofideas,whichmaybedirectedtowardseverypartoftheplan,andwhich,atthesametime,maybemadetoarisemethodicallyfromoneanother。
ForthispurposeIhavetakenahintfromwhatthelaterevolutionsinthepoliticsofEuropehavepointedouttobetheregularprogressofmankind,fromgreatsimplicitytocomplicatedrefinement。
Thisfirstbookshallthensetoutwithtakingupsocietyinthecradle,asImaysay。Ishallhereexaminetheprincipleswhichinfluencetheirmultiplication,themethodofprovidingfortheirsubsistence,theoriginoftheirlabour,theeffectsoftheirlibertyandslavery,thedistributionofthemintoclasses,withsomeothertopicswhichrelatetomankindingeneral。
Hereweshallfindtheprinciplesofindustryinfluencingthemultiplicationofmankind,andthecultivationofthesoil。ThisIhavethrowninonpurposetopreparemyreaderforthesubjectofthesecondbook;wherehewillfindthesameprincipleunderthewingsoflibertyprovidinganeasysubsistenceforanumerouspopulace,bythemeansoftrade,whichsendsthelabourofanindustriouspeopleoverthewholeworld。
Fromtheexperienceofwhathashappenedtheselasttwohundredyears,wefindtowhatapitchthetradeandindustryofEuropehasincreasedalienations,andthecirculationofmoney。I
shallthereforecloselyadheretothese,asthemostimmediateconsequencesoftheprecedingimprovement;and,byanalysingthem,Ishallformmythirdandfourthbooks,inwhichIintendtotreatofmoneyandcredit。
Weseealsohowcredithasengagednationstoavailthemselvesofitintheirwars,andhow,bytheuseofit,theyhavebeenledtocontractdebts;whichtheynevercansatisfyandpay,withoutimposingtaxes。Thedoctrine,then,ofdebtsandtaxeswillverynaturallyfollowthatofcreditinthisgreatchainofpoliticalconsequences。
Bythiskindofhistoricalclue,Ishallconductmyselfthroughthegreatavenuesofthisextensivelabyrinth;andinmyreviewofeveryparticulardistrict,Ishallstepfromconsequencetoconsequence,untilIhavepenetratedintotheinmostrecessesofmyownunderstanding。
Whenasubjectisbrokenoff,IshallrendermytransitionsasgradualasIcan,bystillpreservingsomechainofconnexion;
andalthoughIcannotflattermyselfinsuchinfinitevarietyofchoice,astoorderanddistributiontohitatalltimesonthatmethod,whichmayappeartoeveryreaderthemostnaturalandthemostcorrect,yetIshallsparenopainsincastingthematerialsintodifferentforms,soastomakethebestdistributionoftheminmypower。
Chap。III
UponwhatPrinciples,andfromwhatnaturalCausesdoMankindmultiply?AndwhataretheEffectsofProcreationinCountrieswhereNumbersarefoundtoincrease?
Themultiplicationofmankindhasbeentreatedofindifferentways;somehavemadeouttablestoshowtheprogressionofmultiplication,othershavetreatedthequestionhistorically。
Thestateofnumbersindifferentagesoftheworld,orindifferentcountriesatdifferenttimes,hasbeenmadetheobjectofinquiry;andthemostexactscrutinyhasbeenmadeintoancientauthors,asthemeansofinvestigatingthetruthofthismatter。Allpassagesrelativetothesubjecthavebeenlaidtogether,andaccompaniedwithglossesandinterpretationsthemostplausible,inordertodeterminethemainquestion。TheelaborateperformancesofMrHume,andDrWallace,whohaveadoptedoppositeopinionsinregardtothepopulousnessoftheancientworld,haveleftnothingnewtobesaiduponthissubject;atleasttheapplicationtheyappeartohavegiveninexaminingtheancients,isagreatdiscouragementtoanyonewhomightotherwisestillflatterhimselftofindoutcircumstancesinthem,propertocastanewlightuponthequestion。
Myintentioninthischapterisnottodecide,noreventogivemyopinionuponthatmatter,farlesstocombattheargumentsadvancedoneitherside。Iamtoconsiderthequestionunderadifferentpointofview;nottoinquirewhatnumbersofpeoplewerefoundupontheearthatacertaintime,buttoexaminethenaturalandrationalcausesofmultipliCation。Ifwecandiscoverthese,wemayperhapsbeledtojudgehowfartheymighthaveoperatedindifferentagesandindifferentcountries。
Thefundamentalprincipleofthemultiplicationofallanimals,andconsequentlyofman,isgeneration;thenextisfood:generationgivesexistence,foodpreservesit。Didtheearthproduceofitselfthepropernourishmentformanwithunlimitedabundance,weshouldfindnooccasiontolabourinordertoprocureit。Nowinallcountriesfoundinhabited,asinthosewhichhavebeenfounddesolate,ifthestateofanimalsbeinquiredinto,thenumberofthemwillbefoundinproportiontothequantityoffoodproducedbytheearth,regularlythroughouttheyear,fortheirsubsistence。Isay,regularlythroughouttheyear,becauseweperceive,inthoseanimalswhichproduceingreatabundance,suchasallthefeatheredsort,thatvastmultitudesaredestroyedinwinter;theyarebroughtforthwiththefruitsoftheearth,andfallinproportiontotheirdecay。
Thisprincipleissonatural,thatIthinkitcanhardlybecontroverted。
Astoman,theearthdoesnotspontaneouslyproducenourishmentforhiminanyconsiderabledegree。Iallowthatassomespeciesofanimalssupportlifebydevouringothers,somayman;butitmustbeobserved,thatthespeciesfeedingmustalwaysbemuchinferiorinnumbertothespeciesfedupon。Thisisevidentinreasonandinfact。
Weretheearththereforeuncultivated,thenumbersofmankindwouldnotexceedtheproportionofthespontaneousfruitswhichsheoffersfortheirimmediateuse,orforthatoftheanimalswhichmightbethepropernourishmentofman。
Thereisthereforeacertainnumberofmankindwhichtheearthwouldbeabletomaintainwithoutanylabour:allowmetocallthisquantityA。Doesitnot,fromthisexpositionofthematter,appearplain,thatwithoutlabourAnevercanincreaseanymorethananimals,whichdonotworkforthemselves,canincreasebeyondtheproportionoffoodprovidedforthembynature?Letitbehoweverobserved,thatIdonotpretendtolimitAtoadeterminatenumber。Theseasonswillnodoubtinfluencethenumbersofmankind,asweseetheyinfluencetheplentyofotheranimals;butIsayAwillneverincreasebeyondthefixedproportionabovementioned。
Havingresolvedonequestionwithregardtomultiplication,andshewnthatnumbersmustbecomegreaterorsmalleraccordingtotheproductionsofnature,Icometothesecondthingproposedtobetreatedofinthechapter;towit,whatwillbecomeofthegenerativefacultyafterithasproducedthefullproportionofA,andwhateffectswillafterwardsfollow。
Weseehowbeneficent,Imighthavesaidprodigal,natureisinbestowinglifebygeneration。Severalkindsofanimals,especiallyinsects,multiplybythousands,andyetthespeciesdoesnotappearannuallytoincrease。Nobodycanpretendthatparticularindividualsofanyspecieshaveaprivilegetolive,andthatothersdiefromadifferenceintheirnature。Itisthereforereasonabletoconclude,thatwhatdestroyssuchvastquantitiesofthoseproduced,mustbe,amongothercauses,thewantoffood。Letusapplythistoman。
Thosewhoaresupposedtobefedwiththespontaneousfruitsoftheearth,cannot,fromwhathasbeensaid,multiplybeyondthatproportion;atthesametimethegenerativefacultywillworkitsnaturaleffectsinaugmentingnumbers。Theconsequencewillbe,thatcertainindividualsmustbecomeworsefed,consequentlyweaker。consequently,if,inthatweaklystate,natureshouldwithholdapartofherusualplenty,thewholemultitudewillbeaffectedbyit;adiseasemaytakeplace,andsweepoffafargreaternumberthanthatproportionedtothedeficiencyoftheseason。Whatresultsfromthis?Thatthosewhohaveescaped,findingfoodmoreplentiful,becomevigorousandstrong。generationgiveslifetoadditionalnumbers,foodpreservesit,untiltheyriseuptotheformerstandard。
Thusthegenerativefacultyresemblesaspringloadedwithaweight,whichalwaysexertsitselfinproportiontothediminutionofresistance:whenfoodhasremainedsometimewithoutaugmentationordiminution,generationwillcarrynumbersashighaspossible;ifthenfoodcometobediminished,thespringisoverpowered;theforceofitbecomeslessthannothing。
Inhabitantswilldiminish,atleast,inproportiontotheovercharge。If,upontheotherhand,foodbeincreased,thespringwhichstoodat0,willbegintoexertitselfinproportionastheresistancediminishes;peoplewillbegintobebetterfed;
theywillmultiply,and,inproportionastheyincreaseinnumbers,thefoodwillbecomescarceagain。
Imustheresubjoinaremarkveryanalogoustothissubject。
Thatthegenerativefacultyinmanwhichwehavecomparedtoaspring,andthecareandlovewehaveforourchildren,firstpromptustomultiply,andthenengageustodividewhatwehavewithourlittleones。Thusfromdividingandsubdividingithappens,thatineverycountrywherefoodislimitedtoacertainquantity,theinhabitantsmustbesubsistedinaregularprogression,descendingdownfromplentyandamplesubsistence,tothelastperiodsofwant,andevensometimesstarvingforhunger。
Althoughtheexamplesofthislastextremityarenotcommoninsomecountries,yetIbelievetheyaremoresothanisgenerallyimagined;andtheotherstagesofwantareproductiveofmanydiseases,andofadecaywhichextinguishesthefacultyofgeneration,orwhichweakensit,soastoproducechildrenlessvigorousandlesshealthy。Iappealtoexperience,ifthisreasoningbenotjust。
Puttwoorthreepairsofrabbitsintoafieldproperforthem,themultiplicationwillberapid;andinafewyearsthewarrenwillbestocked:youmaytakeyearlyfromitahundredpairs,Ishallsuppose,andkeepyourwarreningoodorder:giveovertakinganyforsomeyears,youwillperhapsfindyouroriginalstockratherdiminishedthanincreased,forthereasonsabovementioned。AfricayearlyfurnishesmanythousandsforthecultivationofAmerica;inthissheresemblesthewarren。Ihavelittledoubtbutthatifallhersonswerereturnedtoheratonce,byfarthegreaterpartwoulddieofhunger。