Suchagovernmentisevidentlyrestrainedtoverynarrowlimitsofspaceandpopulation。IdoubtifitwouldbepracticablebeyondtheextentofaNewEnglandtownship。Thefirstshadefromthispureelement,which,likethatofpurevitalair,cannotsustainlifeofitself,wouldbewherethepowersofthegovernment,beingdivided,shouldbeexercisedeachbyrepresentativeschoseneither_prohacvice_,orforsuchshorttermsasshouldrendersecurethedutyofexpressingthewilloftheirconstituents。ThisIshouldconsiderasthenearestapproachtoapurerepublic,whichispracticableonalargescaleofcountryorpopulation。AndwehaveexamplesofitinsomeofourStatesconstitutions,which,ifnotpoisonedbypriest-craft,wouldproveitsexcellenceoverallmixtureswithotherelements;and,withonlyequaldosesofpoison,wouldstillbethebest。Othershadesofrepublicanismmaybefoundinotherformsofgovernment,wheretheexecutive,judiciaryandlegislativefunctions,andthedifferentbranchesofthelatter,arechosenbythepeoplemoreorlessdirectly,forlongertermsofyearsorforlife,ormadehereditary;orwheretherearemixturesofauthorities,somedependenton,andothersindependentofthepeople。Thefurtherthedeparturefromdirectandconstantcontrolbythecitizens,thelesshasthegovernmentoftheingredientofrepublicanism;evidentlynonewheretheauthoritiesarehereditary,asinFrance,Venice,&c。,orself-chosen,asinHolland;andlittle,whereforlife,inproportionasthelifecontinuesinbeingaftertheactofelection。
ThepurestrepublicanfeatureinthegovernmentofourownState,istheHouseofRepresentatives。TheSenateisequallysothefirstyear,lessthesecond,andsoon。TheExecutivestillless,becausenotchosenbythepeopledirectly。TheJudiciaryseriouslyanti-republican,becauseforlife;andthenationalarmwielded,asyouobserve,bymilitaryleadersirresponsiblebuttothemselves。
Addtothistheviciousconstitutionofourcountycourtstowhomthejustice,theexecutiveadministration,thetaxation,police,themilitaryappointmentsofthecounty,andnearlyallourdailyconcernsareconfided,self-appointed,self-continued,holdingtheirauthoritiesforlife,andwithanimpossibilityofbreakinginontheperpetualsuccessionofanyfactiononcepossessedofthebench。
Theyareintruth,theexecutive,thejudiciary,andthemilitaryoftheirrespectivecounties,andthesumofthecountiesmakestheState。Andadd,also,thatonehalfofourbrethrenwhofightandpaytaxes,areexcluded,likeHelots,fromtherightsofrepresentation,asifsocietywereinstitutedforthesoil,andnotforthemeninhabitingit;oronehalfofthesecoulddisposeoftherightsandthewilloftheotherhalf,withouttheirconsent。”WhatconstitutesaState?
Nothigh-raisedbattlements,orlabor’dmound,Thickwall,ormoatedgate;