ANTI-DuRING

第4章

试读中

第4章

ANTI-DuRING Friedrich Engels, Clemens Palm

后面的故事,去 App 接着看,下载后搜索书名即可继续阅读。

ANTI-DuRING
阅读主题
字体大小

  Forthatmatter,thereisabsolutelynoneedtobealarmedatthefactthatthestageofknowledgewhichwehavenowreachedisaslittlefinalasallthathaveprecededit。Italreadyembracesavastmassofjudgmentsandrequiresverygreatspecialisationofstudyonthepartofanyonewhowantstobecomeconversantwithanyparticularscience。Butamanwhoappliesthemeasureofgenuine,immutable,finalandultimatetruthtoknowledgewhich,byitsverynature,musteitherremainrelativeformanygenerationsandbecompletedonlystepbystep,orwhich,asincosmogony,geologyandthehistoryofmankind,mustalwayscontaingapsandbeincompletebecauseoftheinadequacyofthehistoricalmaterial——suchamanonlyprovestherebyhisownignoranceandperversity,eveniftherealthingbehinditallisnot,asinthiscase,theclaimtopersonalinfallibility。Truthanderror,likeallthought-conceptswhichmoveinpolaropposites,haveabsolutevalidityonlyinanextremelylimitedfield,aswehavejustseen,andasevenHerrDühringwouldrealiseifhehadanyacquaintancewiththefirstelementsofdialectics,whichdealpreciselywiththeinadequacyofallpolaropposites。Assoonasweapplytheantithesisbetweentruthanderroroutsideofthatnarrowfieldwhichhasbeenreferredtoaboveitbecomesrelativeandthereforeunserviceableforexactscientificmodesofexpression,andifweattempttoapplyitasabsolutelyvalidoutsidethatfieldwereallyfindourselvesaltogetherbeaten:bothpolesoftheantithesisbecometransformedintotheiropposites,truthbecomeserroranderrortruth。Letustakeasanexamplethewell-knownBoyle’slaw。Accordingtoit,ifthetemperatureremainsconstant,thevolumeofagasvariesinverselywiththepressuretowhichitissubjected。

  Regnaultfoundthatthislawdoesnotholdgoodincertaincases。Hadhebeenaphilosopherofrealityhewouldhavehadtosay:Boyle’slawismutable,andishencenotagenuinetruth,henceitisnotatruthatall,henceitisanerror。ButhadhedonethishewouldhavecommittedanerrorfargreaterthantheonethatwascontainedinBoyle’slaw;hisgrainoftruthwouldhavebeenlostsightofinasand-hilloferror;hewouldhavedistortedhisoriginallycorrectconclusionintoanerrorcomparedwithwhichBoyle’slaw,alongwiththelittleparticleoferrorthatclingstoitwouldhaveseemedliketruth。ButRegnault,beingamanofscience,didnotindulgeinsuchchildishness,butcontinuedhisinvestigationsanddiscoveredthatingeneralBoyle’slawisonlyapproximatelytrue,andinparticularlosesitsvalidityinthecaseofgaseswhichcanbeliquefiedbypressure,namely,assoonasthepressureapproachesthepointatwhichliquefactionbegins。Boyle’slawthereforewasprovedtobetrueonlywithindefinitelimits。Butisitabsolutelyandfinallytruewithinthoselimits?Nophysicistwouldassertthat。Hewouldmaintainthatitholdsgoodwithincertainlimitsofpressureandtemperatureandforcertaingases;andevenwithinthesemorerestrictedlimitshewouldnotexcludethepossibilityofastillnarrowerlimitationoralteredformulationastheresultoffutureinvestigations。*2Thisishowthingsstandwithfinalandultimatetruthsinphysics,forexample。

  Reallyscientificworkstherefore,asarule,avoidsuchdogmaticallymoralexpressionsaserrorandtruth,whiletheseexpressionsmeetuseverywhereinworkssuchasthephilosophyofreality,inwhichemptyphrasemongeringattemptstoimposeitselfonusasthemostsovereignresultofsovereignthought。

  But,anaivereadermayask,wherehasHerrDühringexpresslystatedthatthecontentofhisphilosophyofrealityisfinalandevenultimatetruth{D。Ph。2}?Where?Well,forexample,inthedithyrambonhissystempage13,apartofwhichwecitedinChapterII。Orwhenhesays,inthepassagequotedabove:Moraltruths,insofarastheirultimatebasesareunderstood,claimthesamevalidityasmathematicalinsights。

  AnddoesnotHerrDühringassertthat,workingfromhisreallycriticalstandpoint{D。Ph。404}andbymeansofthoseresearchesofhiswhichgototherootofthings{200},hehasforcedhiswaythroughtotheseultimatefoundations,thebasicschemata,andhasthusbestowedfinalandultimatevalidityonmoraltruths?Or,ifHerrDühringdoesnotadvancethisclaimeitherforhimselforforhisage,ifheonlymeanttosaythatperhapssomedayinthedarkandnebulousfuturefinalandultimatetruthsmaybeascertained,ifthereforehemeanttosaymuchthesame,onlyinamoreconfusedway,asissaidby“mordantscepticism“and“hopelessconfusion“

后续内容在 App 继续看

精彩内容未完,打开 App 继续阅读

后面的故事已为你准备好,下载 App 后搜索“ANTI-DuRING”即可继续阅读这一章。