Herespectsmyresponsibilitynoless——thoughherespectsitlessexplicitly——thanIdohis。Whatheallowsmewouldnotbegrantedbyameanermaster。Ifhedoesnotholdhimselfboundtoprovehisowntruth,hereturnsthanksformytrust。Itisasthoughheusedhiscountrymen’scourteoushyperboleandcalledhishousemyown。
Inasenseofthemostnoblehostshiphedoesmethehonoursofhispicture。
BecauseImpressionismissofree,thereforeisitdoublybound。
Becausethereisnonetoarraignit,itisathousandtimesresponsible。Toundertakethisartforthesakeofitsprivilegeswithoutconfessingitsobligations——oratleastwithoutconfessingthemuptothepointofhonour——istotakeavulgarfreedom:toseeimmunitiespreciselywherethereareduties,andanadvantagewherethereisabond。AverymobofmenhavetakenImpressionismuponthemselvesinthisourlaterday。Itisagainstallprobabilitiesthatmorethanafewamongthesehavewithinthemthepointofhonour。Intheirgallerieswearebesetwithadimdistrust。Andtodistrustismorehumiliatingthantobedistrusted。Howmanyoftheselandscape-painters,deliberatelyrash,arepaintingthetruthoftheirownimpressions?Anethicalquestionastoloyaltyiseasilyanswered;truthandfalsehoodastofactare,happilyfortheintelligenceofthecommonconscience,nothardtodivide。ButwhentheDUBIUMconcernsnotfactbutartistictruth,canthemanybesurethattheirsensitiveness,theircandour,theirscruple,theirdelicateequipoiseofperceptions,thevigilanceoftheirapprehension,areenough?NowImpressionistsoflatehavetoldusthingsastotheirimpressions——astotheeffectofthingsuponthetemperamentofthismananduponthemoodofthat——whichshouldnotbeassertedexceptontheartisticpointofhonour。Themajoritycantellordinarytruth,buttheyshouldnottrustthemselvesfortruthextraordinary。Theycanfacethegeneraljudgment,buttheyshouldhesitatetoproduceworkthatappealstothelastjudgment,whichisthejudgmentwithin。Thereistoomuchreasontodivinethatacertainnumberofthosewhoaspiretoderivefromthegreatestofmastershavenotemperamentsworthspeakingof,nopointofviewworthseizing,novigilanceworthawaiting,nomoodworthwaylaying。Andtobe,departipris,anImpressionistwithoutthese!OVelasquez!Norisliteraturequitefreefromalikereproachinherownthings。Anauthor,hereandthere,willmakeasthoughhehadawordworthhearing——nay,worthover-hearing——awordthatseekstowithdrawevenwhileitisuttered;andyetwhatitseemstodissembleisalltooprobablyaplatitude。Butobviously,literatureisnot——asisthecraftandmysteryofpainting——soatthemercyofahalf-imposture,soguardedbyunprovablehonour。Fortheartofpaintingisreservedthatshadowyrisk,thatundefinedsalvation。MaythegodsguardusfromthefurtherpopularisingofImpressionism;forthepointofhonouristhesimplesecretofthefew。
COMPOSURE