Amonglatermoralists,Kantisespeciallynotedforhisrigourinseparatingthepurelyrationalelementofthemoralcode:andhisethicalviewalsoappearstometocoincidetoaconsiderableextent,ifnotcompletely,withthatsetforthintheprecedingsection。Ihavealreadynoticedthathisfundamentalprincipleofdutyisthe`formal’ruleof``actingonamaximthatonecanwilltobelawuniversal’’;which,dulyrestricted,isanimmediatepracticalcorollaryfromtheprinciplethatIfirstnoticedintheprecedingsection。Andwefindthatwhenhecomestoconsidertheendsatwhichvirtuousactionisaimed,theonlyreallyultimateendwhichhelaysdownistheobjectofRationalBenevolenceascommonlyconceived——thehappinessofothermen。[7]Heregardsitasevidentapriorithateachmanasarationalagentisboundtoaimatthehappinessofothermen:indeed,inhisview,itcanonlybestatedasadutyformetoseekmyownhappinesssofarasIconsideritasapartofthehappinessofmankindingeneral。Idisagreewiththenegativesideofthisstatement,asIholdwithButlerthat``one’sownhappinessisamanifestobligation’’
independentlyofone’srelationtoothermen;but,regardedonitspositiveside,Kant’sconclusionappearstoagreetoagreatextentwiththeviewofthedutyofRationalBenevolencethatIhavegiven:——thoughIamnotaltogetherabletoassenttotheargumentsbywhichKantarrivesathisconclusion。
1mustnowpointout——ifithasnotlongbeenapparenttothereader——thattheself-evidentprincipleslaiddownin§;3donotspeciallybelongtoIntuitionisminthe,restrictedsensewhich,forcleardistinctionofmethods,Igavetothistermattheoutsetofourinvestigation。TheaxiomofPrudence,asIhavegivenit,isaself-evidentprinciple,impliedinRationalEgoismascommonlyaccepted。
Again,theaxiomofJusticeorEquityasabovestated——`thatsimilarcasesoughttobetreatedsimilarly’——belongsinallitsapplicationstoUtilitarianismasmuchastoanysystemcommonlycalledIntuitional:whiletheaxiomofRationalBenevolenceis,inmyview,requiredasarationalbasisfortheUtilitariansystem。
Accordingly,IfindthatIarrive,inmysearchforreallyclearandcertainethicalintuitions,atthefundamentalprincipleofUtilitarianism。Imust,however,admitthatthethinkerswhoinrecenttimeshavetaughtthislattersystem,havenot,forthemostpart,expresslytriedtoexhibitthetruthoftheirfirstprinciplebymeansofanysuchprocedureasthatabovegiven。Still,whenIexaminethe``proof’’ofthe``principleofUtility’’presentedbythemostpersuasiveandprobablythemostinfluentialamongEnglishexpositorsofUtilitarianism,——J。S。