Wilson,afterbeingelectedPresident,withinthefirstfortnightafterhehasbeeninauguratedintothathighoffice,permitshimselftobebetrayedintoapublicmisstatementofwhatIhavesaid,andwhatIstandfor,thenheforcesmetocorrecthisstatements。
Mr。WilsonopenshisarticlebysayingthattheProgressive“doctrineisthatmonopolyisinevitable,andthattheonlycourseopentothepeopleoftheUnitedStatesistosubmittoit。”Thisstatementiswithoutoneparticleoffoundationinfact。IchallengehimtopointoutasentenceintheProgressiveplatformorinanyspeechofminewhichbearshimout。Icanpointhimoutanynumberwhichflatlycontradicthim。Wehavenevermadeanysuchstatementasheallegesaboutmonopolies。Wehavesaid:“Thecorporationisanessentialpartofmodernbusiness。Theconcentrationofmodernbusiness,insomedegree,isbothinevitableandnecessaryforNationalandinternationalbusinessefficiency。”DoesMr。Wilsondenythis?Lethimansweryesorno,directly。Itiseasyforapoliticiandetectedinamisstatementtotakerefugeinevasiverhetoricalhyperbole。ButMr。
WilsonisPresidentoftheUnitedStates,andassuchheisboundtocandidutteranceoneverysubjectofpublicinterestwhichhehimselfhasbroached。Ifhedisagreeswithus,lethimbefrankandconsistent,andrecommendtoCongressthatallcorporationsbemadeillegal。Mr。Wilson’swholeattackislargelybasedonadeftbutfarfromingenuousconfoundingofwhatwehavesaidofmonopoly,whichweproposesofaraspossibletoabolish,andwhatwehavesaidofbigcorporations,whichweproposetoregulate;Mr。Wilson’sownvaguelysetforthproposalsbeingtoattemptthedestructionofbothinwaysthatwouldharmneither。Inourplatformweusetheword“monopoly“
butonce,andthenwespeakofitasanabuseofpower,couplingitwithstock-watering,unfaircompetitionandunfairprivileges。DoesMr。Wilsondenythis?Ifhedoes,thenwhereelsewillheassertthatwespeakofmonopolyashesayswedo?HecertainlyowesthepeopleoftheUnitedStatesaplainanswertothequestion。InmyspeechofacceptanceIsaid:“WefavorstrengtheningtheShermanLawbyprohibitingagreementstodivideterritoryorlimitoutput;refusingtoselltocustomerswhobuyfrombusinessrivals;tosellbelowcostincertainareaswhilemaintaininghigherpricesinotherplaces;
usingthepoweroftransportationtoaidorinjurespecialbusinessconcerns;andallotherunfairtradepractices。”Theplatformpledgesusto“guardandkeepopenequallytoall,thehighwaysofAmericancommerce。”Thisistheexactnegationofmonopoly。UnlessMr。Wilsonispreparedtoshowthecontrary,surelyheisboundinhonortoadmitfranklythathehasbeenbetrayedintoamisrepresentation,andtocorrectit。