Ofcourse,Browningisnotpersistentlyneglectfulofthisfundamentalnecessityfortheliteraryartist。Heisoftenasmasterlyinthisasinotherrespects。Butheisnotalways,notoftenenough,alivetotheparamountneed。Hewriteswith“theversebeingasthemooditpaints:“but,unfortunately,themoodisoftenpoeticallyunformative。Hehadnopassionforthequestforseductiveforms。Toomuchofhispoetryhasbeenbornprematurely。Toomuchofit,indeed,hasnotdiedandbeenbornagainforallimmortalverseisapoeticresurrection。
Perfectpoetryisthedeathlesspartofmortalbeauty。
Thegreatartistsneverperpetuategrossactualities,thoughtheyarethesupremerealists。ItisSchiller,Ithink,whosaysineffect,thattoliveagainintheserenebeautyofart,itisneedfulthatthingsshouldfirstdieinreality。
ThusBrowning’sdramaticmethod,even,issometimesdisastrousinitsuntruth,asinCaliban’sanalyticalreasoninganinitialabsurdity,asMr。Berdoehaspointedout,addingepigrammatically,`Calibanisasavage,withtheintrospectivepowersofaHamlet,andthetheologyofanevangelicalChurchman。’NotonlyCaliban,butseveralotherofBrowning’spersonagesAprile,Eglamour,etc。
arewhatGoethecalls`schwankendeGestalten’,mere“waveringimages“。