16
But，ratherthanpursuethissubject，letusbejustandadmitthatthereisperhapsnowayoutofthemazeandthatourreproachesareasincomprehensibleastheconductofthespirits。
Indeed，whatwouldyouhavethemdointhecircleinwhichourlogicimprisonsthem？Eithertheyforetellusacalamitywhichtheirpredictionscannotavert，inwhichcasethereisnouseinforetellingit，or，iftheyannounceittousandatthesametimegiveusthemeanstopreventit，theydonotreallyseethefutureandareforetellingnothing，sincethecalamityisnottotakeplace，withtheresultthattheiractionseemsequallyabsurdinbothcases。
Itisobvious：towhicheversideweturn，wefindnothingbuttheincomprehensible。Ontheonehand，thepreestablished，unshakable，unalterablefuturewhichwehavecalleddestiny，fatalityorwhatyouwill，whichsuppressesman’sentireindependenceandlibertyofactionandwhichisthemostinconceivableandthedreariestofmysteries；ontheother，intelligencesapparentlysuperiortoourown，sincetheyknowwhatwedonot，which，whileawarethattheirinterventionisalwaysuselessandveryoftencruel，neverthelesscomeharassinguswiththeirsinisterandridiculouspredictions。Mustweresignourselvesoncemoretolivingwithoureyesshutandourreasondrownedintheboundlessoceanofdarkness；andistherenooutlet？
17