Asthedifferentrulesofmoralityadmitsuchdifferentdegreesofaccuracy,thoseauthorswhohaveendeavouredtocollectanddigestthemintosystemshavedoneitintwoDifferentmanners;andonesethasfollowedthroughthewholethatloosemethodtowhichtheywerenaturallydirectedbytheconsiderationofonespeciesofvirtues;whileanotherhasasuniversallyendeavouredtointroduceintotheirpreceptsthatsortofaccuracyofwhichonlysomeofthemaresusceptible。Thefirsthavewrotelikecritics,thesecondlikegrammarians。
I。Thefirst,amongwhomwemaycountalltheancientmoralists,havecontentedthemselveswithdescribinginageneralmannerthedifferentvicesandvirtues,andwithpointingoutthedeformityandmiseryoftheonedispositionaswellastheproprietyandhappinessoftheother,buthavenotaffectedtolaydownmanypreciserulesthataretoholdgoodunexceptionablyinallparticularcases。Theyhaveonlyendeavouredtoascertain,asfaraslanguageiscapableofascertaining,first,whereinconsiststhesentimentoftheheart,uponwhicheachparticularvirtueisfounded,whatsortofinternalfeelingoremotionitiswhichconstitutestheessenceoffriendship,ofhumanity,ofgenerosity,ofjustice,ofmagnanimity,andofalltheothervirtues,aswellasoftheviceswhichareopposedtothem:and,secondly,whatisthegeneralwayofacting,theordinarytoneandtenorofconducttowhicheachofthosesentimentswoulddirectus,orhowitisthatafriendly,agenerous,abrave,ajust,andahumaneman,would,uponordinaryoccasions,chusetoact。
Tocharacterizethesentimentoftheheart,uponwhicheachparticularvirtueisfounded,thoughitrequiresbothadelicateandanaccuratepencil,isatask,however,whichmaybeexecutedwithsomedegreeofexactness。Itisimpossible,indeed,toexpressallthevariationswhicheachsentimenteitherdoesoroughttoundergo,accordingtoeverypossiblevariationofcircumstances。Theyareendless,andlanguagewantsnamestomarkthemby。Thesentimentoffriendship,forexample,whichwefeelforanoldmanisdifferentfromthatwhichwefeelforayoung:
thatwhichweentertainforanausteremandifferentfromthatwhichwefeelforoneofsofterandgentlermanners:andthatagainfromwhatwefeelforoneofgayvivacityandspirit。Thefriendshipwhichweconceiveforamanisdifferentfromthatwithwhichawomanaffectsus,evenwherethereisnomixtureofanygrosserpassion。Whatauthorcouldenumerateandascertaintheseandalltheotherinfinitevarietieswhichthissentimentiscapableofundergoing?Butstillthegeneralsentimentoffriendshipandfamiliarattachmentwhichiscommontothemall,maybeascertainedwithasufficientdegreeofaccuracy。Thepicturewhichisdrawnofit,thoughitwillalwaysbeinmanyrespectsincomplete,may,however,havesucharesemblanceastomakeusknowtheoriginalwhenwemeetwithit,andevendistinguishitfromothersentimentstowhichithasaconsiderableresemblance,suchasgood-will,respect,esteem,admiration。
Todescribe,inageneralmanner,whatistheordinarywayofactingtowhicheachvirtuewouldpromptus,isstillmoreeasy。