IcanturnandtwistasIwill,itisnotaquestionofthefacts。Myexistenceisundersuspicion,myinnermostbeing,myindividuality,isconsideredbad,anditisforthisopinionofmethatIampunished。ThelawpunishesmenotforanywrongIcommit,butforthewrongIdonotcommit。Iamreallybeingpunishedbecausemyactionisnotagainstthelaw,foronlybecauseofthatdoIcompelthelenient,well—meaningjudgetoseizeonmybadframeofmind,whichiscleverenoughnottocomeoutintheopen。
Thelawagainstaframeofmindisnotalawofthestatepromulgatedforitscitizens,butthelawofonepartyagainstanotherparty。Thelawwhichpunishestendencyabolishestheequalityofthecitizensbeforethelaw。Itisalawwhichdivides,notonewhichunites,andalllawswhichdividearereactionary。Itisnotalaw,butaprivilege。
Onemaydowhatanothermaynotdo,notbecausethelatterlackssomeobjectivequality,likeaminorinregardtoconcludingcontracts;no,becausehisgoodintentionsandhisframeofmindareundersuspicion。Themoralstateassumesitsmemberstohavetheframeofmindofthestate,eveniftheyactinoppositiontoanorganofthestate,againstthegovernment。Butinasocietyinwhichoneorganimaginesitselfthesole,exclusivepossessorofstatereasonandstatemorality,inagovernmentwhichopposesthepeopleinprincipleandhenceregardsitsanti—stateframeofmindasthegeneral,normalframeofmind,thebadconscienceofafactioninventslawsagainsttendency,lawsofrevenge,lawsagainstaframeofmindwhichhasitsseatonlyinthegovernmentmembersthemselves。Lawsagainstframeofmindarebasedonanunprincipledframeofmindonanimmoral,materialviewofthestate。
Theyaretheinvoluntarycryofabadconscience。Andhowisalawofthiskindtobeimplemented?Byameansmorerevoltingthanthelawitself:
byspies,orbypreviousagreementtoregardentireliterarytrendsassuspicious,inwhichcase,ofcourse,thetrendtowhichanindividualbelongsmustalsobeinquiredinto。Justasinthelawagainsttendencythelegalformcontradictsthecontent,justasthegovernmentwhichissuesitlashesoutagainstwhatitisitself,againsttheanti—stateframeofmind,soalsoineachparticularcaseitformsasitwerethereverseworldtoitslaws,foritappliesadoublemeasuring—rod。