Asnewcharacterssometimesappearbybud—variation,whichdonotoccurintheparent—speciesorinanyalliedspecies,wemayreject,atleastinthesecases,theideathattheyareduetoreversion。Nowitiswellworthwhiletoreflectmaturelyonsomestrikingcaseofbud—variation,forinstancethatofthepeach。Thistreehasbeencultivatedbythemillioninvariouspartsoftheworld,hasbeentreateddifferently,grownonitsownrootsandgraftedonvariousstocks,plantedasastandard,trainedagainstawall,orunderglass;
yeteachbudofeachsub—varietykeepstruetoitskind。Butoccasionally,atlongintervalsoftime,atreeinEngland,orunderthewidelydifferentclimateofVirginia,producesasinglebud,andthisyieldsabranchwhicheverafterwardsbearsnectarines。Nectarinesdiffer,aseveryoneknows,frompeachesintheirsmoothness,size,andflavour;andthedifferenceissogreatthatsomebotanistshavemaintainedthattheyarespecificallydistinct。Sopermanentarethecharactersthussuddenlyacquired,thatanectarineproducedbybud—variationhaspropagateditselfbyseed。Toguardagainstthesuppositionthatthereissomefundamentaldistinctionbetweenbudandseminalvariation,itiswelltobearinmindthatnectarineshavelikewisebeenproducedfromthestoneofthepeach;and,reversely,peachesfromthestoneofthenectarine。Nowisitpossibletoconceiveexternalconditionsmorecloselyalikethanthosetowhichthebudsonthesametreeareexposed?Yetonebudalone,outofthemanythousandsbornebythesametree,hassuddenly,withoutanyapparentcause,producedanectarine。Butthecaseisevenstrongerthanthis,forthesameflower—budhasyieldedafruit,one—halforone—quarteranectarine,andtheotherhalforthree—quartersapeach。Again,sevenoreightvarietiesofthepeachhaveyieldedbybud—variationnectarines:thenectarinesthusproduced,nodoubt,differalittlefromoneanother;butstilltheyarenectarines。Ofcoursetheremustbesomecause,internalorexternal,toexcitethepeach—budtochangeitsnature;butI
cannotimagineaclassoffactsbetteradaptedtoforceonourmindstheconvictionthatwhatwecalltheexternalconditionsoflifeareinmanycasesquiteinsignificantinrelationtoanyparticularvariation,incomparisonwiththeorganisationorconstitutionofthebeingwhichvaries。
ItisknownfromthelaboursofGeoffroySaint—Hilaire,andrecentlyfromthoseofDaresteandothers,thateggsofthefowl,ifshaken,placedupright,perforated,coveredinpartwithvarnish,etc。,producemonstrouschickens。
Nowthesemonstrositiesmaybesaidtobedirectlycausedbysuchunnaturalconditions,butthemodificationsthusinducedarenotofadefinitenature。