ForsuperbengravingsshowingtheviewofBabelasdevelopedbythetheologicalimagination,seeKircher,TurrisBabel,Amsterdam,1679。FortheLawofWillsandCauses,withdeductionsfromitwellstated,seeBeattieCrozier,CivilizationandProgress,London,1888,pp。112,178,179,273。ForPlato,seethePoliticus,p。272,ed。Stephani,citedinErschandGruber,articleBabylon。Foragoodgeneralstatement,seeBibleMyths,NewYork,1883,chap。iii。ForAristotle’sstrangewantofinterestinanyclassificationofthevarietiesofhumanspeech,seeMaxMuller,LecturesontheScienceofLanguage,London,1864,seriesi,chap。iv,pp。123-125。
ButnaturallytheversionofthelegendwhichmostaffectedChristendomwasthatmodificationoftheChaldeanformdevelopedamongtheJewsandembodiedintheirsacredbooks。Toathinkingmaninthesedaysitisveryinstructive。ThecomingdownoftheAlmightyfromheaventoseethetowerandputanendtoitbydispersingitsbuilders,pointstothetimewhenhisdwellingwassupposedtobejustabovethefirmamentorsolidvaultabovetheearth:thetimewhenheexercisedhisbeneficentactivityinsuchactsasopening“thewindowsofheaven“togivedownrainupontheearth;inbringingoutthesuneverydayandhangingupthestarseverynighttogivelighttotheearth;inhurlingcomets,togivewarning;inplacinghisbowinthecloud,togivehope;in,comingdowninthecooloftheeveningtowalkandtalkwiththemanhehadmade;inmakingcoatsofskinsforAdamandEve;inenjoyingtheodouroffleshwhichNoahburnedforhim;ineatingwithAbrahamundertheoaksofMamre;inwrestlingwithJacob;andinwritingwithhisownfingeronthestonetablesforMoses。
Socametheanswertothethirdquestionregardinglanguage;andallthreeanswers,embodiedinoursacredbooksandimplantedintheJewishmind,suppliedtotheChristianChurchthegermsofatheologicaldevelopmentofphilology。ThesegermsdevelopedrapidlyinthewarmatmosphereofdevotionandignoranceofnaturallawwhichpervadedtheearlyChurch,andtheregrewagreatorthodoxtheoryoflanguage,whichwasheldthroughoutChristendom,“always,everywhere,andbyall。”fornearlytwothousandyears,andtowhich,untilthepresentcentury,allsciencehasbeenobliged,underpainsandpenalties,toconform。
Theredid,indeed,comeintohumanthoughtatanearlyperiodsomesuggestionsofthemodernscientificviewofphilology。
Lucretiushadproposedatheory,inadequateindeed,butstillpointingtowardthetruth,asfollows:“Natureimpelledmantotrythevarioussoundsofthetongue,andsostruckoutthenamesofthings,muchinthesamewayastheinabilitytospeakisseeninitsturntodrivechildrentotheuseofgestures。”But,amongtheearlyfathersoftheChurch,theonlyonewhoseemstohavecaughtanechoofthisutterancewasSt。GregoryofNyssa: