BesidestheVirtueofPurity,whichwefounditconvenienttodiscussinthelastchapter,thereremainoneortwoprominentexcellencesofcharacterwhichdonotseemtobecommonlyadmiredandinculcatedwithanydistinctreferenceeithertoprivateortogeneralhappiness;
andwhich,thoughinmostcasesobviouslyconducivetooneorotheroftheseends,sometimesseemtoinfluenceconductinadirectionatvariancewiththem。
Forexample,Courageisaqualitywhichexcitesgeneraladmiration,whetheritisshowninself-defence,orinaidingothers,orevenwhenwedonotseeanybenefitresultingfromtheparticularexhibitionofit。Again,inChristiansocieties,Humilityifbelievedsincereoftenobtainsunqualifiedpraise,inspiteofthelossthatmayevidentlyresultfromaman’sunderratinghisownabilities。Itwillbewell,therefore,toexaminehowfarineithercasewecanelicitaclearandindependentmaximdefiningtheconductcommendedundereachofthesenotions。
TobeginwithCourage。Wegenerallydenotebythistermadispositiontofacedangerofanykindwithoutshrinking。Wesometimesalsocallthosewhobearpainunflinchinglycourageous:butthisqualityofcharacterwemorecommonlydistinguishasFortitude。Nowitseemsplainthatifweseekforadefinitionofstrictduty,ascommonlyrecognised,undertheheadeitherofCourageorofFortitude,wecanfindnonethatdoesnotinvolveareferencetoothermaximsandends。Fornoonewouldsaythatitisourdutytofacedangerortobearavoidablepaingenerally,butonlyifitmeetsusinthecourseofduty。Andeventhisneedsfurtherqualification:forasregardssuchdutiesasthosee。g。ofgeneralBenevolence,itwouldbecommonlyallowedthattheagent’spainanddangeraretobetakenintoaccountinpracticallydeterminingtheirextent:——itwouldbeheldthatwearenotboundtoendureanypainexceptforthepreventionofmanifestlygreaterpaintoanother,ortheattainmentofamoreimportantamountofpositivegood:nortorunanyrisk,unlessthechanceofadditionalbenefittobegainedforanotheroutweighsthecostandchanceoflosstoourselvesifwefail。IndeeditisdoubtfulwhetherthecommonestimateofthedutyofBenevolencecouldbesaidtoamountquitetothis。[2]
When,however,weconsiderCourageasanExcellenceratherthanaduty,itseemstoholdamoreindependentpositioninourmoralestimation。Andthisviewcorrespondsmorecompletelythantheothertothecommonapplicationofthenotion;astherearemanyactsofcourage,whicharenotaltogetherwithinthecontroloftheWill,andthereforecannotberegardedasstrictduties。For1dangerisfrequentlysuddenandneedstobemetwithoutdeliberation,sothatourmannerofmeetingitcanonlybesemi-voluntary。And2thoughnaturallytimidpersonscanperhapswitheffortcontrolfearastheycanangerorappetite,iftimebeallowedfordeliberation,andcanpreventitfromtakingeffectinderelictionofduty:stillthisresultisnotallthatisrequiredfortheperformanceofsuchcourageousactsasneedmorethanordinaryenergy——fortheenergyofthetimidvirtuousmanisliabletobeexhaustedintheefforttocontrolhisfear:e。g。inbattlehecanperhapsstandstilltobekilledaswellasthecourageousmanbutnotchargewiththesameimpetuosityorstrikewiththesamevigourandprecision。[3]