Butagain,ifthesejudgmentsarenotclearanddefinite,stilllessaretheyconsistent。Idonotnowmeanthatoneman’sestimateofthevalueofanykindofpleasuresdiffersfromanother’s:
forwehaveassumedeachsentientindividualtobethefinaljudgeofthepleasantnessandpainfulnessofhisownfeelings,andthereforethiskindofdiscrepancydoesnotaffectthevalidityofthejudgments,andcreatesnodifficultyuntilanyonetriestoappropriatetheexperienceofothers,ButImeanthateachindividual’sjudgmentofthecomparativevalueofhisownpleasuresisapttobedifferentatdifferenttimes,thoughitrelatestothesamepastexperiences;andthatthisvariationisalegitimategroundfordistrustingthevalidityofanyparticularcomparison。
Thecausesofthisvariationseemtobepartlyduetothenatureoftherepresentedfeeling,andpartlytothegeneralstateofthemindatthetimeofmakingtherepresentation。Tobeginwiththeformer:wefindthatdifferentkindsofpastpleasuresandpainsdonotequallyadmitofbeingrevivedinimagination。Thus,generallyspeaking,ourmoreemotionalandmorerepresentativepainsaremoreeasilyrevivedthanthemoresensationalandpresentative:forexample,itisatthismomentmuchmoreeasyformetoimaginethediscomfortofexpectancywhichprecededapastsea-sicknessthanthepainoftheactualnausea:althoughIinfer——fromtherecollectionofjudgmentspassedatthetime——thattheformerpainwastriflingcomparedwiththelatter。Tothiscauseitseemsduethatpasthardships,toils,andanxietiesoftenappearpleasurablewhenwelookbackuponthem,aftersomeinterval;fortheexcitement,theheightenedsenseoflifethataccompaniedthepainfulstruggle,wouldhavebeenpleasurableiftakenbyitself;anditisthisthatwerecallratherthanthepain。Inestimatingpleasurestheothercauseofvariationismoreconspicuous;weareconsciousofchangesoccasionalorperiodicinourestimateofthem,dependinguponchangesinourmentalorbodilycondition。E。g。itisamatterofcommonremarkwithrespecttothegratificationsofappetitethatwecannotestimatethemadequatelyinthestateofsatiety,andthatweareapttoexaggeratetheminthestateofdesire。Idonotdenythatintensityofantecedentdesireintensifiesthepleasureoffruition;
sothatthispleasurenotonlyappears,asPlatothought,butactuallyisgreaterowingtothestrengthofthedesirethathaspreceded。Stillitisamatterofcommonexperiencethatpleasureswhichhavebeenintenselydesiredareoftenfoundtodisappointexpectation。
Thereseemtobenospecialstatesofaversion,determinedbybodilycauses,andrelatedtocertainpainsasourappetitestotheircorrespondentpleasures;butmostpersonsareliabletobethrownbytheprospectofcertainpainsintothestateofpassionateaversionwhichwecallfear,andtobetherebyledtoestimatesuchpainsasworsethantheywouldbejudgedtobeinacalmermood。