Whatevermeritamanmayhavethoughttherewouldbeinmakinghimselfmiserable,nosuchnotionseemsevertohaveoccurredtoanyofthem,thatitmaybeamerit,muchlessaduty,tomakeothersmiserable:althoughitshouldseem,thatifacertainquantityofmiserywereathingsodesirable,itwouldnotmattermuchwhetheritwerebroughtbyeachmanuponhimself,orbyonemanuponanother。Itistrue,thatfromthesamesourcefromwhence,amongthereligionists,theattachmenttotheprincipleofasceticismtookitsrise,flowedotherdoctrinesandpractices,fromwhichmiseryinabundancewasproducedinonemanbytheinstrumentalityofanother:witnesstheholywars,andthepersecutionsforreligion。Butthepassionforproducingmiseryinthesecasesproceededuponsomespecialground:theexerciseofitwasconfinedtopersonsofparticulardescriptions:
theyweretormented,notasmen,butashereticsandinfidels。Tohaveinflictedthesamemiseriesontheirfellowbelieversandfellow-sectaries,wouldhavebeenasblameableintheeyesevenofthesereligionists,asinthoseofapartizanoftheprincipleofutility。Foramantogivehimselfacertainnumberofstripeswasindeedmeritorious:buttogivethesamenumberofstripestoanotherman,notconsenting,wouldhavebeenasin。Wereadofsaints,whoforthegoodoftheirsouls,andthemortificationoftheirbodies,havevoluntarilyyieldedthemselvesapreytovermin:butthoughmanypersonsofthisclasshavewieldedthereinsofempire,wereadofnonewhohavesetthemselvestowork,andmadelawsonpurpose,withaviewofstockingthebodypoliticwiththebreedofhighwaymen,housebreakers,orincendiaries。Ifatanytimetheyhavesufferedthenationtobepreyeduponbyswarmsofidlepensioners,oruselessplacemen,ithasratherbeenfromnegligenceandimbecility,thanfromanysettledplanforoppressingandplunderingofthepeople。Ifatanytimetheyhavesappedthesourcesofnationalwealth,bycrampingcommerce,anddrivingtheinhabitantsintoemigration,ithasbeenwithotherviews,andinpursuitofotherends。Iftheyhavedeclaimedagainstthepursuitofpleasure,andtheuseofwealth,theyhavecommonlystoppedatdeclamation:theyhavenot,likeLycurgus,madeexpressordinancesforthepurposeofbanishingthepreciousmetals。Iftheyhaveestablishedidlenessbyalaw,ithasbeennotbecauseidleness,themotherofviceandmisery,isitselfavirtue,butbecauseidlenesssaytheyistheroadtoholiness。Ifunderthenotionoffasting,theyhavejoinedintheplanofconfiningtheirsubjectstoadiet,thoughtbysometobeofthemostnourishingandprolificnature,ithasbeennotforthesakeofmakingthemtributariestothenationsbywhomthatdietwastobesupplied,butforthesakeofmanifestingtheirownpower,andexercisingtheobedienceofthepeople。Iftheyhaveestablished,orsufferedtobeestablished,punishmentsforthebreachofcelibacy,theyhavedonenomorethancomplywiththepetitionsofthosedeludedrigorists,who,dupestotheambitiousanddeep-laidpolicyoftheirrulers,firstlaidthemselvesunderthatidleobligationbyavow。
IX。Theprincipleofasceticismseemsoriginallytohavebeenthereverieofcertainhastyspeculators,whohavingperceived,orfancied,thatcertainpleasures,whenreapedincertaincircumstances,have,atthelongrun,beenattendedwithpainsmorethanequivalenttothem,tookoccasiontoquarrelwitheverythingthatoffereditselfunderthenameofpleasure。Havingthengotthusfar,andhavingforgotthepointwhichtheysetoutfrom,theypushedon,andwentsomuchfurtherastothinkitmeritorioustofallinlovewithpain。Eventhis,wesee,isatbottombuttheprincipleofutilitymisapplied。
X。Theprincipleofutilityiscapableofbeingconsistentlypursued;
anditisbuttautologytosay,thatthemoreconsistentlyitispursued,thebetteritmusteverbeforhuman-kind。Theprincipleofasceticismneverwas,norevercanbe,consistentlypursuedbyanylivingcreature。Letbutonetenthpartoftheinhabitantsofthisearthpursueitconsistently,andinaday\'stimetheywillhaveturneditintoahell。