CountEustacetonameafewhad12,GeoffreydeMandeville2,theAbbotofWestminster4,theAbbessofBarking3,andseeminglytothesehousesnostripsinthearablefieldswereattached。79*Thus,thoughmanyoftheburgessesmaytillthesoil,theboroughcommunityisnotanagrariancommunity。Wecannottreatitasavillagecommunitythathasprosperedandslowlychangeditshabits。Anewprinciplehasbeenintroduced,anelementofheterogeneity。Themenwhomeeteachotherincourtandmarket,themenwhowillhereafterfarmthecourtandmarket,arenottheshareholdersinanagriculturalconcern。
Thattenurialheterogeneityofwhichwehavebeenspeakinghadanotherimportanteffect。Wheninlaterdaysaruralmanorisbeingraisedtotherankofaliberburgus,theintroductionof\'burgagetenure\'seemstoberegardedastheveryessenceoftheenfranchisement。80*Probablythisfeaturehadappearedinmanyboroughsatanearlydate。ThelordwithlandsinOxfordshiremayhavebeenboundtokeepafewhousesandretainersinOxford。If,however,thecommercialelementinthetownbegantogetthebetterofthemilitaryelement,ifOxfordbecameacentreoftrade,thenahouseinOxfordcouldbeletforamoneyrent。InDomesdayBookthebaronsaredrawingrentsfromtheirboroughhouses。Ifanyreturnistobemadebytheoccupiertotheowneritwilltaketheformofamoneyrent;itcanhardlytakeanotherform。Thustenureatamoneyrentwouldbecomethetypicaltenureofaburgagetenement。Itwillbeasecurelyheritabletenure,becausethelandlordisanabsenteeandhastoofewtenantsinthetowntorequirethecareofaresidentreeve。Buttheremayhavebeenmanydwellersinsomeoftheboroughswhowereboundtohelpinthecultivationofastretchofroyalorepiscopaldemesnethatlayclosetothewalls。Inthewestsomeoftheking\'sburgessesseemtohavebeenholdingunderonerousterms。
AtShrewsbury,whichliesneartheborderofWaleswhereeverygirl\'smarriagegaverisetoanamobyr,amaidhadtopayten,awidowtwentyshillingswhenshetookahusband,andareliefoftenshillingswasduewhenaburgessdied。81*AtHerefordthereeve\'sconsentwasnecessarywhenaburgagewastobesold,andhetookathirdoftheprice。WhenaburgessdiedthekinggothishorseandarmstheseHerefordburgesseswerefightingmen;
ifhehadnohorse,thentenshillings\'orhislandwiththehouses。\'Anyonewhowastoopoortodohisservicemightabandonhistenementtothereevewithouthavingtopayforit。Suchanentryasthisseemstotellusthattheserviceswerenotrivialreturnforthetenement。82*
Ontheotherhand,wemayseeatStamfordwhatseemtobetheremainsofaveryfreegroupofsettlers,presumablyDanes。Thetowncontainsamongotherhouses77housesofsokemen\'whoholdtheirlandsindemesneandseeklordswherevertheyplease,andoverwhomthekinghasnothingbutwiteandheriotandtoll。\'
Thesemaybethesamepersonswhohold272acresoflandandpaynorentforit。83*AtNorwich,again,weseemtohearofatimewhentheburgesseswerefreetocommendthemselvestowhomevertheywould,andwerethereforelivinginhouseswhichwerealltheirown,andforwhichtheypaidnorent。84*Itisverypossiblethat,sofaraslandlordlyrightsareconcerned,therewasasmuchdifferencebetweentheeasternandthewesterntownsastherewasbetweentheeasternandthewesternvillages。Stillifwelookatboroughafterborough,tenureatamoneyrentisthetenureoftheburgagehousesthatweexpecttofind,andsuchatenure,evenifinitsoriginithasbeenprecarious,islikelytobecomeheritableandsecure。Astotheshirethegns,theyhaveinsomecasespaidtothekingsmallrentsfortheirhaws;butinothers,forexampleatOxford,tenurebywall-workhasbeentheirtenure,andwheninothertownswefindthempayingrenttothekingwemayperhapsseecommutedwall-work。
TracesarefewinDomesdayBookofanypropertythatcanberegardedasthepropertyofanascentmunicipalcorporation,andevenofanythatcanbecalledthejointorcommonpropertyoftheburgesses。Ingeneraleachburgessholdshishouseinthetownofthekingorofsomeotherlordbyaseveraltitle,and,ifhehaslaodintheneighbouringfields,thisalsoheholdsbyaseveraltitle。\'IntheboroughofNottinghamtherewereinKingEdward\'sday183burgessesand19villani。Tothisboroughbelong6carucatesoflandfortheking\'sgeldandonemeadowandcertainsmallwoods……Thislandwasdividedbetween38burgessesand[theking]received75s。7d。fromtherentofthelandandtheworksoftheburgesses。\'\'IntheboroughofDerbytherewereinKingEdward\'sday243residentburgesses……Tothisboroughbelong12carucatesoflandforthegeld,buttheymightbeploughedby8teams。Thislandwasdividedamong41burgesseswhohad12teams。85*Inthesecasesweseeplainlyenoughthatsucharablelandasisinanywayconnectedwiththeboroughhasbeenheldbybutafewoutofthetotalnumberoftheburgesses。
Thereforewemustdealcautiouslywithentriesthatarelessexplicit。When,forexample,inthedescriptionofStamfordweread“Lagemannietburgenseshabentcclxxiiacrassineomniconsuetudine,\'86*wemustnotatoncedecidethatthereisanyownershipbytheburgessesasacorporation,oranyjointownership,oreventhatalltheburgesseshavestripsinthesefields,thoughapparentlytheburgesseswhohavestripspaynorentforthem。Thisisthefactandtheonlyfactthatthecommissionersdesiretorecord。Theydonotcarewhethereveryburgesshasapiece,orwhetheraswascertainlythecaseelsewhereonlysomeofthemheldlandoutsidethewalls。WhenofNorwichweread\'etinburgotenentburgensesxliiicapellas,\'87*wedonotsupposethatalltheNorwichburghershavechapels,stilllessthattheyholdtheforty-threechapelsasco-owners,stilllessthatthesechapelsbelongtoacorporation。WerememberthattheLatinlanguagehasneitheradefinitenoranindefinitearticle。Thereforewhenof80acresatCanterbury,whicharenowheldbyRalphdeColombiers,weread\'quastenebantburgensesinalodiaderege,\'weneednotsupposethattheseacreshadbelongedtothei。e。toalltheburgessesofCanterbury。88*SoofExeteritiswritten:\'BurgensesExoniaeurbishabentextracivitatemterramxiicaruc[arum]quaenullamconsuetudinemredduntnisiadipsamcivitatem。\'This,thoughanotherinterpretationispossible,mayonlymeanthatthereareoutsidethecitytwelveplough-landswhichareheldbyburgesseswhoserentsgotomakeupthatsumof?8whichispaidtotheking,orratherinparttothesheriffandinparttothequeendowager,asthefermofthecity。89*ConcerningColchesterthereisanentrywhichperhapsascribestothecommunityofburgessestheownershiporthetenancyoffourscoreacresoflandandofastripeightperchesinwidthsurroundingthetownwall;butthisentryisexceedinglyobscure。90*
AnotherdarkcaseoccursatCanterbury。Wearetoldthattheburgessesorcertainburgessesusedtoholdlandoftheking\'intheirgild。\'91*AlongwiththiswemustreadanotherpassagewhichstateshowinthesamecitytheArchbishophastwelveburgessesandthirty-twohouseswhich\'theclerksofthevillholdintheirgild。\'Apparentlyinthislastcasewehaveaclericalcluborfraternityholdingland,andtheburgher\'sgildmaybeofmuchthesamenature,avoluntaryassociation。NotverylongafterthedateofDomesday,forAnselmwasstillalive,anexchangeoflandswasmadebetweentheconventhired,familia
ofChristChurchandthe\'cnihts\'ofthechapmangildofCanterbury。Thetransactiontakesplacebetweenthe\'hired\'ontheonehand,the\'heap\'forsuchisthewordemployedontheother。ThewitnessestothistransactionareArchbishopAnselmandthe\'hired\'ontheonehand,Calvealtheportreeveand\'theeldestmenoftheheap\'ontheother。92*Buttoseeamunicipalcorporationintheburghers\'gildofDomesdayBookwouldbeveryrash。Wedonotknowthatalltheburghersbelongedtoitorthatithadanygovernmentalfunctions。93*
Wemayofcoursefindthatagroupofburgesseshas\'rightsofcommon;\'butrightsofcommon,thoughtheyarerightswhicharetobeenjoyedincommon,areapttobecommonrightsinnoothersense,foreachcommonerhasaseveraltitletosendhisbeastsontothepasture。Thus\'alltheburgessesofOxfordhavepastureincommonoutsidethewallwhichbringsin[totheking]
6s。8d。\'94*Thesoilistheking\'s;theburgessespayfortherightofgrazingit。Theroundnessofthesumthattheypayseemsindeedtohintatsomearrangementbetweenthekingandtheburgessestakeninmass;butprobablyeachburgess,andthelordofeachburgess,regardarightofpastureasappurtenanttoaburgagetenement。Thecaseisstriking,forwehaveseenhowheterogeneousagrouptheseOxfordburgesseswere。95*Nolessthannineprelates,tosaynothingofearlsandbarons,hadburgessesinthecity。WemustgreatlydoubtwhetherthereisanypowerinanyassemblyoftheburgessestotakefromtheBishopofWinchesterortheCountofMortainthecustomaryrightsofpasturethathavebeenenjoyedbythetenantsofhistenements。
Wemightperhapshaveguessedthattheboroughswouldbetheplacesofallothersinwhichsuchcommunalismastherewasintheancientvillagecommunitywouldmaintainanddevelopitself,untilincourseoftimetheboroughcorporation,theidealborough,wouldstandoutastheowneroflandswhichlaywithinandwithoutthewall。But,ifwehavenotbeengoingastray,wemayseewhythisdidnothappen,atleastinwhatwemaycalltheoldnationalboroughs。Theburgensicgroupwasnothomogeneousenough。Wemaysupposethatsomemembersofithadinheritedarablestripsandpasturerightsfromtheoriginalsettlers;butotherswere\'knights\'whohadbeenplacedinthehawsoftheshire-thegns,orweremerchantsandcraftsmenwhohadbeenattractedbythemarket,andforthemtherewouldbenoroominanoldagrarianscheme。Indeeditisnotimprobablethat,evenasregardsrightsofpasture,therewasmoredifferencebetweenburgessandburgessthentherewasbetweenvillagerandvillager。
Inmoderntimesitisnotunknownthatsomeoftheburgesseswillhavepasturerights,whileotherswillhavenone,andinthosewhoarethusfavouredwemayfancythatweseethesuccessorsintitleoftheking\'stenantswhoturnedouttheirbeastsontheking\'sland。96*
Wehaveseenthatintheboroughsagroupofmenisformedwhoseprincipleofcohesionisnottobefoundinlandtenure。
Thedefinitionofaburgessmayinvolvethepossessionofahousewithinorhardbythewalls;buttheburgessesdonotcoalesceasbeingthetenantsorthemenofonelord;andyetcoalescetheywill。Theyareunitedinandbythemootandthemarket-place,unitedunderthekinginwhosepeacetheytraffic;andthentheyaresoonunitedoveragainsttheking,whoexactstollfromthemandhasfavourstograntthem。Theyaspiretofarmtheirowntolls,tomanagetheirownmarketandtheirowncourt。Theking\'srightsarepecuniaryrights;heisentitledtocollectnumeroussmallsums。insteadofthesehemaybewillingtotakeafixedsumeveryyear,or,inotherwords,tolethisrightstofarm。
ThisstepseemstohavebeenverygenerallytakenbeforetheConquest。Alreadytheboroughswerefarmed。Nowthesumswhichthekingwoulddrawfromaboroughwouldbeofseveraldifferentkinds。Inthefirstplace,therewouldbetheprofitsofthemarketandoftheboroughcourt。Inthesecondplace,therewouldbethegafol,the\'haw-gavel\'and\'land-gavel\'arisingfromtenementsbelongingtothekingandoccupiedbyburgesses。Inthethirdplace,theremightbethedanegeld;butthedanegeldwasatax,anoccasionaltax,andforthemomentwemayleaveitoutofourconsideration。Nowtheprofitsofthemarketandcourtseemtohavebeenfarmed。Thesumsthattheybringintothekingareroundsums。Thefarmerseemstohavebeenthesherifforinsomecasestheking\'sportreeve。Wecanfindnocaseinwhichitisabsolutelycleartoourmindsthattheborough。itself,thecommunitasburgi,isreckonedtobetheking\'sfarmer。Again,theking\'sgafol,thatishisburgagerents,maybefarmed:theyarecomputedataroundsum。ThusatHuntingdontenpoundsarepaidbywayofland-gafol,andwemaybefairlycertainthatthesumoftherentsoftheindividualburgesseswhoheldtheirtenementsimmediatelyofthekingtherewereotherburgesseswhobelongedtotheAbbotofRamseydidnotexactlymakeupthisneatsum。97*Inthiscase,however,thesumduetothekingfromhisfarmer,probablythesheriff,inrespectoftheland-gafolisexpresslydistinguishedfromthesumthathehastopayforthefarmoftheboroughfirmaburgi:——atleastinitsnarrowestsense,theburguswhichisfarmedisnotamassoflandsandhouses,itisamarketandacourt。98*But,thoughwefindnocaseinwhichthecommunityoftheboroughisunambiguouslytreatedastheking\'sfarmer,therearecasesinwhichitseemstocomebeforeusasthesheriff\'sfarmer。\'Theburgesses\'ofNorthamptonpaytothesheriff?010s。perannum:——\'thisbelongstohisfarm。\'99*ThesheriffofNorthamptonshireisliabletothekingforaroundsumasthefarmoftheshire,but\'theburgesses\'ofNorthamptonareliabletothesheriffforaroundsum。Thismaymeanthatforthisroundsumtheyarejointlyandseverallyliable,while,ontheotherhand,theycollectthetollsandfines,perhapsalsotheking\'sburgagerents,andhaveanopportunityofmakingprofitbythetransaction。
Wemustnotbeinhastetoexpelthesherifffromtheboroughsoftheshire,ortobringtheburgessesintoimmediatecontactwiththeking\'streasury。WemustrememberthatatthebeginningofHenryII\'sreignthereisscarcelyanexceptiontotherulethattheboroughsoftheshireareintheeyesofauditorsattheExchequersimplypartsofthatcountywhichthesherifffarms。Sofarasthefarmisconcerned,theroyaltreasuryknowsnothingofanyboroughs。100*ThesheriffofGloucestershire,forexample,accountsforaroundsumwhichisthefarmofhiscounty;neitherhenoranyoneelseaccountstothekingforanyfarmoftheboroughofGloucester。If,asismostprobable,theboroughisbeingfarmed,itisbeingfarmedbysomepersonorpersonstowhom,nottheking,butthesheriffhasletitforalongerorshorterperiodatafixedrent。Here,again,weseethelikenessbetweenaboroughandahundred。Thekingletstheshiretofarm;theshireincludeshundredsandboroughs;thesheriff\'letsthehundredstofarm;thesheriffletstheboroughstofarm。\'Afewyearslateranewarrangementismade。ThekingbeginstolettheboroughofGloucestertofarm。Asumof?0blanchisnowdeductedfromtherentthatthesheriffhasbeenpayingforhisshire,and,ontheotherhand,Osmundthereeveaccountsfor?5,whichistherentoftheborough。Wemustnotantedateachangewhichistakingplaceverygraduallyinthemiddleofthetwelfthcentury。Normustweatoncerejecttheinferencethat,asthebailiffstowhomthesheriffletsthehundredsarechosenbyhim,soalsothebailiffsorport-reevestowhomheletstheboroughsareorhavebeenchosenbyhim。Itseemsverypossiblethatoneofthefirststepstowardsindependencethataboroughtakesisthatitsburgessesinducethesherifftoaccepttheirnomineeashisfarmerofthetowniftheyinmasswillmakethemselvesjointlyandseverallyliablefortherent。Thesemovementstakeplaceinthedarkandwecannotdatethem;buttoantedatethemwouldbeeasy。
Wealsoseethatthe\'geld\'thattheboroughhastopayisaroundsumthatremainsconstantfromyeartoyear。Cambridge,forexample,isassessedatahundredhides,Bedfordathalfahundred。101*Nowwehavegoodreasontobelievethatintheopencountryalso,aroundsumofgeldorandthisisthesamethingaroundnumberofhideshadbeenthrownuponthehundreds,thatthesumthrownuponahundredwasthenpartitionedamongthevills,andthatthesumthrownuponavillwaspartitionedamongthepersonswhoheldlandinthevill。Intheopencountry,however,whenoncethepartitionhad-beenmade,thenumberofhidesthatwascastuponthelandofanyoneproprietorseemstohavebeenfixedforgoodandall。102*Ifwesuppose,forexample,thatavillhadbeenassessedattenhidesandthatfiveofthoseunitshadbeenassignedtoacertainEdward,thenEdwardorhissuccessorsintitlewouldalwayshavetopayforfivehides,andwouldhavetopayfornomorealthoughtheotherproprietorsinthevillobtainedanexemptionfromthetaxorwereinsolvent。Inshort,thetaxthoughoriginallydistributedbyapartitionarymethodwasnotrepartitionable。Ontheotherhand,intheboroughsamorecommunalarrangementseemstohaveprevailed。Insomesenseoranother,thewholeborough,nomatterwhatitsfortunesmightbe,remainedanswerableforthetwenty,fiftyorahundredhidesthathadbeenimposeduponit。Suchadifferencewouldnaturallyarise。Intheopencountrythetaxationalhidationwassupposedtorepresentanddidrepresent,albeitrudely,astateoffactsthathadonceexisted。Themanwhowaschargedwithahideoughtintruthtohavehadoneofthoseagrarianunitsthatwerecommonlyknownashides。Butwhenaboroughwaschargedwithhides,amethodoftaxationthatwasadaptedtoandsuggestedbyruralarrangementswasbeinginappropriatelyappliedtowhathadbecomeorwouldsoonbecomeanurbandistrict。Thusthegrosssumthatiscastupontheboroughdoesnotsplititselfonceandforallintomanysmallsumseachofwhichtakesrootinaparticulartenement。Thewholesumiseligiblefromthewholeborougheverytimeageldisimposed。Itisrepartionable。
Forallthis,however,wemustbecarefulnottoseemorecommunalismormorelocalself-governmentthanreallyexists。Atfirstsightwemaythinkthatwedetectacommunalorajointliabilityofalltheburgessesforthewholesumthatisduefromtheboroughinanyoneyear。\'TheEnglishborn\'burgessesofShrewsburysendupapiteouswail。103*TheystillhavetopaythewholegeldastheypaiditintheConfessor\'sday,althoughtheearlhastakenforhiscastlethesitesoffifty-onehouses,andotherfiftyhousesarewaste,andforty-threeFrenchburgessesholdhouseswhichusedtopaygeld,andtheearlhasgiventotheabbey,whichhehasfounded,thirty-nineburgesseswhousedtopaygeldalongwiththeothers。Butwhenweexaminethemattermoreclosely,wemaydoubtwhetherthereishereanyjointandseveraltosaynothingofanycorporateliability。
Veryvariousarethemodesinwhichaland-taxorhouse-taxmaybeassessedandlevied。Supposeataxof?00imposeduponacertaindistrictinwhichthereareahundredhouses。Supposeitalsotobelawthat,thoughsomeofthesehousescometothehandsofeleemosynarycorporationswhichwewillimaginetoenjoyanimmunityfromtaxationstillthewhole?00mustberaisedannuallyfromthehouseholdersofthedistrict。Forallthis,wehavenotasyetdecidedthatanyhouseholderwilleverbeliable,eveninthefirstinstance,formorethanhisownparticularshareofthe?00。Areadjustmentoftaxationtheremustbe。Itmaytakeoneofmanyforms。Theremaybearevaluationofthedistrict,andthe?00maybenewlyapportionedbysomemeetingofhouseholdersorsomegovernmentofficer。But,againthereadjustmentmaybeautomatic。Formerlytherewere100housestopay?00。Nowthereare90housestopay?00。Thateachofthe90mustpayten-ninthsofapoundisaconclusionthattheruleofthreedrawsforus。Inthemiddleagesanautomaticreadjustmentwasalltheeasierbecauseofthecommonassumptionthatthevalueoflandsandhouseswasknowntoeveryoneandthatonevirgateinamanorwasasgoodasanother,one\'haw\'inaboroughasgoodasanother。104*WedonotsaythatthecomplaintoftheburgessesatShrewsburypointstonomorethananautomaticreadjustmentoftaxationwhichallalonghasbeenataxationofindividuals;stillthewarningisneedfulthattheexactionatregularorirregularintervalsofafixedamountfromadistrict,orfromthehouseholdersorinhabitantsofadistrict,anamountwhichremainsconstantthoughcertainportionsofthedistrictobtainimmunityfromtheimpost,doesnotofnecessitypointtoanykindofliabilitythatisnottheliabilityofonesingleindividualforspecificsumswhichheandheonlyhastopay;nordoesitofnecessitypointtoanyself-governingorself-assessingassemblyofinhabitants。105*
Returning,however,tothecaseofNorthampton,itcertainlyseemstotellusofacomposition,notindeedbetweentheburgessesandtheking,butbetweentheburgessesandthesheriff。\'TheburgessesofNorthamptonpaytothesheriff?0
10s。\'Wemaybelievethat\'theburgesses\'whopaythissumhaveachanceofmakingaprofit。Ifso,\'theburgesses\'arealreadybeginningtofarm\'theborough。\'Fromthis,nevertheless,wemustnotleaptocorporateliabilityorcorporateproperty。VerylikelythesheriffregardseveryburgessofNorthamptonasliabletohimforthewhole?010s。;verycertainly,aswethink,hedoesnotlookforpaymentmerelytopropertywhichbelongs,nottoanyindividualburgessnortoanysumofindividualburgesses,butto\'theborough\'ofNorthampton。Noriftheburgessesmakeprofitoutoftollsandfines,doesitfollowthattheyhaveapermanentcommonpurse;theymaydividethesurpluseveryyear,106*orwemaysuspectthemofdrinkingtheprofitsassoonastheyaremade。
Entrieswhichdescribethelimitsthataresettothedutyofmilitaryorofnavalservicemayseemmoreeloquent。ThusofDoverwearetoldthattheburgessesusedtosupplytwentyshipsforfifteendaysintheyearwithtwenty-onemenineachship,andthattheydidthisbecausethekinghadreleasedtothemhissakeandsoke。107*Hereweseemtoreadofadefinitetransactionbetweenthekingoftheonepartandtheboroughoftheotherpart,andonewhichimpliesagooddealofgovernmentalorganizationintheborough。Wewouldsaynothingtolessenthejustforceofsuchapassage,whichdoesnotstandalone;108*
butstillthereneedbebutlittlemoreorganizationintheboroughofDoverthanthereisinBerkshire。Itwasthecustomofthatcountythat,whenthekingsummonedhishost,onlyonesoldierwentfromeveryfivehides,whileeachhideprovidedhimwithfourshillingsforhisequipmentandwages。109*Wemayguessthatinacountysuchaschemeveryrapidly\'realized\'
itselfandtookrootinthesoil,thatinaboroughtherewasless\'realism,\'thatthereweremorefrequentreadjustmentsoftheburden;butthedifferenceisadifferenceofdegree。
Ofanythingthatcouldbecalledtheconstitutionoftheboroughs,nexttonothingcanwelearn。Wemaytakeitthatinmostcasestheking\'sfarmerwasthesheriffoftheshire;insomefewcases,asforexampleatHereford,thereeveoftheboroughmayhavebeendirectlyaccountabletotheking。110*Weknownoproofthatinanycasethereevewasanelectedofficer。
Probablyineachboroughacourtwasheldwhichwasacourtfortheborough;probablyitwas,atleastasageneralrule,co-ordinatewithahundredcourt,andindeedatstartingtheboroughseemstoberegardedasavillwhichisalsoahundred。111*Theactionofthiscourt,however,liketheactionofotherhundredcourts,mustastimewentonhavebeenhamperedbythegrowthofseignorialjustice。Thesakeandsokewhichalordmighthaveoverhismenandoverhislandswerecertainlynotexcludedbytheboroughwalls。Hehadsometimesbeenexpresslytoldthathemightenjoytheserights\'withinboroughandwithoutborough。\'Itisdifficultforustorealizetheexactmeaningthat\'sakeandsoke\'wouldbearwhenascribedtoaprelateorthegnwhohadbuttwoorthreehouseswithinthetown。
Perhapsinsuchcasesthetownhouseswereforjurisdictionalpurposesdeemedtobesituatewithinsomeruralmanoroftheirlord。Butinaboroughalordmighthaveacompactgroupoftenantsquitelargeenoughtoformapettycourt。Insuchacasetheboroughcourtwouldhavetheseignorialcourtsasrivals,andmanyadisputewouldtherebe。AtLincolnoneTochihadahallwhichundoubtedlywasfree\'fromallcustom\';buthehadalsothirtyhousesoverwhichthekingbadtollandforfeiture。Sotheburgessesswore;butacertainpriestwasreadytoprovebyordealthattheysworefalsely。112*Inthesecasesthelord\'sterritorywouldappearinlatertimesasalittle\'liberty\'lyingwithintheboroughwalls。Themiddleageswerefarspentbeforesuchlibertieshadbecomemorepettynuisances。113*Intheoldcathedraltowns,suchasCanterburyandWinchester,thebishop\'sjurisdictionalpowersandimmunitieswereseriousaffairs,forthebishop\'stenantswerenumerous。114*Nevertheless,inthegreatandancientboroughs,theboroughswhichstandoutastypesandmodels,therewasfromaveryremotetimeacourt,aborough-mootorportman-moot,whichwasnotseignorial,acourtwhichwasaunitinanationalsystemofcourts。
Oftheformthattheboroughcourttookwecansaylittle。
Perhapsatfirstitwouldbeanassemblyofallthefreeburgmenorport-men。Asitsbusinessincreasedinthelargeboroughs,asitbegantositonceaweekinsteadofthriceayear,asetofpersonsboundtoserveasdoomsmenmayhavebeenformed,asetofaldermenorlawmenwhoseofficesmightormightnotbehereditary,mightormightnot\'runwith\'thepossessionofcertainspecifictenements。A\'husting\'mightbeformed,thatis,ahouse-thingasdistinctfroma\'thing\'orcourtheldintheopenair。Lawrequiredthatthereshouldbestandingwitnessesinaborough,beforewhombargainsandsalesshouldtakeplace。Suchademandmighthastentheformationofasmallbodyofdoomsmen。
InCambridgetherewerelawmenofthegnlyrank;115*inLincolnthereweretwelvelawmen;116*inStamfordtherehadbeentwelve,thoughatthedateofDomesdayBooktherewerebutnine;117*wereadoffouriudicesinYork,118*andoftwelveiudicesinChester。119*Solateas1275thetwelvelawmenofStamfordlivedoninthepersonsoftheirheirsorsuccessors。
Thereare,saidajury,twelvemeninStamfordwhoarecalledlawmenbecausetheirancestorswereinoldtimethejudgesofthelawsiudicesleguminthesaidtown;theyholdofthekinginchief;bywhatservicewedonotknow。butyoucanfindoutfromDomesdayBook。120*Overthebodiesofthese,presumably,Danish,lawmentherehasbeenmuchdisputation。WeknowthattakenindividuallythelawmenofLincolnwereholdersofheritablefranchises,ofsakeandsoke。WeknowthatamongthetwelveiudicesofChesterweremenoftheking,menoftheearl,menofthebishop;theyhadtoattendthe\'hundred\',thatis,wetakeit,theboroughcourt。Weknownomore;butitseemslikelythatwehavetodealwithpersonswhocollectivelyformagroupofdoomsmen,whileindividuallyeachofthemisagreatman,ofthegnlyrank,withsakeandsokeoverhismenandhislands;hisofficepassestohisheir。121*Onthewhole,however,wemustdoubtwhetherthegeneralityofEnglishboroughshadarrivedateventhissomewhatrudimentarystageoforganization。In1200themenofIpswich,havingreceivedacharterfromKingJohn,decidedthatthereshouldbeintheirboroughtwelvechiefportmen,\'astherewereintheotherfreeboroughsinEngland,\'whoshouldhavefullpowertogovernandmaintainthetownandtorenderthejudgmentsofitscourt。122*NowIpswichhasarighttobeplacedintheclassofancientboroughs,ofcountytowns,andyettoallappearanceithadnodefiniteclassofchiefmenordoomsmenuntiltheyear1200。Stillweoughtnottoinferfromthisthatthetownmoothadbeeninpracticeademocraticinstitution。Theremaybeagreatdealofoligarchy,andoligarchyofanoppressivekind,thoughtherulingclasshasneverbeendefinedbylaw。DomesdayBookallowsustoseeinvarioustownsalargenumberofpoorfolkwhocannotpaytaxesorcanonlypayapolltax。Wemustbecharyofconcedingtothiscrowdanyshareinthedoomsofthecourt。123*
Butwhatconcernsthegovernmentoftheboroughshasforthetimebeensufficientlysaidbyothers。Inourfewlastwordswewillreturntoourfirsttheme,thedifferencebetweentheboroughandthemeretownship。
WehaveseenthatinDomesdayBookaprominentpositionisconcededtocertaintowns。Theyarenotbroughtunderanyrubricwhichwouldplacethemupontheking\'soranyotherperson\'sland。Itmustnowbeconfessedthattherearesomeothertownsthatarenotthustreatedandthatnonethelessarecalledboroughs。If,however,werememberthatburgessesoftenareinlawwheretheyarenotinfact,thelistthatweshallmakeoftheseboroughswillnotbelong。Stillsuchboroughsexistandafewwordsshouldbesaidaboutthem。Theyseemtofallintotwoclasses,fortheyaredescribedasbeingontheking\'slandoronthelandofsomenobleorprelate。Ofthelatterclasswewillspeakfirst。ItdoesnotcontainmanymembersandinsomecaseswecanbecertainthatintheConfessor\'sdaytheboroughinquestionhadnootherlordthantheking。Totnessisacaseinpoint。ItnowfallsunderthetitleTerraJudheldeTottenais;
butwearetoldthatKingEdwardhelditindemesne。124*InSussexweseethatSteyning,PevenseyandLewesarecalledburgi,125*SteyningisplacedonthelandoftheAbbotofF閏amp,PevenseyonthatoftheCountofMortainandLewesonthatofWilliamofWarenne;butatLewestherehavebeenmanyhawsappurtenanttotheruralmanorsoftheshirethegns。126*
InKenttheboroughofHytheseemstobecompletelyunderthearchbishop。127*HehasburgessesatRomneyoverwhomhehasjusticiaryrights,buttheyservetheking。128*The\'littleboroughcalledFordwich\'belongedtotheAbbotofStAugustin。
Butofthisweknowthehistory。TheConfessorgavehimtheroyaltwo-thirds,whilethebishopofBayeuxasthesuccessorofEarlGodwingavehimthecomitalone-third。129*Furthernorth,LouthinLincolnshireandNewarkinNottinghamshireseemtobeaccountedboroughs;theybothbelongtothebishopofLincoln;
butinthecaseofNewarkwhichwasprobablyanoldburhwemaydoubtwhetherhistitleisveryancient。130*WearetoldthatatTattershall,thePontefractoflaterdays,131*therearesixty\'minuteburgesses,\'thatis,wetakeit,burgessesinasmallway。IlbertdeLacyisnowtheirlord;buthereagainwemaysuspectarecentactofmediatization。132*GranthaminLincolnshireisplacedontheTerraRegis;ithadbelongedtoQueenEdith;therewere,however,seventy-seventoftsinitwhichbelongedto\'thesokemenofthethegns,\'thatis,tothesokemenofthethegnsoftheshire。133*TheninSuffolkweseethatIpswichisdescribedattheendofthesectionwhichdealswiththeroyalestates;asimilarplaceisfoundforNorwich,YarmouthandThetfordinthesurveyofNorfolk。134*ButforDunwichwemustlookelsewhere。TherewereburgessesatDunwich;buttoallseemingtheroyalrightsoverthetownhadpassedintothehandsofEadricofLaxfield。135*ThesuccessorofthesameEadrichasburgessesamonghistenantsatEye。136*ThereareburgessesatClare,thoughClarebelongsaltogethertotheprogenitorofthelordlyracewhichwilltakeitsnamefromthislittletown。137*
Butatleastinthislastcase,theburgessesmaybenew-comers,orratherperhapswemayseethatanoldideaisgivingwaytoanewerideaofaborough,andthatifmenengagedintradeorhandicraftsettleroundamarket-placeandpaymoney-rentstoalordtheywillbecalledburgesses,thoughthetownisnonationalfortress。AtBerkhampstead52burgessesarecollectedinaburbium,buttheymaybeasnewasthetwoarpentsofvineyard。138*WemustnotsaydogmaticallythatneverinthedaysbeforetheConquesthadavillagebecomeaboroughwhileithadforitsoneandonlylandlordsomepersonotherthantheking,somebishop,orsomethegn。ThismayhavehappenedatTaunton。In1086,therewereburgessesatTauntonanditenjoyed\'burh-riht,\'andyetfromaveryremotetimeithadbelongedtothebishopsofWinchester。ButthecasesinwhichwemaysupposethatavillageinprivatehandsbecameaburgusandthatthischangetookplacebeforetheNormaninvasionseemtobeextremelyfew。Inthesefewthecauseofthechangemayhavebeenthatthekingbywayofspecialfavourimposedhisburhgriduponthetownandtherebyaugmentedtherevenueofitslord。139*
Astotheboroughsthatareregardedasstandingontheking\'sland,thesealsoseemtobefewandforthemoreparttheyaresmall。ThereareburgessesatMaldon;140*butMaldonisnotplacedbythesideofColchester;141*itisdescribedamong,butBristoltheroyalestates。ThereareburgessesatBristol;142*isnotplacedbesideGloucesterandWinchcombe。
Perhapsweshouldhaveheardmoreofit,ifithadnot,likeTamworth,stoodontheborderoftwocounties。Inthesouth-westtheking\'sofficialsseemtobegrapplingwithdifficultiesasbesttheymay。InDorsettheyplaceDorchester,Bridport,WarehamandShaftesburyabovetherubricTerraRegis,143*andwecannotfindthattheyreckonanyotherplaceasaborough。InDevonshireweseeExeterabovetheline;LidfordandBarnstaple,however,arecalledboroughsthoughtheyareassignedtotheking\'sland,andasalreadysaidTotnessisaborough,thoughitismediatizedandisdescribedamongtheestatesofitsBretonlord。144*NoboroughinSomersetisplacedabovetheline,thoughwelearnthatthekinghas107burgessesinIlchesterwhopayhim20shillings,145*andthatheandothershaveburgessesatBath。146*Perhapsthespacethatstandsvacantbeforethelistofthetenantsinchiefshouldhavebeenfilledwithsomewordsaboutthesetwotowns。Axbridge,LangportandMilborneseemtobeboroughs;AxbridgeandLangportoccurinthatlistofancientfortresseswhichwehavecalledTheBurghalHidage。147*
Wellswasanepiscopal,Somertonaroyalmanor;wehavenoreasonforcallingeitherofthemaborough。InHampshireanotheroftheancientfortresses,TwynehamthemodernChristChurchisstillcalledburgus,butseemstobefindingitslevelamongtheroyalmanors。148*InWiltshireMalmesburyandMarlboroughareplacedabovetheline。Welearnthatthekingreceives?0fromtheburgusofWilton,149*andwealsolearnincidentallythatvariouslordshaveburgessesinthattown;forexample,thebishopofSalisburyhasburgessesinWiltonwhobelongtohismanorofSalisbury。150*OldSalisbury\'oldSarum\'aswefoolishlycallitseemstobeameremanorbelongingtothebishop;butthekingreceivesitsthirdpenny。HereceivesalsothethirdpennyofCricklade,whichwehavenamedbeforenowasoneoftheoldWessexstrongholds,andseveralofthecountymagnateshadburgessesthere。OntheotherhandCalne,BedwindandWarminsterarereckonedtobemanorsontheking\'sland。
Burgessesbelongtothem;butwhetherthoseburgessesarereallyresidentinthemmaynotbequitecertain。151*Devizeswecannotfind。Thatpuzzlesshouldoccurinthisquarteriswhatourgeneraltheorymightleadustoexpect。IntheoldhomeoftheWest-Saxonkingstheremaywellhavebeentownswhichhadlongagosecuredthenameandthepeaceofroyalburgs,thoughtheymanifestednoneofthattenurialheterogeneitywhichisthecommonmarkofaborough。Atown,avillage,whichnotonlybelongedtothekingbutcontainedapalaceorhouseinwhichheoftendwelt,wouldenjoyhisspecialpeace,andmightmaintainitsburghaldignitylongaftertherewaslittle,ifany,realdifferencebetweenitandothermanorsorvillagesofwhichthekingwastheimmediatelandlord。Alreadyin1086theremayhavebeen\'rottenboroughs,\'boroughsthatwererottenbeforetheywereripe。152*
Aboroughbelongstothegenusvillat鷑。Inageafterageourtaskistodiscoveritsdifferentia,andthetaskishardbecause,asagesucceedsage,changesinlawandchangesinfactaremakingtheolddistinctionsobsoletewhileothersarebecomingimportant。Letusobserve,then,thatalreadywhenDomesdayBookwasinthemakingthoseancientattributesofwhichwehavebeenspeakingweredisappearingorwerefatedsoontodisappear。Wehavethoughtofthetypicalboroughasafortifiedtownmaintainedbyadistrictformilitarypurposes。Butalreadytheshirethegnshavebeenlettingtheirhawsatarentandprobablyhavebeenlettingthemtocraftsmenandtraders。Alsothetimehascomeforknight-serviceandcastlesandcastle-guard。Wehavethoughtofthetypicalboroughasthesphereofaspecialpeace。Butthedayisathandwhenarevolutioninthecriminallawwilldestroytheoldsystemofwerandw韙eandb髏,andtheking\'speacewillreignalwaysandeverywhere。153*Wehavethoughtofthetypicalboroughasatownwhichhasacourt。Butthedayisathandwhenalmosteveryvillagewillhaveitscourt,itsmanorialcourt。Newcontrasts,however,areemergingastheoldcontrastsfadeaway。Againstabackgroundofvilleinageandweek-work,theboroughbeginstostandoutasthesceneorburgagetenure。Theservicebywhichtheburgessholdshistenementisamoneyrent。Thismayleadtoalargeincreaseinthenumberofboroughs。Ifalordenfranchisesamanor,abolishesvilleincustoms,takesmoneyrents,allowshistenantstofarmthecourtandperhapsalsotofarmamarketthathehasacquiredfromtheking,hewillbesaidtocreatealiberburgus。154*Merchantgilds,electedbailiffs,electedmayorsandcommonsealswillappearandwillcomplicatethequestion。Therewillfollowatimeofuncertaintyandconfusionwhenthesheriffswilldecideassuitsthembestwhichofthesmallertownsareboroughsandwhicharenot。
Ifthetheorythatwehavebeensuggestingistrue,allorverynearlyallourancientboroughsandwewilldrawthelineofancientryattheConquestareintheirinceptionroyalboroughs。Thegroupofburgesseswhentakenasawholehadnosuperiorotherthantheking。Hiswasthepeacethatprevailedinthestreets;theprofitsofthecourtandofthemarketwerehis,thoughtheywerefarmedbyareeve。Rarely,however,washethelandlordofalltheburgesses。Ingeneralnotafewofthemlivedinhousesthatbelongedtothethegnsoftheshire。Wemustbecarefulthereforebeforewespeakofthesetownsas\'boroughsontheroyaldemesne。\'Forthemorepart,thecompilersofDomesdayBookhaverefusedtoplacethemontheTerraRegis。Incourseoftimesomeofthemwillbecurrentlyspokenofasboroughsonoroftheroyaldemesne。Therightsofthosewhorepresentthethegnsoftheshirewillhavebecomemererightstorent,and,theiroriginbeingforgotten,theywillevenbetreatedasmererent-charges。155*Thegreatmajorityoftheburgesseswillinmanyinstancesbetheking\'simmediatetenantsandhewillbetheonlylordofthatincorporealthing,\'theborough,\'theonlymanwhocangrantitacharterorletittofarm。ButwemustdistinguishbetweenthesetownsandthosewhichattheConquestweremanorsontheking\'sland。Theselatter,ifheenfranchisesthem,willbeboroughsontheroyaldemesneinanexactersense。
So,again,wemustdistinguishbetweenthoseancientboroughswhichthekinghasmediatizedandthosemanorsofmesnelordswhichareraisedtotherankofboroughs。Wehaveseenthatfromtheancientboroughthekingreceivedarevenueoftollsandfines。Thereforehehadsomethingtogiveaway。Hecouldmediatizetheborough。DomesdayBookshowsusthatthishadalreadybeendoneinafewinstances。156*Atalatertimesomeevenofthecountytownspassedoutoftheking\'shandsintothehandsofearls。ThishappenedatLeicesterandatWarwick。Theearlsucceededtotheking\'srights,andtheburgesseshadtogototheearlfortheirlibertiesandtheircharters。Butsuchcasesareverydistinctfromthoseinwhichamesnelordgrantsanenfranchisingchartertothemenofaplacewhichhashithertobeenoneofhismanors,andbyspeakingofboroughswhichare\'onthelandofmesnelords\'wemustnotconfusetwoclassesoftownswhichhavelonghaddifferenthistories。Intheancientboroughsthereisfromthefirstanelementthatwemustcallbothartificialandnational。Theboroughdoesnotgrowupspontaneously;itismade;itis\'wrought\';itis\'timbered。\'Ithasanationalpurpose;itismaintained\'atthecostofthenation\'bythedutythattheshireowestoit。Thistraitmaysoonhavedisappeared,maysoonhavebeenforgotten,butagreatworkhadbeendone。Inthesenationallysupportedandheterogeneouslypeopledtownsanewkindofcommunitymightwaxandthrive。
NOTES:
1。AsketchoftheprincipalargumentofthissectionwaspublishedinEng。Hist。Rev。,xi。13,asareviewofKeutgen\'sUntersuchungen黚erdenUrsprungderdeutschenStadtverfassung。
TheoriginoftheFrenchandGermantownsbasbecomethethemeofalargeandveryinterestingliterature。AgoodintroductiontothiswillbefoundinanarticlebyM。Pirenne,L\'originedesconstitutionsurbaines,Revuehistorique,liii。52,lvii。293,andanarticlebyMrAshley,QuarterlyJournalofEconomics,vol。
x。July,1896。ThecontinuoussurvivalofRomanmunicipalinstitutionseveninGaulseemstobedeniedbyalmostallmodernstudents。
2。Hist。Eng。Law,i。625。
3。Stubbs,Const。Hist。iii。448。
4。Wemustexcludecasesinwhichthekingtakesanaidfromhiswholedemesne,e。g。forhisdaughter\'smarriage,forinsuchacasemanyroyalmanorswhichhavenorighttobecalledboroughsmustmakeagift。
5。Round,GeoffreydeMandeville,347,hasexcellentremarksonthispoint。
6。Nearly。
7。ThismaycomeonlyfromtheStaffordshirepartofTamworth。
8。Chichesterpaysinlateryears;butverylittle。
9。PipeRoll,31Hen。I。p。139。
10。WastheblankspaceinD。B。i。246leftfortheboroughofTamworth?ThisboroughisincidentallymentionedinD。B。i。238,246,246b。
11。Buttheaccountofthetwosisterboroughsherefallsbetweentheaccountsofthetwosistercounties。
12。D。B。i。337。ItisevencalledasuburbiumofLincoln,thoughitliesfull10milesfromthecity。
13。TheoneglimpsethatIhavehadofthemanuscriptsuggestedtome1thattheaccountsofsomeoftheboroughswerepostscripts,and2thatspacewasleftforaccountsofLondonandWinchester。Theanatomyofthebookdeservesexaminationbyanexpert。
14。D。B。i。154。
15。D。B。i。56。
16。D。B。i。58。
17。D。B。i。238。
18。D。B。i。143。
19。Ellis,Introduction,ii。446;WinchcombeLand-boc,ed。Royce,p。xiv;Stevenson,RentalofGloucester,p。ix。
20。D。B。i。128,128b;andabove,p。144。
21。K。855iv。211。
22。Stow,Survey,ed。Strype,Bk。iii。p。121。
23。D。B。i。135b。
24。Hist。Eng。Law,i。636。
25。Rot。Hund。ii。361。
26。D。B。i。189。
27。RentalofGloucester,ed。W。H。Stevenson:Gloucester,1890,p。x。
28。TherearemanyexamplesinKemble\'sCodex。
29。PipeRoll,31Hen。I。p。41:\'Vicecomesredditcompotumde?0deauxiliocivitatis……Etinperdonis……ComitideMellent25sol……ComitideLerecestria35sol……ComitideWarenna16
sol……Comiti。Gloecestriae116sol。et8den。SeealsotheLiberWintoniae,D。B。iv。531ff。
30。IntheA-S。land-booksthewordcivitasiscommonlyappliedtoWorcester,Winchester,Canterbury,andothersuchplaces,whicharebothbishops\'seesandtheheadplacesoflargedistricts。ButK。v。p。180Gloucesterisacivitas,andforsometimeaftertheConquestitisratherthecountytownthanthecathedraltownthatbearsthistitle。DidanyoneeverspeakofSelseyorSherborneasacivitas?In803K。v。p。65thebishopsofCanterbury,Lichfield,Leicester,Sidnacester,Worcester,Winchester,Dunwich,LondonandRochesterstylethemselvesbishopsofcivitates,whilethoseofHereford,Sherborne,ElmhamandSelseydonotusethisword。Butaninferencefromthiswouldberash。
31。Aninterestingexampleisthis。In779OffaconveystoathegnlandatSulmonnesburg。TheboundariesmentionedinthecharterarethoseofthepresentofBourton-on-the-Water。
\'Sulmonnesburg……istheancientcampparishclosetoBourtonwhichgaveitsnametotheDomesdayHundredofSalmanesberie,andatagapintherampartofwhichaCourtLeetwasheldtillrecently。\'SeeC。S。Taylor,Pre-DomesdayHideofGloucestershire,Trans。BristolandGloucestershireArchaeol。
Soc。vol。xviii。pt。2。Asregardsthenanmesofhillsandofvillagesnamedfromhillstheremayoccasionallybesomedifficultyinmarkingoffthosewhichgobacktobeorhberry,berrow,barrowfromthosewhichgobacktoburhburgh,borough,bury。Mr。StevensontellsmethatintheWestofEnglandthetermination-boroughsometimesrepresents-beorh。
32。Alfred,40;Ine,45。
33。Aethelr。iv。4。TheQuadripartitusisouronlyauthorityfortheseInstituta;butDr。LiebermannQuadrip。p。138holdsthatthetranslatorhadinfrontofhimadocumentwrittenbeforetheConquest。Schmidwouldreadborh-bryce:seep。541;butthisemendationseemsneedless。HaslIotthesumbeenNormanized?Theking\'sburh-bryceusedtobe120i。e。inEnglish\'ahundred\'
shillings,andahundredNormanshillingsmake?。SoaccordingtotheBerkshirecustomD。B。i。56bhewhobynightbreaksacivitaspays100shillingstothekingandnotitisnotedtothesheriff。
34。D。B。i。2:\'Concordatumestderectiscallibusquaehabentpercivitatemintroitumetexitum,quicunqueinillisforisfecerit,regiemendabit。\'SeetheimportantdocumentcontainedinaSt。Augustin\'sCartularyandprintedinLarking,DomesdayofKent,Appendix,35:\'Etomnesviecivitatisquehabentduasportas,hocestintroitumetexitum,illesuntdeconsuetudineRegis。\'
35。Schmid,App。XII;Leg。Henr。c。I6。
36。Fleta,p。66;seealso13Ric。II。stat。I。cap。3。
37。Edmund,II,2。
38。SeealsoSchmid,App。IVgrideandbemunde,section15;\'Ifanymanfightsorstealsintheking\'sburhortheneighbourhoodthe\'verge\',heforfeitshislife,ifthekingwillnotconcedethatheberedeemedbyawergild。\'
39。AEthelstan,II。20。
40。K。1334vi。p。195:acontractmadeatExeterbeforeEarlGodwinandalltheshire。
41。Edgar,III。5;Cnut,II。I8。
42。MentionismadeofthewallsofRochesterandCanterburyinvariouschartersfromthemiddleofcent。viiionwards:K。vol。
i。pp。138,183,274;vol。ii。pp。I,26,36,57,86;vol。v。p。
68。
43。Green,ConquestofEngland,189-207。
44。Forinstance,K。iii。pp。5,50。
45。K。I154v。302:\'adiacentetiamagriquamplurimicircacastellumquodWelingafordvocitatur。\'K。152i。183:\'castelliquodnominaturHrofescester。\'——K。276ii。57:\'castelliHrobi。\'
46。AbeautifulexampleisgivenbyStaffordshireandWarwickshire。Eachhasitsboroughinitscentre,whileTamworthontheborderispartlyintheoneshire,partlyintheother。
SeePipeRoll,31Hen。I。75,76,107,108。AstotheseMercianshires,seeStubbs,Const。Hist。,i。123;Green,ConquestofEngland,237:\'Hertfordshire,BuckinghamshireandBedfordshireareotherinstancesofpurelymilitarycreation,districtsassignedtothefortresseswhichEadwardraisedatthesepoints。\'
47。SeeourindexunderBurghalHidage。MrW。H。Stevenson\'svaluableaidintheidentificationoftheseburgsisgratefullyacknowledged。
48。D。B。i。154。
49。D。B。i。262b。
50。Itwillbeunderstoodthatwearenotcontendingforanexactcorrespondencebetweencivilandmilitarygeography。OxfordandWallingfordarebordertowns。BerkshiremenhelptoOxford,andOxfordshiremenhelptomaintainWallinford。
51。Widukind,1。35。ForcommentsseeWaitz,HeinrichV。95;
Richter,Annalen,iii。8;Giesebrecht,Kaiserzeited。5,i。
222,811;Keutgen,UrsprungderdeutschenStadtverfassung,p。44。
GiesebrechtholdsthatEdward\'smeasuresmaywellhavebeenHenry\'smodel。
52。A-S。Chron。ann。894。
53。Acharterof899K。v。p。141professestotellhowKingAlfred,AbpPlegmundandAEthelredealdormanoftheMerciansheldamoot\'deinstaurationeurbisLondoniae。\'Oneresultofthismootwasthattwoplotsoflandinsidethewalls,withhythesoutsidethewalls,weregivenbytheking,theonetothechurchofCanterbury,theothertothechurchofWorcester。HowwilltheinstauratioofLondonbesecuredbysuchgrants?
54。K。1144v。280。Othercases:K。663Chichester,673
Winchester,705Warwick,724Warwick,746Oxford,1235
Winchester。
55。K。765-6,805。
56。Schmid,App。VThismightmeanaseatofjusticeinthegateofhisownburh。ButthisdOcumentwillhardlybeolderthan,ifsooldas,cent。x。,bywhichtimeweshouldsupposethatburhmoreoftenpointedtoaboroughthantoastronghouse。
WemayguessthatinthelattersenseitwassupplantedbythehallofwhichwereadagreatdealinDomesday。Seeabove,p。
109。However,itdoesnotseemcertainthatO。E。geatcanmeanstreet。
57。A-S。Chron。ann。994。
58。Thorpe,Diplomatarium,610。WhentheConfessorsendsawrittoLondonheaddressesittothebishop,portreeveandburh-thegns。SeeK。iv。pp。856,857,861,872。
59。Gross,GildMerchant,i。183,189。
60。Gross,op。cit。ii。37。
61。Hist。Eng。Law,i。257。
62。A-S。Chron。ann。1097:\'Eacmanegesciran