Itwouldhaveseveraluses——oneofthemrelevanttothetruthabovepointedout。Suchapresentationwouldmakeclearhowthatidentityofgovernmentalethicswithmilitaryethicswhichnecessarilyexistsduringprimitivetimes,whenthearmyissimplythemobilizedsocietyandthesocietyisthequiescentarmy,continuesthroughlongstages,andevennowaffectsingreatdegreesourlaw—proceedingsandourdailylives。Having,forinstance,shownthatinnumeroussavagetribesthejudicialfunctionofthechiefdoesnotexist,orisnominal,andthatverygenerallyduringearlystagesofEuropeancivilization,eachmanhadtodefendhimselfandrectifyhisprivatewrongsasbesthemight——havingshownthatinmedievaltimestherightofprivatewaramongmembersofthemilitaryorderwasbroughttoanend,notbecausetheheadrulerthoughtithisdutytoarbitrate,butbecauseprivatewarsinterferedwiththeefficiencyofhisarmyinpublicwarshavingshownthattheadministrationofjusticedisplayedthroughsubsequentagesalargeamountofitsprimitivenature,intrialbybattlecarriedonbeforethekingorhisdeputyasumpire,andwhich,amongourselves,continuednominallytobeanalternativeformoftrialdownto1819;itmightthenbepointedoutthatevennowtheresurvivestrialbybattleunderanotherform:counselbeingthechampionsandpursestheweapons。Incivilcases,therulingagencycaresscarcelymorethanofoldaboutrectifyingthewrongsoftheinjured;but,practically,itsdeputydoeslittleelsethantoenforcetherulesofthefight:theresultbeinglessaquestionofequitythanaquestionofpecuniaryabilityandforensicskill。Nay,solittleconcernfortheadministrationofjusticeisshownbytherulingagency,thatwhen,bylegalconflictcarriedoninthepresenceofitsdeputy,thecombatantshavebeenpecuniarilybledeventotheextentofproducingprostration,andwhenanappealbeingmadebyoneofthemthedecisionisreversed,thebeatencombatantismadetopayfortheblundersofthedeputy,orofaprecedingdeputy;andnotunfrequentlythewrongedman,whosoughtprotectionorrestitution,istakenoutofcourtpecuniarilydead。
Adequatelydone,suchaportrayalofgovernmentalmisdeedsofcommissionandomission,provingthatthepartially—survivingcodeofethicsarisingin,andproperto,astateofwar,stillvitiatesgovernmentalaction,mightgreatlymoderatethehopesofthosewhoareanxioustoextendgovernmentalcontrol。Afterobservingthatalongwiththestill—manifesttraitsofthatprimitivepoliticalstructurewhichchronicmilitancyproduces,theregoesastill—manifestsurvivalofitsprimitiveprinciples;
thereformerandthephilanthropistmightbelesssanguineintheiranticipationsofgoodfromitsall—pervadingagency,andmightbemoreinclinedtotrustagenciesofanon—governmentalkind。
Butleavingoutthegreaterpartofthelargetopiccomprehendedunderthetitleofthisarticle,Iproposeheretodealonlywithacomparativelysmallremainingpart——thosesinsoflegislatorswhicharenotgeneratedbytheirpersonalambitionsorclassinterests,butresultfromalackofthestudybywhichtheyaremorallyboundtopreparethemselves。
Adruggist’sassistantwho,afterlisteningtothedescriptionofpainswhichhemistakesforthoseofcolic,butwhicharereallycausedbyinflammationofthececum,prescribesasharppurgativeandkillsthepatient,isfoundguiltyofmanslaughter。Heisnotallowedtoexcusehimselfonthegroundthathedidnotintendharmbuthopedforgood。Thepleathathesimplymadeamistakeinhisdiagnosisisnotentertained。Heistoldthathehadnorighttoriskdisastrousconsequencesbymeddlinginamatterconcerningwhichhisknowledgewassoinadequate。Thefactthathewasignoranthowgreatwashisignoranceisnotacceptedinbarofjudgment。Itistacitlyassumedthattheexperiencecommontoallshouldhavetaughthimthateventheskilled,andmuchmoretheunskilled,makemistakesintheidentificationofdisordersandintheappropriatetreatment;andthathavingdisregardedthewarningderivablefromcommonexperience,hewasanswerablefortheconsequences。