Whateverelsemaybesaidofthiskindofdoctrine,itisatleastoriginalandhasaconclusivesound。MarkTwainhadverylittleusefororthodoxyandconservatism。WhenitwasannouncedthatDr。JacquesLoeb,oftheUniversityofCalifornia,haddemonstratedthecreationoflifebychemicalagencieshewasdeeplyinterested。Whenanewspaperwritercommentedthata\"consensusofopinionamongbiologists\"wouldprobablyrateDr。Loebasamanoflivelyimaginationratherthananinerrantinvestigatorofnaturalphenomena,hefeltcalledtochafftheconsensusidea。
IwishIcouldbeasyoungasthatagain。AlthoughIseemsooldnowIwasonceasyoungasthat。Iremember,asifitwerebutthirtyorfortyyearsago,howaparalyzingconsensusofopinionaccumulatedfromexpertsa—settingaroundaboutbrotherexpertswhohadpatientlyandlaboriouslycold—chiseledtheirwayintooneoranotherofnature’ssafe—depositvaultsandwerereportingthattheyhadfoundsomethingvaluablewasplentyforme。Itsettledit。
Butitisn’tsonow—no。BecauseinthedriftoftheyearsIbyandbyfoundoutthataConsensusexaminesanewthingwithitsfeelingsratheroftenerthanwithitsmind。
Therewasthatprimitivesteam—engine—agesback,inGreektimes:aConsensusmadefunofit。TherewastheMarquisofWorcester’ssteam—engine250yearsago:aConsensusmadefunofit。TherewasFulton’ssteamboatofacenturyago:aFrenchConsensus,includingthegreatNapoleon,madefunofit。TherewasPriestley,withhisoxygen:aConsensusscoffedathim,mobbedhim,burnedhimout,banishedhim。WhileaConsensuswasproving,bystatisticsandthings,thatasteamshipcouldnotcrosstheAtlantic,asteamshipdidit。
Andsoonthroughadozenpagesormoreoflivelysatire,endingwithanextractfromAdam’sDiary。