WhenIarrivedforthefirsttimeatNewYork,bythatpartoftheAtlanticOceanwhichiscalledtheNarrows,Iwassurprisedtoperceivealongtheshore,atsomedistancefromthecity,aconsiderablenumberoflittlepalacesofwhitemarble,severalofwhichwerebuiltafterthemodelsofancientarchitecture。WhenIwentthenextdaytoinspectmorecloselythebuildingwhichhadparticularlyattractedmynotice,Ifoundthatitswallswereofwhitewashedbrick,anditscolumnsofpaintedwood。AlltheedificeswhichIhadadmiredthenightbeforewereofthesamekind。
Thesocialconditionandtheinstitutionsofdemocracyimpart,moreover,certainpeculiartendenciestoalltheimitativearts,whichitiseasytopointout。Theyfrequentlywithdrawthemfromthedelineationofthesoultofixthemexclusivelyonthatofthebody:andtheysubstitutetherepresentationofmotionandsensationforthatofsentimentandthought:inaword,theyputtherealintheplaceoftheideal。
IdoubtwhetherRaphaelstudiedtheminutestintricaciesofthemechanismofthehumanbodyasthoroughlyasthedraughtsmenofourowntime。Hedidnotattachthesameimportancetorigorousaccuracyonthispointastheydo,becauseheaspiredtosurpassnature。Hesoughttomakeofmansomethingwhichshouldbesuperiortoman,andtoembellishbeauty’sself。Davidandhisscholarswere,onthecontrary,asgoodanatomistsastheyweregoodpainters。Theywonderfullydepictedthemodelswhichtheyhadbeforetheireyes,buttheyrarelyimaginedanythingbeyondthem:theyfollowednaturewithfidelity:whilstRaphaelsoughtforsomethingbetterthannature。Theyhaveleftusanexactportraitureofman;buthedisclosesinhisworksaglimpseoftheDivinity。Thisremarkastothemanneroftreatingasubjectisnolessapplicabletothechoiceofit。ThepaintersoftheMiddleAgesgenerallysoughtfarabovethemselves,andawayfromtheirowntime,formightysubjects,whichlefttotheirimaginationanunboundedrange。Ourpaintersfrequentlyemploytheirtalentsintheexactimitationofthedetailsofprivatelife,whichtheyhavealwaysbeforetheireyes;andtheyareforevercopyingtrivialobjects,theoriginalsofwhichareonlytooabundantinnature。
ChapterXII:WhyTheAmericansRaiseSomeMonumentsSoInsignificant,AndOthersSoImportantIhavejustobserved,thatindemocraticagesmonumentsoftheartstendtobecomemorenumerousandlessimportant。Inowhastentopointouttheexceptiontothisrule。Inademocraticcommunityindividualsareverypowerless;buttheStatewhichrepresentsthemall,andcontainsthemallinitsgrasp,isverypowerful。Nowheredocitizensappearsoinsignificantasinademocraticnation;nowheredoesthenationitselfappeargreater,ordoesthemindmoreeasilytakeinawidegeneralsurveyofit。
Indemocraticcommunitiestheimaginationiscompressedwhenmenconsiderthemselves;itexpandsindefinitelywhentheythinkoftheState。Henceitisthatthesamemenwholiveonasmallscaleinnarrowdwellings,frequentlyaspiretogiganticsplendorintheerectionoftheirpublicmonuments。