Villainage in England

第60章

试读中

第60章

Villainage in England Paul Vinogradoff

后面的故事,去 App 接着看,下载后搜索书名即可继续阅读。

Villainage in England
阅读主题
字体大小

  Nowthisisbynomeansatriflefromthepointofviewoflegalanalysis。Thegrandandpettyjuriesofthecommonlawaremeansofinformation,andnothingmore。Theyformnopartofthetribunal,strictlyspeaking;thecourtisconstitutedbythejudges,thelawyerscommissionedbytheking,whoadoptthismethodininvestigatingthefactsbeforethem,becauseaknowledgeofthefactsatissue,andanunderstandingoflocalconditionssurroundingthem,issupposedtoresidenaturallyinthecountrywherethefactshavetakenplace。54*Historicallytheinstitutionisevolvedfromexaminationsofwitnessesandexperts,andhasbranchedoffinFranceintothecloseformalismofinquisitorialprocess。Themanorialjury,ontheotherhand,representsthecourt,andinterchangeswithit。55*Forthisreason,wemayspeakdirectlyofthecourtinsteadoftreatingofitsdelegates。Andiftheverdictofthecourtistaken,itisnotonaccountofthechanceknowledge,thepresumableacquaintanceofthesuitorswithfactsandconditions,butasalivingremembranceofwhattookplacebeforethissamecourt,orasare-assertionofitspowerofregulatingthelegalstandingofthecommunity。Theverdictofthesuitorsisonlyanotherformoftheentryontherolls,andbotharemeansofsecuringthecontinuityofaninstitutionandnotmerelyofprovidinginformationtooutsiders。Ofcourse,claimsmaynotbealwaysreducedtosuchelementaryformsthattheycanbedecidedbyamerereferencetomemory,thememoryoftheconstitutedbodyofthecourt。Acertainamountofreasoningandinferencemaybeinvolvedintheirsettlement,asetofjuridicaldoctrinesisnecessarytoprovidethegeneralprinciplesofsuchreasoning。

  Andinbothrespectsthemanorialcourtiscalledupontoact。Itisconsideredastherepositaryoflegallore,andtheexponentofitsapplications。Thismeansthatthecourtis,whatitsnameimplies,atribunalandnotasetofprivatepersonscalledupontoassistajudgebytheirknowledgeoflegaldetailsormaterialfacts。56*

  Thewholeexpositionbringsusbacktoapointofprimaryimportance。Thetitlebywhichlandisheldaccordingtomanorialcustomisderivedfromcommunalauthorityquiteasmuchasfromthelord’sgrant。Withoutsteppingoutofthefeudalevidenceintohistoricalinquiry,wefindthatcivilarrangementsofthepeasantryarebasedonactsperformedthroughtheagencyofthesteward,andbeforethemanorialcourt,whichhasavoiceinthematterandvouchesforitsvalidityandremembrance。The’fullcourt’isnoticedintherecordsasquiteasnecessaryanelementintheconveyancingbusinessasthelordandhissteward,althoughthelegal。theoryofmoderntimeshasaffectedtotakeintoaccountonlytheselatter。57*Indeed,itisthepartassumedbythecourtwhichappearsasthedistinctive,ifnotthemoreimportantfactor。Afeoffmentoflandmadeonthebasisoffreetenureproceedsfromthegrantorinthesamewayasagrantontheconditionsofbasetenure;freeholdcomesfromthelord,aswellascopyhold。Butcopyholdisnecessarilytransferredincourt,whilefreeholdisnot。Andifwespeakofthepresentmentofoffencesthroughtherepresentativesoftownships,asofthepracticeofcommunalaccusation,evensowehavetocallthetitlebywhichcopyholdtenureiscreatedaclaimbasedoncommunaltestimony。

  Allthepointsnoticedintherollsofmanorsheldatcommonlawaretobefoundonthesoilofancientdemesne,buttheyarestatedmoredefinitelythere,andtherightsofthepeasantpopulationareassertedwithgreaterenergy。Ourpreviousanalysisoftheconditionofancientdemesnehasledustotheconclusion,thatitpresentsacrystallisationofthemanorialcommunityinanearlierstageofdevelopmentthanintheordinarymanor,butthattheconstitutiveelementsinbothcasesareexactlythesame。Forthisreason,everyquestionarisinginregardtotheusualarrangementsoughttobeexaminedinthelightoftheevidencethatcomesfromtheancientdemesne。

  Wehaveseenthatitwouldbeimpossibletomaintainthatoriginallythestewardwastheonlyjudgeofthemanorialtribunal;thewholecourtwithitsfreeandunfreesuitorsparticipatesmateriallyintheadministrationofjustice,anditsofficeisextendedtoquestionsoflawaswellastoissuesoffact。Ontheotherhand,itwasclearthatthestewardandthelordwerealreadypreparingthepositionwhichtheyultimatelyassumedinlegaltheory,thatintheexerciseoftheirfunctionstheywerebeginningtomonopolisethepowerofultimatedecisionandtorestrictthecourttothedutyofpreliminarypresentment。

后续内容在 App 继续看

精彩内容未完,打开 App 继续阅读

后面的故事已为你准备好,下载 App 后搜索“Villainage in England”即可继续阅读这一章。