Benthamwasclearlythevictimofacommondelusion。Ifasystemwillwork,theminutestdetailscanbeexhibited。Therefore,itisinferred,anexhibitionofminutedetailprovesthatitwillwork。Unfortunately,thephilosophersofLaputawouldhavehadnomoredifficultyinfillingupdetailsthanthelegislatorsofEnglandortheUnitedStates。WhenBenthamhadsettledinhis’RadicalReformBill’83*thatthe’voting-box’wastobeadoublecubeofcast-iron,withaslitinthelid,intowhichcardstwoinchesbyone,whiteononesideandblackontheother,couldbeinserted,hemusthavefeltthathehadgotveryneartoactualapplication:hecanpicturethewholeoperationandnobodycansaythattheschemeisimpracticableforwantofworkingplansofthemachinery。Therewill,doubtless,benodifficultyinsettlingtheshapeoftheboxes,whenwehaveonceagreedtohavetheballot。ButadiscussionofsuchremotedetailsofUtopiaisofincomparablylessrealinterestthanthediscussionintheRationaleofEvidenceofpoints,which,howeverminute,wereoccurringeveryday,andwhichwerereallyinurgentneedofthelightofcommon-sense。
Bentham’sgeneralprinciplesmaybeverysimplystated。Theyare,infact,suchasweresuggestedbyhisviewoflegalgrievances。Why,whenhehaddemonstratedthatcertainmeasureswouldcontributetothe’greatesthappinessofthegreatestnumber,’weretheynotatonceadopted?Becausetherulersdidnotdesirethegreatesthappinessofthegreatestnumber。This,inBentham’slanguage,istosaythattheyweregovernedbya’sinisterinterest。’Theirinterestwasthatoftheirclass,notthatofthenation;theyaimedatthegreatesthappinessofsome,notatthegreatesthappinessofall。Ageneralisationofthisremarkgivesusthefirstaxiomsofallgovernment。Therearetwoprimaryprinciples:the’self-preference’principle,invirtueofwhicheverymanalwaysdesireshisowngreatesthappiness;andthe’greatesthappiness’
principle,invirtueofwhich’therightandproperend’ofgovernmentisthe’greatesthappinessofthegreatestnumber。’84*The’actualend’ofeverygovernment,again,isthegreatesthappinessofthegovernors。Hencethewholeproblemistoproduceacoincidenceofthetwoends,bysecuringanidentityofinterestbetweengovernorsandgoverned。Tosecurethatwehaveonlytoidentifythetwoclassesortoputthegovernmentinthehandsofall。85*Inamonarchy,theruleraimsattheinterestofonehimself;
ina’limitedmonarchy’theaimisatthehappinessofthekingandthesmallprivilegedclass;inademocracy,theendistherightonethegreatesthappinessofthegreatestnumber。Thisisashortcuttoallconstitutionalquestions。
Probablyithasoccurredinsubstancetomostyouthfulmembersofdebatingsocieties。Bentham’sconfidenceinhislogicliftshimaboveanyappealtoexperience;andheoccasionallyremindsusoftheproofgiveninMartinChuzzlewitthatthequeenmustliveintheTowerofLondon。The’monarch,’asheobserves,86*