IfIwishtoprovethatthesoulisarealbeing,someonestopsmebytellingmethatitisafaculty。IfIassertthatitisafaculty,andthatIhavethefacultyofthinking,IamtoldthatIammistaken。thatGod,theeternalmasterofallnature,doeseverythinginme,anddirectsallmyactionsandallmythoughts。thatifIproducedmythoughts,IshouldknowthethoughtIwillhaveinaminute。thatIneverknowit。thatI
amonlyanautomatonwithsensationsandideas,necessarilydependent,andinthehandsoftheSupremeBeing,infinitelymorecomplianttoHimthanclayistothepotter。
Iconfessmyignorance,therefore。Iavowthatfourthousandtomesofmetaphysicswillnotteachuswhatoursoulis。
Anorthodoxphilosophersaidtoaheterodoxphilosopher——Howhaveyoubeenabletocometothepointofimaginingthatthesoulismortalbynature,andeternalonlybythepurewishofGod?
Bymyownexperience,saidtheother。