Donotallowyourselvestobemisledbythecommonnotionthatanhypothesisisuntrustworthysimplybecauseitisanhypothesis。Itisoftenurged,inrespecttosomescientificconclusion,that,afterall,itisonlyanhypothesis。Butwhatmorehavewetoguideusinnine—tenthsofthemostimportantaffairsofdailylifethanhypotheses,andoftenveryill—basedones?Sothatinscience,wheretheevidenceofanhypothesisissubjectedtothemostrigidexamination,wemayrightlypursuethesamecourse。Youmayhavehypothesesandhypotheses。Amanmaysay,ifhelikes,thatthemoonismadeofgreencheese:thatisanhypothesis。Butanotherman,whohasdevotedagreatdealoftimeandattentiontothesubject,andavailedhimselfofthemostpowerfultelescopesandtheresultsoftheobservationsofothers,declaresthatinhisopinionitisprobablycomposedofmaterialsverysimilartothoseofwhichourownearthismadeup:andthatisalsoonlyanhypothesis。ButIneednottellyouthatthereisanenormousdifferenceinthevalueofthetwohypotheses。Thatonewhichisbasedonsoundscientificknowledgeissuretohaveacorrespondingvalue;andthatwhichisamerehastyrandomguessislikelytohavebutlittlevalue。EverygreatstepinourprogressindiscoveringcauseshasbeenmadeinexactlythesamewayasthatwhichI
havedetailedtoyou。Apersonobservingtheoccurrenceofcertainfactsandphenomenaasks,naturallyenough,whatprocess,whatkindofoperationknowntooccurinnatureappliedtotheparticularcase,willunravelandexplainthemystery?Henceyouhavethescientifichypothesis;anditsvaluewillbeproportionatetothecareandcompletenesswithwhichitsbasishadbeentestedandverified。Itisinthesemattersasinthecommonestaffairsofpracticallife:theguessofthefoolwillbefolly,whiletheguessofthewisemanwillcontainwisdom。Inallcases,youseethatthevalueoftheresultdependsonthepatienceandfaithfulnesswithwhichtheinvestigatorappliestohishypothesiseverypossiblekindofverification。
IdaresayImayhavetoreturntothispointby—and—by;buthavingdealtthusfarwithourlogicalmethods,Imustnowturntosomethingwhich,perhaps,youmayconsidermoreinteresting,or,atanyrate,moretangible。Butinrealitytherearebutfewthingsthatcanbemoreimportantforyoutounderstandthanthementalprocessesandthemeansbywhichweobtainscientificconclusionsandtheories。1Havinggrantedthattheinquiryisaproperone,andhavingdeterminedonthenatureofthemethodswearetopursueandwhichonlycanleadtosuccess,Imustnowturntotheconsiderationofourknowledgeofthenatureoftheprocesseswhichhaveresultedinthepresentconditionoforganicnature。
Here,letmesayatonce,lestsomeofyoumisunderstandme,thatIhaveextremelylittletoreport。Thequestionofhowthepresentconditionoforganicnaturecameabout,resolvesitselfintotwoquestions。Thefirstis:Howhasorganicorlivingmattercommenceditsexistence?Andthesecondis:Howhasitbeenperpetuated?OnthesecondquestionI
shallhavemoretosayhereafter。Butonthefirstone,whatInowhavetosaywillbeforthemostpartofanegativecharacter。