Thereisagratificationoftheartisticsenseinthecontemplationofskillfulwork。Butitisalsotobeaddedthatnosuchevidenceofskillfulworkmanship,orofingeniousandeffectiveadaptationofmeanstoanend,will,inthelongrun,enjoytheapprobationofthemoderncivilizedconsumerunlessithasthesanctionoftheCanonofconspicuouswaste。
Thepositionheretakenisenforcedinafelicitousmannerbytheplaceassignedintheeconomyofconsumptiontomachineproducts。Thepointofmaterialdifferencebetweenmachine-madegoodsandthehand-wroughtgoodswhichservethesamepurposesis,ordinarily,thattheformerservetheirprimarypurposemoreadequately。Theyareamoreperfectproduct——showamoreperfectadaptationofmeanstoend。Thisdoesnotsavethemfromdisesteemanddeprecation,fortheyfallshortunderthetestofhonorificwaste。Handlaborisamorewastefulmethodofproduction;hencethegoodsturnedoutbythismethodaremoreserviceableforthepurposeofpecuniaryreputability;hencethemarksofhandlaborcometobehonorific,andthegoodswhichexhibitthesemarkstakerankasofhighergradethanthecorrespondingmachineproduct。Commonly,ifnotinvariably,thehonorificmarksofhandlaborarecertainimperfectionsandirregularitiesinthelinesofthehand-wroughtarticle,showingwheretheworkmanhasfallenshortintheexecutionofthedesign。Thegroundofthesuperiorityofhand-wroughtgoods,therefore,isacertainmarginofcrudeness。Thismarginmustneverbesowideastoshowbunglingworkmanship,sincethatwouldbeevidenceoflowcost,norsonarrowastosuggesttheidealprecisionattainedonlybythemachine,forthatwouldbeevidenceoflowcost。
TheappreciationofthoseevidencesofhonorificcrUdenesstowhichhand-wroughtgoodsowetheirsuperiorworthandcharmintheeyesofwell-bredpeopleisamatterofnicediscrimination。
Itrequirestrainingandtheformationofrighthabitsofthoughtwithrespecttowhatmaybecalledthephysiognomyofgoods。
Machine-madegoodsofdailyuseareoftenadmiredandpreferredpreciselyonaccountoftheirexcessiveperfectionbythevulgarandtheunderbredwhohavenotgivenduethoughttothepunctiliosofelegantconsumption。Theceremonialinferiorityofmachineproductsgoestoshowthattheperfectionofskillandworkmanshipembodiedinanycostlyinnovationsinthefinishofgoodsisnotsufficientofitselftosecurethemacceptanceandpermanentfavor。Theinnovationmusthavethesupportofthecanonofconspicuouswaste。Anyfeatureinthephysiognomyofgoods,howeverpleasinginitself,andhoweverwellitmayapproveitselftothetasteforeffectivework,willnotbetoleratedifitprovesobnoxioustothisnormofpecuniaryreputability。