Sunday,November15。
LunchedwithJohnson,fellowofMerton,andmetmyoldfriendMlle。BlazeduBury。Hercomments,fromthepointofviewofabrilliantyoungFrenchwoman,onallshesawaboutheratOxfordwerepungentandsuggestive。IntheeveningheardtheArchbishopofYorkThompson,preachatSt。Mary’s。Heurgedthestudentstoconsecratethemselvesbytheirexampletothemaintenanceofabetterstandardofmorality;but,despitehisstrengthandforce,thesermonseemedheavyandperfunctory。
November16。
ToWindsorwithapartyoffriends,andaswehadaspecialpermittoseealargenumberofroomsandcuriousobjectsnotusuallyshown,thevisitwasveryinteresting。SadlysuggestivewasGordon’sBible,everypagehavingitsmarginscoveredwithannotationsinhisownhand:itwasbroughtfromKhartoumafterhismurder,presentedbyhissistertotheQueen,andisnowpreservedinanexquisitelywroughtsilvercasket。
Tuesday,November18。
VisitedSomervilleHallforwomen,whichshowsavastadvanceoverOxfordasIformerlyknewit。Tothinkthatitscreationhonorsthememoryofawomanwhoattainedherhighscientificknowledgeinspiteofeverydiscouragement,andwho,whenshehadattainedit,wasdenouncedoutrageouslyfromthepulpitofYorkMinsterforit!DinedatMertonCollegewiththewarden,Hon。
GeorgeBroderick,inthehall,whichhasbeenmostbeautifullyrestoredbySirGilbertScott。WhenwillthefoundersofourAmericancollegesanduniversitiesunderstandthevasteducationalvalueofsurroundingslikethese,andespeciallyofa\"hall\"inwhichstudentsmeeteveryday,beneathstoriedwindowsandthebustsandportraitsofthemosteminentmeninthehistoryofscience,literature,andpublicservice?
InanswertothequestionwhetherinAmericanuniversitiestherewasanythingliketheassociationbetweeninstructorsandstudentsinEngland,Ispokeoftheevolutionofourfraternityhousesaslikelytobringaboutsomethingofthesort。ThefraternalrelationbetweenteachersandtaughtiscertainlythebestthingintheEnglishuniversities,andcoversamultitudeofsins。IfIwereagreatmillionaireIwouldestablishinourgreateruniversitiesascoreorsoofself—governingcolleges,eachwithcomfortablelodging—roomsandstudiesandwithitsownlibraryanddining—hall。Inthecommonroom,afterdinner,IsatnextProfessorWallace,whosebookonKantIhadread。HethinksthesystemofethicsreallypredominantinEnglandismodifiedKantianism。
November19。
ToMortimer,nearReading,onavisittoSirPaulHunter,whooncevisitedmeatCornell。Extractsfrommydiaryofthisvisitareasfollows:
November20。
ToBearwood,theseatofJohnWalter,M。P。,proprietorofthe\"Times,\"andforthefirsttimeinmylifesawafoxhunt,withthemeet,thehuntsmeninredcoats,andalltherestofit。
November21。
VisitedtheoldAbbeyChurchatReadingwithSirPaul,andintheeveningmetvariousinterestingpeopleatdinner,amongthemSirJohnMowbray,M。P。forOxfordandMr。Walter。
Sunday,November22。
Aftermorningserviceinthebeautifulparishchurchwhich,withitsschools,wasthegiftofMr。Benyon,severalofustookawalktoSilchester,withitsruinsofanoldRomanbath,ontheDukeofWellington’sestate。IntheeveningMr。Walter,whousuallyappearssoreticentandquiet,openedhimselftomequitefreely,speakingveryearnestlyregardingtheunfortunateturnwhichthequestionbetweenCatholicsandProtestantshastakeninEnglandunderpressurefromtheVatican,especiallyasregardsmarriages,andillustratinghisviewbysomemostsuggestivenewspapercuttings。HealsogavemewhatheclaimedwasthetruestoryofEarlRussell’sconductinlettingouttheConfederatecruisersagainstusduringtheCivilWar,attributingittothefactthatanunderlingchargedwithpreventingitwentsuddenlymad,sothatthematterdidnotreceiveearlyattention。ButthisdidnotmodifymyopinionofEarlRussell。ThankHeaven,heliveduntilhesawGreatBritainmadetopayheavilyforhisobstinacy。
Pitythathedidnotlivetoseethepresentrestorationofgoodfeelingbetweenthetwocountries;estoperrpetua(1905)。
Monday,November23。
Intheafternoondroveto\"Bramshill,\"themagnificentseatofSirWilliamCope;afterall,therehasneverbeenanydomesticarchitecturesonobleastheElizabethanandJacobean。IntheeveningtoaTorymeeting,SirJohnMowbraypresiding;hisopeningspeechastoundedme。Presentingtheclaimsofhisparty,hesaidthattheTorieswerenotonlytheauthorsofextendedsuffrageunderLordBeaconsfield,butthattheyoughtalsotohavethecreditoffreetradeingrain,sinceSirRobertPeelhadsupportedthebillfortherepealofthecornlaws。RememberingthetreatmentwhichSirRobertPeelreceivedfromDisraeliandtheTorypartyforthisveryact,itseemedtomethatSirJohn’sspeechwasthecoolestthingIhadeverheardinmylife。Itwastakeningoodpart,however。InAmericaIamquitesurethatsuchaspeechwouldhavebeenconsideredaninsulttotheaudience。
November24。
ToCambridge,whereImetanumberofoldfriends,includingDr。
Waldstein,directoroftheFitzwilliamMuseum,andSedleyTaylor,fellowofTrinity;andintheeveningdinedatKing’sCollegewiththeformerandanumberofinterestingmen,includingWestcott,theeminentNewTestamentscholar(sinceBishopofDurham)。
November26。
DinedatTrinityCollegewithSedleyTaylorandothers,andthencetothePolitico—EconomicAssociationtohearadiscussionuponcooperationinproduction;thosetakingtheprincipalpartinthemeetingbeingsundryleadingmenamongtheprofessorsandfellowsdevotedtopoliticaleconomy。DuringthedayIcalledonRobertsonSmith,theeminentbiblicalcritic,who,havingbeenthrownoutoftheFreeChurchofScotlandforrevealingsundrytruthsinbiblicalcriticismadozenyearstoosoon,hasbeenreceivedintoafarbetterplaceatCambridge。
November27。
HadadelightfulhourduringthemorninginKing’sCollegechapelwithBradshaw,thelibrarianoftheuniversity——amostaccomplishedman。Hehasapassionforchurcharchitecture,andhisdiscussionsofthewonderfulstainedwindowsofthechapelwereveryinteresting。TheeveningserviceatKing’sCollegewasmostbeautiful:nothingcouldbemoreperfectthantheantiphonalrenderingofthePsalmsbythetwochoirsandthegreatorgan。
MoreandmoreIamimpressedbytheEDUCATIONALvalueofsuchthings。
November28。
DuringthegreaterpartofthedayinthelibraryofTrinityCollegewithSedleyTaylor。Yearsbefore,IhadexploreditstreasureswithAldisWright,buttherewerenewthingstofascinateme。DiningatKing’sCollegewithWaldstein,metProfessorSeeley,authorofthe\"LifeofStein,\"abookwhich,eversinceitsappearance,hasbeenanobjectofmyadmiration。
November29。
Inthemorning,atKing’sCollegechapel,Iwasgreatlystruckbytheacousticpropertiesofthisimmensebuilding;for,havingseatedmyselfnearthedooratthewestend,Idistinctlyheardeverywordoftheprayerforthechurchmilitantasitwasrecitedbeforethealtarattheotherend。Afterward,atOscarBrowning’srooms,lookedoveramultitudeofinterestingdocuments,includingBritishofficialreportsfromNewYorkduringourWaroftheRevolution;andintheevening,atWaldstein’srooms,metSirHenryMaineanddiscussedwithhimhisbookon\"PopularGovernment。\"Heinterestedmegreatly,andI
pointedouttohimsomethingswhich,inmyopinion,hemightwelldwellmorestronglyuponinfutureeditions,andamongthesethepopularityofthevetopowerintheUnitedStates,asshowninitsextensionbyrecentlegislationofvariousStatestoitemsofsupplybills。
AtnoontoluncheonatChrist’sCollegewithProfessorRobertsonSmith,theScotchheretic。ThiswastheCambridgehomeofMiltonandDarwin,interestingmemorialsofwhomwereshownme。AmongtheguestswasDr。Creighton,professorofecclesiasticalhistory。TheearlypartofCreighton’sbookonthe\"HistoryofthePapacyDuringtheReformationPeriod\"hadespeciallyinterestedme,andInowenjoyedgreatlyhisknowledgeofItalianmatters。HediscussedTomasini’sbookonMachiavelli,andsundrynewItalianbooksontherelationsofthePopesandFraPaoloSarpi。
November30。
TookteaatSt。Mary’sHallwithSirHenryMaine,andcontinuedourdiscussiononhis\"PopularGovernment,\"which,whileopposedtodemocracy,paysagreattributetotheConstitutionoftheUnitedStates。DinedwithProfessorCreighton;metvariousinterestingpeople,anddiscussedwithhimandMrs。CreightonsundrypointsinEnglishhistory,especiallythecareerofArchbishopLaud;myopinionofMacaulay’sinjusticebeingconfirmedthereby。
December11。
WentinthemorningwithSedleyTaylorandProfessorStuart,M。P。,anoldfriendofformervisits,andinspectedthemechanicallaboratoryandworkshops。Therewereaboutseventyuniversitymen,moreorless,engagedinthese,anditwasinterestingtoseeEnglishCambridgeadoptingthesamelinewhichwehavealreadytakenatCornellagainstsomuchopposition,andsurprisingtofindtheCambridgeequipmentfarinferiortothatofCornell。Afterwardvisitedthepollingboothsforanelectionwhichwasgoingon,andnotedtheextraordinaryprecautionsagainstanyinterferencewiththesecrecyoftheballot。AlsototheCavendishphysicallaboratory,which,likethemechanicallaboratory,wasfarinferiorinequipmenttooursatCornell。IntheeveningtotheGreekplay,——the\"Eumenides\"ofaeschylus,——whichwaswonderfullywelldone。TheAthena,MissCaseofGirtonCollege,wassuperb;theApolloimposing;theOrestesagoodactor;andthemusicveryeffective。IfoundmyselfseatednextAndrewLang,sowellknownforhisliteraryactivityinvariousfields;andonspeakingtohimoftheevidentdelightsoflifeatCambridgeandOxford,Ifoundthathehadoutlivedhisenthusiasmonthatsubject。
December2。
InthemorningtookacharmingwalkthroughSt。Peter’s,Queen’s,andothercolleges,enjoyingtheirquietinteriorcourts,theirhallsandcloisters,thebridgesacrosstheCam,andthewalksbeyond。ThentoalecturebyProfessorSeeleyon\"ForcesofGovernmentinHistory。\"Itwasadmirablyclear,though,inparts,perhapstoosubtle。AstoEnglandhesummedallupbysayingthatitspresentsystemwassimplyrevolutionatanymoment。Walkinghomewithhimafterward,Iaskedwhy,ifhisstatementwerecorrect,itdidnotrealizetheoldidealinFrance——namely,thatof\"Larevolutionenpermanence。\"AtluncheonwithWaldsteinatKing’sCollegewefoundLordLytton,recentlygovernor—generalofIndia,knowntoliteratureas\"OwenMeredith,\"withLadyLytton;
alsoSirWilliamAnson,provostofAllSouls;aswellastheAthenaoflastevening,MissCase;theOrestes,theApollo,SirHenryMaine,andothers。IwasamusedatthedifferencebetweenLordLytton’swayofgreetingmeandhistreatmentofSirWilliamAnson。WhenIwasintroduced,heatoncetookmebythehand,andbegantalkingverycordiallyandopenly;butwhenhiseminentcountrymanwasintroduced,eacheyedtheotherasifinsuspicion,didnotshakehands,bowedverycoldly,andsaidnothingbeyondmutteringsomeoneoftheusualformulas。ItwasacuriousexampleoftheshynessofEnglishmeninmeetingeachother,andoftheirwantofshynessinmeetingmenfromothercountries。AttableLordLyttonspokeregardingtheannexationofBurmah,likelytobeaccomplishedbythedethronementoftheking,Theebaw;saidthatitoughttohavebeenaccomplishedlongago,andthatthedelayofactioninthepremiseswasduetoEnglishtimidity。BothheandLadyLyttonwereveryagreeable。HegaveaninterestingaccountofanativedramaperformedbeforehiminIndiaatthecommandofoneofthegreatprinces,thoughspeakingofitas\"deadlydull。\"Speakingofdifficultiesinlearningidioms,hetoldthestoryofaGermanprofessorwho,pridinghimselfonhisthoroughknowledgeofEnglishidioms,said,\"Wemust,asyouEnglishsay,takezecowbyzecorns。\"AtthissomeonerejoinedwiththestoryofthelearnedbabooinIndiawhospokeofsomethingas\"magnificent,soul—inspiring,andtip—top。\"AsanotherexampleofbabooEnglishwasmentionedtheinscriptionupononeoftheshow—casesinanexhibitioninIndia:
\"Allthegoodsinthiscaseareforsale,buttheycannotberemoveduntilafterthedayofjudgment。\"
IntheeveningmettheHistoricalClubatOscarBrowning’srooms,andheardanadmirablepaperbyProfessorSeeleyon\"BourbonFamilyCompacts。\"HesaidthatthefactoftheirexistencewasnotfullyestablisheduntilRankementionedthem,andthathe,Seeley,thenexaminedtheEnglishForeignOfficerecordsandfoundthem。HespokeofthemasrefutingtheargumentsofMacaulayandothersastothefollyofsupposingthatdifferentbranchesofthesamefamilyondifferentthronesarelikelytocoalesce。OscarBrowningthenreadapaperontheflightofLouisXVItoVarennes。Itwaselaborate,andbasedonclosestudyandpersonalobservation。BrowninghadeventakenmeasurementsofthedistanceoverwhichKingLouispassedonthatfatalnight,withtheresultthatheprovedCarlyle’saccounttobeentirelyinaccurate,andhisindictmentagainstLouisXVIbaseduponittobeabsurd。SofarfromtheKinghavinglumberedalongslowlythroughthenightinMme。Korf’scoachbecausehehadnottheforceofcharactertomakehisdrivergorapidly,Browningfoundthatthejourneywasmadeinremarkablyquicktime。
December3。
BreakfastingwithSedleyTaylor,ImetProfessorStuart,M。P。,whothinksagreatliberal,peacefulrevolutionintheEnglishconstitutionwillbeaccomplishedwithinthenextfiftyyears。
ThencewalkedwithTaylortoNewnhamCollege,wherewewereverykindlyreceivedbyMissGladstone,daughteroftheprimeminister,andshownallabouttheplace。WewerealsocordiallyreceivedbyMissClough,andmadetheacquaintanceoftwoAmericangirls,onefromNewJerseyandtheotherfromCalifornia。MuchprogresshadbeenmadesincemyformervisitundertheguidanceofProfessorandMrs。Fawcett。ThencetoJesusCollegechapelandsawWilliamMorris’sstainedglass,whichisthemostbeautifulmodernworkofthekindknowntome。
December4。
VisitedSt。John’s,St。Peter’s,andothercolleges;intheafternoonsawtheeight—oaredboatscomedowntheriverinfinestyle;andintheeveningwenttotheannual\"auditdinner\"atTrinityCollege,thenumberofvisitorsinthemagnificenthallbeingverylarge。Ifoundmyselfbetweenthevice—master,Trotter,andProfessorHumphrey,thedistinguishedsurgeon。ThelatterthoughtViennahadshotaheadofBerlininsurgery,thoughheconsideredBillrothtooventuresome,andpraisedrecentAmericanworksonsurgery,butthoughtEnglandwasstillkeepingthelead。Atthecloseofthedinnercameacuriouscustom。Twoservantsapproachedthevice—masterattheheadofthefirsttable,laiddownuponitanarrowrolloflinen,andthentheguestsrolledthisalongbypushingitfromeithersideuntil,whenithadreachedtheotherend,astripofsmoothlinenwasleftalongthemiddleofthewholetable。Thenagreatsilverdish,withladlesoneitherside,andcontainingsomesortoffragrantfluid,wassetinfrontofthevice—master,uponthenarrowstripoflinenwhichhadformedtheroll,andthesamethingwasrepeatedateachoftheothertables。Thevice—masterhavingthenfilledalargeglassathissidefromthedish,andI,athissuggestion,havingdonethesame,thegreatdishwaspusheddownthetabletoguestafterguest,eachfollowingourexample。Waitingtoseewhatwastofollow,Ipresentlyobservedagentlemannearmedippinghisnapkinintohisglassandvigorouslyscrubbinghisfaceandneckwithit,evidentlytocoolhimselfoffafterdinner;thiswasrepeatedwithmoreorlessthoroughnessbyotherspresent;andthencameamusicalgraceaftermeat——thenonnobis,Domine——wonderfullygivenbythechoir。Inthecombinationroom,afterward,ImetmostagreeablyMr。Trevelyan,M。P。,anephewofMacaulay,whohaswrittenanadmirablebiographyofhisuncle。
December6。
DinedatTrinityCollegeastheguestofAldisWright,andmetanumberofinterestingmen,amongthemMahaffy,theeminentprofessorofGreekatTrinityCollege,Dublin。BothheandWrighttoldexcellentstories。AmongthoseofthelatterwasoneofaScotchwomanwho,onbeinginformedofthechangemadebytherevisersintheLord’sPrayer,——namely,\"anddeliverusfromtheevilone,\"——said,\"Idoothe’llbesairuplifted。\"MahaffygavedrollaccountsofWhately,ArchbishopofDublin。OneofthesehadasitsheroacountryclergymanwhocametoaskWhatelyforalivingwhichhadjustbecomevacant。Thearchbishop,thinkingtohavealittlefunwithhisguest,said,\"Ofcourse,firstofall,Imustknowwhatyourchurchpoliticsare:areyouanattitudinarian,alatitudinarian,oraplatitudinarian?\"Towhichtheparsonreplied,\"ThankGod,yourGrace,IamnotanArianatallatall,ifthat’swhatyemane。\"ThepointofthislayinthefactthatamongthechargesconstantlymadebytheHigh—churchpartyagainstWhatelywasthatofsecretUnitarianism。ButthereplysoamusedWhatelythathebestowedthelivingontheoldparsonatonce。MahaffyalsosaidthatwhenArchbishopTrench,whowasamanexceedinglymindfuloftheproprietiesoflife,arrivedinDublinheassuredMahaffythatheintendedtofollowinallthingstheexampleofhiseminentpredecessor,whereuponMahaffyanswered,\"ShouldyourGracedoso,youwillinsummerfrequentlysitinyourshirtsleevesonthechainsinfrontofyourpalace,swingingtoandfro,andsmokingalongpipe。\"
Someonecappedthiswithastorythat,onavisitoroncetellingWhatelyhowafriendofhisinaremotepartofIrelandhadsuchconfidenceinthepeopleabouthimthatheneverlockedhisdoors,thearchbishopquietlyreplied,\"Somefinemorning,whenyourfriendwakes,hewillfindthatheistheonlyspoonleftinthehouse。\"
December7。
ForseveraldaysvisitingattractiveplacesinLondon。OfmostinteresttomeweretalkswithLecky,thehistorian。HeespeciallylamentedGoldwinSmith’sexpatriation,andreferredtohisadmirablestyle,thoughregrettinghislackofcontinuityinhistoricalwork。ThoughanIrishmandevotedmostheartilytoIreland,LeckythoughtGladstone’shomerulepolicysuicidal。OnmytellinghimofOscarBrowning’sstudyofLouisXVI’sflighttoVarennes,hestoodupforCarlyle’sgeneralaccuracy。HelikedSirHenryMaine’sbook,butwassurprisedatsomuchpraisefor\"TheFederalist,\"sincehethoughtStory’s\"Commentaries\"muchbetter。HethoughtDraper’s\"HistoryoftheIntellectualDevelopmentofEurope\"showedtoomuchfondnessforverylargegeneralizations。HelikedHildreth’s\"HistoryoftheUnitedStates\"betterthanBancroft’s,andIarguedagainstthisview。
HepraisedBuckle’sstyle,andwhenIaskedhimregardinghisown\"EighteenthCentury,\"hesaiditwastobelongerthanhehadexpected。Astohis\"EuropeanMorals,\"hesaidthatitmustberecastbeforeitcouldbecontinued。ReturningtothesubjectofhomeruleinIreland,hesaiditwassuretoleadtoreligiouspersecutionandconfiscation。Hespeaksinaverylow,gentlevoice,istallandawkward,buthasaverykindface,andpleasesmegreatly。DuringmystayinLondonIdidsomeworkintheBritishMuseumonsubjectswhichinterestedme,andatavisittoMaskelyneandCooke’sgreattempleofjuggleryinPiccadillysawadisplaywhichsetmethinking。Fewmiracle—mongershaveeverperformedanyfeatssowonderfulasthosethereaccomplished;themenandwomenwhotakesuchpleasureinattributingspiritualandsupernaturalorigintothecheapjuggleryof\"mediums\"shouldseethisperformance。
CHAPTERLIII
FRANCE,ITALY,ANDSWITZERLAND——1886—1887
NewYear’sdayof1886foundmywifeandmyselfagaininParis;
and,duringourstayofnearlyafortnightthere,wemetvariousinterestingpersons——amongthemMr。McLane,theAmericanministeratthatpost,whomIhadlastseen,overthirtyyearsbefore,whenwecrossedtheoceantogether——hethengoingasministertoChina,andIasattachetoSt。Petersburg。HisdiscussionsbothofAmericanandFrenchpoliticswereinteresting;butafarmoresuggestivetalkerwasMme。BlazedeBury。ThoughaFrenchwoman,shewassaidtobeadaughterofLordBrougham;hisportraithungaboveherchairinthesalon,andshecertainlyshowedaversatilityworthyofthefamousphilosopherandstatesman,ofwhomitwassaid,whenhewasappointedchancellor,thatifheonlyknewalittlelawhewouldknowalittleofeverything。Sheapparentlyknewnotonlyeverything,buteverybody,andaboundedinrevelationsandprophecies。
OnthewayfromParistotheRivieraweencounteredatLyonsverycoldweather,and,givingmywrapstomywife,Ihurriedoutintothestationintheevening,boughtofanews—venderamassofoldnewspapers,and,havingswathedmyselfinthese,wentthroughthenightcomfortably,althoughourcoupewasexposedtoamostpiercingwind。
ArrivingatCannes,wefoundJamesBryceoftheEnglishParliament,BaronGeorgevonBunsenoftheGermanParliament,andLordActon(sinceprofessorofhistoryattheUniversityofCambridge),allinterestingmen,butthelatterpeculiarlyso:
thenearestapproachtoomniscienceIhaveeverseen,withthepossibleexceptionofTheodoreParker。AnotherpersonwhoespeciallyattractedmewasSirCharlesMurray,formerlyBritishministeratLisbonandDresden。HisfirstwifewasanAmerican,——MissWadsworthofGeneseo,——andhehadtraveledmuchinAmerica——oncethroughtheAdirondackswithGovernorSeymourofNewYork,ofwhomhespokemostkindly。DiscussingtheEasternQuestion,hesaidthatanynation,exceptRussia,mighthaveConstantinople;hegavereminiscencesofoldKingJohnofSaxony,whowasveryscholarly,butthelastmanintheworldtobeaking。MostcharmingofallwerehisreminiscencesofTalleyrand。
ThebestthingsduringmystayweremywalksandtalkswithLordActon,whowasfullofinformationatfirsthandregardingGladstoneandotherleadersbothinEnglandandontheContinent。
AlthoughaRomanCatholic,hespokehighlyofFraser,lateAnglicanBishopofManchester。AstoAmericans,hehadknownCharlesSumnerinAmerica,buthadnotformedahighopinionofhim,evidentlythinkingthatthesenatororatedtoomuch;hehadwithhimalargecollectionofbooks,selected,doubtless,fromhistwolargelibraries,inLondonandintheTyrol,andwiththisheastonishedoneasdoesajugglerwho,fromasinglesmallbottle,poursoutanykindofwinedemanded。Forexample,oneday,Bunsen,Bryce,andmyselfbeingwithhim,thefirst—namedsaidsomethingregardingacuriousphilologicaltractbyBernays,putforthwhenBunsenwasastudentatGottingen,butnowentirelyoutofprint。AtthisLordActonwenttooneofhisshelves,tookdownthisraretract,andhandedittous。So,too,duringoneofourwalks,thetalkhappeningtofallupononeofmyheroes,FraPaoloSarpi,Iaskedhowitwasthat,whileintheoldchurchontheLagoonatVeniceIhadatthreedifferentvisitssoughtSarpi’sgraveinvain,IhadatthelastvisitfounditjustwhereIhadlookedforitbefore。AtthishegavemeamostinterestingaccountoftheoppositionofPopeGregoryXVI——who,beforehiselevationtothepapacy,hadbeenabbotofthemonastery——toSarpi’sburialwithinitssacredprecincts,andofthecompromiseunderwhichhisburialwasallowed。Thiscompromisewasthathisbones,whichhadsolongbeenkeptintheducallibrarytoprotectthemfromclericalhatred,mightbeburiedinthechurchontheisland,providedSarpiwere,duringtheceremonies,honoredsimplyasthediscovererofthecirculationoftheblood,——whichheprobablywasnot,——andnothonoredasthegreateststatesmanofVenice——whichhecertainlywas。This,asIthensupposed,closedthesubject;butintheafternoonaservantcameover,bringingmefromLordActonamostinterestingcollectionoforiginalmanuscriptsrelatingtoSarpi,——alargepartofthembeingthecorrespondencebetweenthepapalauthoritiesandtheVenetianswhohadwishedtogiveSarpi’sbonesdecentburial,overhalfacenturybefore。InowfoundthatthereasonwhyIhadnotdiscoveredthegravewasthatthemonks,aslongastheywereallowedcontrol,hadpersistedinbreakingupthetabletbearingtheinscription;thattheycouldnotdisturbthebonesforthereasonthatSarpi’sadmirershadinclosedtheminalargeandstrongironbox,anchoringitsothatitwasverydifficulttoremove;butthatsincethedeathofthelatepatriarchandtheabolitionofmonkishpowertheinscriptionoverthegravehadbeenallowedtoremainundisturbed。
Duringanotherofourmorningwalksthediscussionhavingfallenonwitchcraftpersecution,LordActoncalledintheafternoonandbroughtmeaninterestingadditiontomycollectionofcuriousbooksonthatsubject——avolumebyChristianThomasius。
OnanotherofourexcursionsIaskedhimregardingtheCongregationoftheIndexatRome,anditsprocedure。TothisheansweredthatindividualsorcommissionsareappointedtoexaminespecialworksandreportsthereupontotheCongregation,whichthenallowsorcondemnsthem,asmayseembest;andImarveledmuchwhen,intheafternoonofthatday,hesentmespecimensofsuchoriginalreportsonvariousbooks。
HeagreedwithmethatthepapalcondemnationofVictorHugo’s\"LesMiserables\"wasamistakeasamatterofpolicy——asgreatamistake,indeed,ashundredsandthousandsofothercondemnationshadbeen。OfPopeLeoXIIIhespokewithrespect,givingmeanaccountoftheveryliberalconcessionsmadebyhimattheVaticanlibrary,sothatitisnowfreelyopenedtoProtestants,whereasitwasformerlykeptcloselyshut。AtalaterperiodthiswasconfirmedtomebyDr。PhilipSchaff,theeminentProtestantchurchhistorian,whotoldmethatformerlyattheVaticanlibraryhewasonlyallowed,asaspecialfavor,tolookatthefamousCodex,withanattendantwatchinghimeverymoment;
whereasafterPopeLeoXIIIcameintocontrolhewaspermittedtostudytheCodexandtakenotesfromitathisease。
InanotherofhiswalksLordActondiscussedGladstone,whomhegreatlyadmired,butpointedoutsomecuriouspeculiaritiesinthegreatstatesmanandchurchman,——amongthese,thatheworshipedthememoryofArchbishopLaudanddetestedthememoryofWilliamIII。
VeryinterestingweresundrylittledinnersonSaturdayeveningsattheCercleNautique,atwhichIfoundnotonlyLordActon,butSirHenryKeating,aretiredEnglishjudge;GeneralPalfrey,whohaddistinguishedhimselfinourCivilWar;andafewothergoodtalkers。AtoneofthesedinnersSirHenrystartedthequestion:
\"Whowasthegreatestmanthateverlived?\"LordActongaveveryinterestingargumentsinfavorofNapoleon,whileIdidmybestinfavorofCaesar;myargumentbeingthatthesystemwhichCaesarfoundedmaintainedtheRomanEmpireduringnearlyfifteenhundredyearsafterhisdeath;thatitsfundamentalideasandfeatureshaveremainedeffectiveinvariousgreatnationsuntilthepresentday;andthattheyhaveinourowncenturyshownthemselvesmorevigorousthanever。LordActoninsistedthatwehavenomeansofknowingtheprocessesofCaesar’smind;thatweknowthemodeofthinkingofonlytwoancients,SocratesandCicero;thatpossibly,ifweknewmoreofShakspere’smentalprocesses,thepreeminencemightbeclaimedforhim,butthatweknownothingofthemsavefromhiswritings;whileweknowNapoleon’sthoroughlyfromthevastcollectionsofmemoirs,statepapers,orders,conversations,etc。,aswellasinhisamazingdealingswiththeproblemsofhistime;thatthescopeandpowerofNapoleon’smentalprocessesseemalmostpreternaturalandofthishegavevariousremarkableproofs。Hearguedthatconsiderationsofmoralcharacterandaims,aselementsingreatness,mustbeleftoutofsuchadiscussion;thattheintellectualprocessesandtheirresultswereallthatwecouldreallyestimateincomparingmen。SirHenryKeatingobservedthathisfather,anofficerintheBritisharmy,wasvastlyimpressedbythesightofNapoleonatSt。Helena;whereuponLordActonremarkedthatThiersacknowledgedtoGuizot,whotoldLordActon,thatNapoleonwas\"unscelerat。\"ThatseemedtomearatherstrongwordtobeusedbyamanwhohaddonesomuchtorevivetheNapoleoniclegendLordActonalsoquotedawell—authenticatedstory——vouchedforbytwopersonswhomhenamed,oneofthembeingtheCountdeFlahaut,whowaspresentandheardtheremark——thatwhentheimperialguardsbrokeatWaterloo,Napoleonsaid,\"IthasalwaysbeensosinceCrecy。\"
TowardtheendofFebruarywewentontoFlorence,andtheremet,frequently,Villari,thehistorian;Mantegazzi;andotherleadingFlorentines。MentionbeingmadeoftheJesuitFatherCurci,whohadrebelledagainstwhatheconsideredthefatalinfluenceofJesuitismonthepapacy,Villarithoughthimtooscholastictohaveanyrealinfluence。OfSettembrinihespokehighlyasanoblecharacterandvaluablecritic,thoughwithnopermanentplaceinItalianliterature。HeexcusedthetardinessofItaliansinputtingupstatuestoGiordanoBrunoandFraPaoloSarpi,sincetheyhadsomanyotherrecentstatuestoputup。AsIlookbackuponthisconversation,itisapleasuretorememberthatI
havelivedtoseeboththesestatues——thatofBruno,ontheplaceinRomewherehewasburnedalive,andthatofSarpi,ontheplaceinVenicewheretheassassinssentbyPopePaulVlefthimfordead。
EarlyinMarchwearrivedinNaples,goingpiouslythroughtheoldsightswehadseenseveraltimesbefore。RevisitingAmalfi,I
sawthearchbishoppontificatingatthecathedral:hewasthefinest—lookingprelateIeversaw,remindingmeamazinglyofmyoldprofessor,SillimanofYale。Then,duringthestayofsomeweeksinSorrento,ItookasanItalianteacheracharmingoldpadre,whoreadhismasseverymorninginoneofthechurchesanddevotedtherestofthedaytoliterature。Hewasatheartliberal,anditwasfromhimthatIreceivedacopyofthefamous\"Politico—PhilosophicalCatechism,\"adoptedbyArchbishopApuzzoofSorrento,thanwhich,probably,nothingmoredefiantofmoralprincipleswaseverwritten。Thearchbishophadbeenmadeby\"KingBomba\"tutortohisson,andnowonderthattheyoungmanwasfinallykickedignominiouslyoffhisthrone,andhiscountryannexedtotheItaliankingdom。Thiscatechism,writtenyearsbeforebytheelderLeopardi,butadoptedandpromotedbythearchbishop,wasdevotedtomaintainingtherighteousnessofallthatsystemofextremedespotism,oath—breaking,defianceofnationalsentiment,andviolationsofordinarydecency,whichhadmadethekingdomofNaplesabywordduringsomanygenerations。
Thereinpatriotismwasprovedtobeadelusion;populareducationanabsurdity;observanceofthemonarch’sswornwordoppositiontodivinelaw;aconstitutionamereplaythinginthemonarch’shands;theBibleissteadilyquotedinbehalfof\"therightdivineofkingstogovernwrong\";andallthiswithamixtureofcynicismandunctuousnesswhichmakesthiscatechismoneofthemostremarkablepoliticalworksofmoderntimes。
AtthistimeImadeaninterestingacquaintancewithFrancisGalton,theeminentEnglishauthorityonheredity。Discussingdreams,hetoldmeastoryofaladywhosaidthatsheknewthatdreamscametrue;forshedreamedoncethatthenumber3drewaprizeinthelottery,andagainthatthenumber8drewit;andso,shesaid,\"Imultipliedthemtogether,3X8=27,boughtaticketbearingthelatternumber,andwontheprize。\"
VeryinterestingweremymeetingswithMarionCrawford,theauthor。Nothingcouldbemoredelightfulthanhisvillaandsurroundings,andhisaccountsofItalianlifewerefascinating,asonewouldexpectafterreadinghisnovels。AnothernewacquaintancewasMr。Mayall,anEnglishmicroscopist;hegavemeaccountsofhisvisittotheLouvrewithHerbertSpencer,who,afterlookingsteadilyatthe\"ImmaculateConception\"ofMurillo,said\"Icannotlikeapaintedfigurethathasnovisiblemeansofsupport。\"
OnmyreturnnorthwardIvisitedthemostfamousofChristianmonasteries,——thecradleoftheBenedictineorder,——MonteCassino,andtheremetayoungEnglishnovice,whointroducedmetovariousBenedictinefathers,especiallysundryGermanswhoweredecoratingwithByzantinefiguresthelowerstory,nearthealtarofSt。Benedict。AtdinnertheyoungmanagreedwithmethatitmightbewelltohaveaBenedictinecollegeatOxford,butthoughtthatanycollegeestablishedtheremustbecontrolledbytheJesuitorder。HeprofessedrespectfortheJesuits,butevidentlywithsomemistrustoftheirmethods。