Whileacknowledgingtheimportanceofparticularfactsassamplesofhighertruths,heistotakeabroadandgeneralviewofhumanity.Heistodealwiththewholeraceandwiththeworld,notwithparticulartribesorseparatecountries.Heistobearinmindthattheworldisreallyanorganismwhereinnoonepartcanbemovedwithouttheothersbeingaffectedalso.Heistodistinguishbetweencauseandoccasion,betweentheinfluenceofgenerallawsandparticularfancies,andheistorememberthatthegreatestlessonsoftheworldarecontainedinhistoryandthatitisthehistorian’sdutytomanifestthemsoastosavenationsfromfollowingthoseunwisepolicieswhichalwaysleadtodishonourandruin,andtoteachindividualstoapprehendbytheintellectualcultureofhistorythosetruthswhichelsetheywouldhavetolearninthebitterschoolofexperience,Now,asregardshistheoryofthenecessityofthehistorian’sbeingcontemporarywiththeeventshedescribes,sofarasthehistorianisamerenarratortheremarkisundoubtedlytrue.Buttoappreciatetheharmonyandrationalpositionofthefactsofagreatepoch,todiscoveritslaws,thecauseswhichproduceditandtheeffectswhichitgenerates,thescenemustbeviewedfromacertainheightanddistancetobecompletelyapprehended.A
thoroughlycontemporaryhistoriansuchasLordClarendonorThucydidesisinrealitypartofthehistoryhecriticises;and,inthecaseofsuchcontemporaryhistoriansasFabiusandPhilistus,Polybiusincompelledtoacknowledgethattheyaremisledbypatrioticandotherconsiderations.AgainstPolybiushimselfnosuchaccusationcanbemade.Heindeedofallmenisable,asfromsomeloftytower,todiscernthewholetendencyoftheancientworld,thetriumphofRomaninstitutionsandofGreekthoughtwhichisthelastmessageoftheoldworldand,inamorespiritualsense,hasbecometheGospelofthenew.
Onethingindeedhedidnotsee,orifhesawit,hethoughtbutlittleofit—howfromtheEasttherewasspreadingovertheworld,asawavespreads,aspiritualinroadofnewreligionsfromthetimewhenthePessinuntinemotherofthegods,ashapelessmassofstone,wasbroughttotheeternalcitybyherholiestcitizen,tothedaywhentheshipCASTORANDPOLLUXstoodinatPuteoli,andSt.PaulturnedhisfacetowardsmartyrdomandvictoryatRome.
Polybiuswasabletopredict,fromhisknowledgeofthecausesofrevolutionsandthetendenciesofthevariousformsofgovernments,theuprisingofthatdemocratictoneofthoughtwhich,assoonasaseedissowninthemurderoftheGracchiandtheexileofMarius,culminatedasalldemocraticmovementsdoculminate,inthesupremeauthorityofoneman,thelordshipoftheworldundertheworld’srightfullord,CaiusJuliusCaesar.This,indeed,hesawinnouncertainway.Buttheturningofallmen’sheartstotheEast,thefirstglimmeringofthatsplendiddawnwhichbrokeoverthehillsofGalileeandfloodedtheearthlikewine,washiddenfromhiseyes.
TherearemanypointsinthedescriptionoftheidealhistorianwhichonemaycomparetothepicturewhichPlatohasgivenusoftheidealphilosopher.Theyareboth’spectatorsofalltimeandallexistence.’Nothingiscontemptibleintheireyes,forallthingshaveameaning,andtheybothwalkinaugustreasonablenessbeforeallmen,consciousoftheworkingsofGodyetfreefromallterrorofmendicantpriestorvagrantmiracle—worker.Buttheparallelendshere.Fortheonestandsalooffromtheworld—stormofsleetandhail,hiseyesfixedondistantandsunlitheights,lovingknowledgeforthesakeofknowledgeandwisdomforthejoyofwisdom,whiletheotherisaneageractorintheworldeverseekingtoapplyhisknowledgetousefulthings.Bothequallydesiretruth,buttheonebecauseofitsutility,theotherforitsbeauty.Thehistorianregardsitastherationalprincipleofalltruehistory,andnomore.Totheotheritcomesasanall—